7 ms·
"The officers never identified themselves as law enforcement to James, and bystanders who witnessed the beating were equally in the dark, calling 911 to report
by giantg2 4y ago
"The officers never identified themselves as law enforcement to James, and bystanders who witnessed the beating were equally in the dark, calling 911 to report what they believed to be an attempted murder in broad daylight."
Sounds like the officers got lucky. Plain clothes, not identifying themselves, onlookers thinking it's attempted murder... in some parts of the country that will get you shot.
- soco 4y agoMaybe it also depends on the skin of the attackers. But even without it, I'm still baffled (as many other commenters here) by the holy statute of the police in the States. They're no lambs in other places either, for sure, and they will also fight tooth and nail against any accusations of wrongdoing, but there's still a huge difference...
- ssalka 4y agoMost of the time, when officers do this, they get paid vacation.
- wing-_-nuts 4y agoThis reminds me of when people were being rounded up and shoved into white panel vans by people who refused to identify themselves during the portland protests. If an officer refuses to identify themselves, it's not a lawful arrest, it's a kidnapping. I argued at the time that someone would be entirely within their rights to defend themselves in this circumstance. No doubt the DA would press charges but do you really think a jury would convict?
- notch898a 4y agoThe people doing that were CBP deployed in Portland under statutory authorization passed in the wake of 9/11. CBP are a federal police force who aren't required to follow the constitution within 100 miles of the border (so no need to follow constitution in portland) and any case would go to federal courts where 99% of cases end up in plea deal.
- giantg2 4y ago"but do you really think a jury would convict?" I have no doubt they would (assuming survival).
- vkou 4y ago> but do you really think a jury would convict? Would you bet your life on it? Or on the officers in question not gunning you down for your troubles?
- wing-_-nuts 4y agoBear in mind the alternative here are letting a group of unidentified randos throw you into an unmarked van. You're already betting your life on it.
- vkou 4y agoGetting kidnapped by US police is one of the few kidnapping situations where you are vastly better off not trying to fight. They have no problem with turning you into a corpse on the street, but, unlike your run-of-the-mill serial killer are probably not kidnapping you so they can turn you into one in their murder basement.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- notch898a 4y agoYou have to know who is kidnapping you first though. I don't think most people would be able to figure it out in time when a bunch of camouflaged federal police jump out of an unmarked van. You've got maybe a second at best to make the decision, and if you've done nothing wrong the idea some unmarked federal police force you've never seen before is going to snatch you up is probably not even in the realm of your imagination, thus it must be criminal kidnappers.
- soco 4y agoOnce again for clarity: you just don't know they are police.
- trasz3 4y agoIn a properly working law system those officers getting shot and killed by bystanders could solve the problem by making the police think twice. Of course it won’t work in this case.
- ryathal 4y agoIf the officers were shot and killed then others would just hunt down and murder the innocent bystander that did the shooting, and probably hurt a few more for good measure. Any threat real or imagined against police is not tolerated in the US and the police will retaliate when necessary to enforce that.