8 ms·
South Korea has the lowest fertility rate, which has lessons for us all
- TheMoonToMyLeft 4y ago[flagged]
- nine_zeros 4y agoWe keep reading these articles which raise alarm. Then we see responses that range from good for the planet to apocalypse. Are there S. Koreans on this forum who can contribute their anecdotal experience with declining population?
- chupasaurus 4y ago> we see responses that range from good for the planet to apocalypse. That's because logistic map is a known source of chaos.
- yeknoda 4y agoFor now. Over time, low fertility families will die, their genetic and cultural material will disappear, and the remaining human population will be dominated by high fertility families. There are extremely strong feedback mechanisms that play out pretty quick. Survivors survive!
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI think this attitude is a little bit simplistic. It doesn't address what that time frame would be or what happens in the interim. When you say pretty quick is that 5 years or 500 years? While I agree there are some strong feedback mechanisms that lead to population growth, stating that alone ignores the fact that there are even stronger forcing mechanisms in the present pushing population down. The outcome will depend on how those extremely strong feedback mechanisms on both sides interact moving forward. The modern world has yet to see a population where growth rates have bounced back, and some countries like Japan have been declining for more than 50 years.
- MadSudaca 4y agoMaybe in the new generation the same % of people will decide to not have kids and populations in developed countries will continue shrinking geometrically maintaining the present trend. This line of reasoning is very interesting to ponder though. The black plague in Europe made survivors materially richer as they were able to take possession of what was left behind from the deceased. As there's less and less people to compete for stuff, the existing younger populations will be richer, thus giving them an incentive to focus on leisure and reproduction. Then there would be a cycle were the sharp decline in population, plants the seeds for the next big rise.
- ssnistfajen 4y agoCurrently high fertility families are concentrated on the two extreme ends of the wealth spectrum, the ultra-rich and the ultra-poor. That's not a great sign for human society's already dreadful wealth inequality.
- xiphias2 4y ago,,For Ryu, she said having children is not worth sacrificing her career. "The reality is that one of the parents has to resign from work or take a long break, but the problem is, it's almost always the female or the mom who has to take a leave," she said This was always like that, having a kid means very serious sacrifice in other parts of life (for example for women it's selecting a less attractive partner in exchange for higher stability, for men it's stopping changing partners and putting all resources into one family). Maybe one thing that changed is the lie that we are all special and we can have it all (I thought the same in my 20s).
- kodyo 4y agoHanging put with her coworkers as she ages out of the dating pool will surely be fulfilling.
- ssnistfajen 4y agoContemporary expections for personal careers and the mode of modern work is fundamentally hostile to people/families having children. Legally mandating parental leaves aren't going to stop private sector businesses from subtly discriminating against new parents, and parents' work-life balance is tilted towards children for at least the first decade after childbirth.
- red-iron-pine 4y agoSubtle discrimination is still discrimination and can be litigated against. Furthermore, extending child leave to both parents has done a lot to help fight stigma in Scandinavian countries. As has well funded, affordable child care for workers. Salaries in Montreal are garbage, but I'd consider working there because child care is heavily subsidized and very good. The break even tilts towards the rest of Canada at my pay-grade, but only just.
- antisthenes 4y ago> This was always like that, having a kid means very serious sacrifice in other parts of life (for example for women it's selecting a less attractive partner in exchange for higher stability What in the hell did I just read? Women selecting a financially stable, less attractive partner is a "sacrifice" these days? Same thing for men, sticking to providing just for your family is "sacrifice"? Jesus, did the neo-cultural values really did get shoved so far down people's throats that having a normal family is considered a sacrifice/abnormal?
- alexb_ 4y agoWhat exactly is the problem with a declining population anyways? It feels like if you have less people in your country, the resources within can be better distributed. What is the downside here - that if we have less children and less immigration, we are going to have cheaper food, cheaper housing, cheaper energy, and less poverty? Seems like a good thing to me.
- aNoob7000 4y agoIf I'm not wrong, the issue is with funding government programs. Most government programs are funded by taxes and if the populations is dropping then naturally the tax base is shrinking.
- alexb_ 4y agoThe expenses would also start shrinking though.
- aNoob7000 4y agoDepends on the expense. For example with Social Security, part of the problem we have now is that there are less people paying into the program then in the past. I only see two options, increase taxes or push back retirement.
- rs999gti 4y ago> push back retirement Which leads to violence and protests: https://www.nytimes.com/2023/03/16/world/europe/macron-france-pension.html https://www.nytimes.com/2023/03/16/world/europe/macron-franc...
- xeromal 4y agoNot for the elderly population until they die off. More consuming than producing means there's less to give up top.
- s1artibartfast 4y ago
- tjs8rj 4y agoFor a while, declining fertility rates were de facto considered a good sign in the demographic transition model. Usually experts would say "declining fertility is because people are chasing more fulfilling things! Our societies are so good that there is so much more to enjoy than children!". This always felt wrong. Why would the happiest society be the one that turns off it's natural processes? Is there any instance in nature where a declining birth rate is a sign of good things for a species? Glad the tide is finally turning to recognize the obvious truth: declining birth rates is a sign of distress in a society.
- jfowief 4y agoAnd a corollary to that truth, traditional societies are actually far more reasonable in their values and "moral progress" is actually running in the opposite direction than commonly assumed, with society going backwards and committing suicide.
- Night_Thastus 4y agoDeclining fertility rates were considered good for multiple reasons: * It's associated with lower infant/youth mortality rates (people have less children when they know each will survive) * It's associated with higher per-person productivity and industrialization (it makes sense to have several children helping you on a farm, but with industrialization it makes more sense to send 1-2 to college) Declining birth rates are not "a sign of distress". Assuming ideal conditions, fertility would float around the value we see in highly developed nations. However, this is a problem economically, because our economy is built on indefinite growth and the idea that the younger generations financially support the elderly. With too few youth and too many elderly, the system collapses. The economic problems will work out eventually, but it is going to suck financially for many until things stabilize.
- lotsofpulp 4y ago> Why would the happiest society be the one that turns off it's natural processes? The natural process is for women to not have a say in how many children they give birth to, and instead be subject to the whims of their male counterparts, who can obviously overpower them. A decline from a certain fertility rate to a certain fertility rate can indicate that women are gaining agency.
- pjc50 4y ago> But when the lease on her apartment in Seoul, South Korea, became too much to afford This is not complicated. If you want more people there has to be somewhere they can live. It is far better to not have people born than to hit the point where overpopulation starts killing people (usually via homelessness or violence).
- s1artibartfast 4y agoIt isn't that simple. You see the same phenomenon in Europe and Japan where there are entire villages of houses to be had if you are willing to take over the deed. There are forces at work here besides just space. People are drawn not to places where they can have space and families, but to dense urban areas without space to live. It is a conflict of desires and objectives.
- AstralStorm 4y agoThe desire is to not be destitute and have access to services including education, not to be in a city as such.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI think it is more complicated than that, Often tradeoffs of magnitude opposed to black and white. There are jobs and education in rural areas, at least to some degree, but people prefer higher paying jobs and better education, which is more available in the cities. I think that there is some level of thinking that the grass is always greener on the other side. I remember visiting my rural hometown after college and a few years working in SF to find that many acquaintances with only highschool degrees were now homeowners with 2.5 kids working at bars or auto shops. I'm sure they thought that I was rich, living in the city with 3X their salary. I think that if you look at the National cost of living data for towns and cities he will find that there is something more going on then just jobs and education because many people flock to cities that don't have particularly good good relative cost of living
- ssnistfajen 4y ago
- beardedman 4y agoTo have more sex? EDIT: My god, it was a joke.
- xeromal 4y agoI'm convinced a lot of our issues is just our general lost of testosterone and ability to conceive kids. Our bodies are just becoming worse and worse and conceiving and bearing children. Probably microplastics coupled with a sedentary lifestyle.
- beardedman 4y agoPretty good point actually.
- kibwen 4y agoDespite the hormonal changes induced by microplastics/obesity (or whatever the culprit is), the current drop in fertility rates is not because people are incapable of conceiving, but rather because people cannot financially support the cost of having children. If governments want children, they need to start paying for it: guaranteed paid maternity and paternity leave, state-funded daycare, and reduced housing costs. People are simply concluding that it is better to not have children than to raise children in abject poverty.
- xeromal 4y agoI just don't agree with this argument because humans have been having boatloads of children during all terrible-to-live eras of human history.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoHow many of those eras did women have access to very effective birth control, or the ability to say no to sex (or simply opt out of entering into a relationship with a man for her future security)?
- chasebank 4y agoI'm confused. Fertility is one's ability to conceive children but this article seems to be about one's situational want to conceive children. Is fertility rate the rate at which women are getting pregnant or the rate of the ability of women getting pregnant?
- rarec 4y agoIt's the rate that women are getting pregnant. Circumstances and societal conditions can certainly curtail and slow the willingness of otherwise capable women to have families.
- chasebank 4y agoDo you just refer to fertility as 'South Korea's Fertility' when referencing the ability to conceive? I mean, it's not incredibly shocking that a country half the size of Florida, essentially an island nation with a population of 50M, are deciding not to have children.
- wenc 4y agoSouth Korea is not half the size of Florida — it’s the other way around. FL is less than half the size of SK. Also it’s not an island nation — it’s on the Korean Peninsula. If you mean it’s an island nation in terms of connectivity then most nations in the world are islands too. Brazil for instance is culturally disconnected from its neighbors due to language.
- chasebank 4y agoA quick google says SK is 38k sq/mi and FL is 65k sq/mi. Maybe I missed something? SK is essentially an island nation. It's not like you can drive your car or train up north through the DMZ and wander up to China.
- wenc 4y agoI see what you mean. I was referring the half the size in terms of population — SK is 50m vs FL with 21m. SK has great transportation connectivity so I’m not sure how being topographically disconnected has an effect in modern times.
- qoomio 4y agoI don't understand why the governments just tax the elderly with vast real estate holding to fund their generations well being as they get older. Why tax the youth for these programs
- Longlius 4y agoI imagine some form of this will eventually take place but it's going to get ugly - retirees have far higher rates of political participation than young people and will fight tooth and nail to protect their wealth.
- qoomio 4y agoI 100% agree
- ssnistfajen 4y agoA large portion of elderly people don't have vast real estate holdings. Wealth inequality is solely divided along age lines. Also, elderly people have lots of free time to pay attention to politics and show up to vote. In elective democracies they can become a strong voting bloc in order to prevent politicians campaigning on such platforms from gaining power.
- seo-speedwagon 4y agoThe article mentions a number of systemic issues that would need to be overcome if the SK government wants to credibly claim they’re trying to do something about declining birth rates. To poke at just one: South Korea already has an insanely long work week, and they tried to make it even longer (69 hours!). Honestly, where do you expect people to find the time and energy to produce and raise kids if they work a 5x12 +9 hours on the weekend (I don’t know how the actual work week is broken down tho) https://www.msn.com/en-us/money/companies/south-korea-tried-to-push-an-almost-70-hour-work-week-but-was-forced-to-rethink-after-millennials-and-gen-z-protested/ar-AA18QArh https://www.msn.com/en-us/money/companies/south-korea-tried-...
- BenGosub 4y agoThat's crazy
- abhaynayar 4y agoMinor irrelevant detail, but most links in the article start with a space character. Looking into the source, it looks like they've misplaced the space: `previous word<a href="..."> next word`