3 ms·
This write-up is pretty confusing, because it doesn't address the actual legal issue or what happened in the court system earlier. That's covered in the actual
by rayiner 4y ago
This write-up is pretty confusing, because it doesn't address the actual legal issue or what happened in the court system earlier. That's covered in the actual petition: https://ij.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/Cert-Petition_FINAL.pdf https://ij.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/Cert-Petition_FINA..., and the decision the first time this case was before the Supreme Court: https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/20pdf/19-546_7mip.pdf https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/20pdf/19-546_7mip.pdf
The Question Presented is:
> This case returns after remand from Brownback v. King, 141 S. Ct. 740 (2021), where this Court flagged for future review the question presented:
> Whether the Federal Tort Claims Act’s judgment bar, 28 U.S.C. 2676, which this Court has repeatedly said functions in much the same way as the common- law doctrine of res judicata, nevertheless operates to bar claims brought together in the same action.
The actual question before the Supreme Court is an odd procedural issue. King sued the police officers, raising FTCA and Bivens claims for constitutional violations. The district court dismissed both claims. King appealed only the Bivens claims to the Sixth Circuit, which found that the officers did not have immunity under federal law and allowed that claim to proceed.
Back in the district court, however, the government invoked Section 2676, a provision of the FTCA that bars subsequent litigation involving the same facts after a decision on the FTCA claim. The government argued that the unappealed dismissal of the FTCA claim barred the Bivens claims from proceeding.
The first time around, the Supreme Court held that the FTCA's judgment bar could be triggered by a dismissal (for weird reasons specific to the FTCA), but left the question open as to whether the bar could apply to another claim in the same action. (In this case, whether dismissal of the FTCA claim could bar the Bivens claim.) The Sixth Circuit decided that the section 2676 bar could apply to other claims brought in the same action. So now King is seeking to have the Supreme Court decide that question.