12 ms·
Nearly Half of Firms Are Drafting Policies on ChatGPT Use
- shapefrog 4y agoI love hand waving polls as a premise for a story, bonus points awarded if they are a twitter poll. In other news - Nearly half of firms doing nothing about ChatGPT use.
- rickydroll 4y agoUnderstood. Although personally I would file ADA case on the banning of ChatGPT and copilot as they both allow someone with a physical disability be able to work in software development. And before you object, break your hands and try to live with speech recognition as it stands today. Then you will grab onto things like copilot as a lifesaver.
- lm28469 4y agoWe need X because X helps 0.01% of the population despite having potential very bad side effect has always been one of the weakest argument though. It's the same rhetoric they use to try to push for backdoor in OSes, messaging services, &c. "but what about the pedophiles, think of the children!"
- bdzr 4y agoCopilot is a lifesaver, but Talon and Cursorless are quite good for voice based programming today.
- karaterobot 4y ago> And before you object, break your hands and try to live with speech recognition as it stands today. That is a LOT to ask me to do before objecting. I'm pretty good at imagination, so I'll probably skip that step.
- flappyeagle 4y agoWear mittens
- throw10920 4y ago> they both allow someone with a physical disability be able to work in software development This is somewhere between "intentionally misleading" and "objectively false" as people with physical disabilities are already able to work in software development. > speech recognition as it stands today ...is somewhat clunky and slower than typing, but still usable. The limiting factor for software engineering is not and has never been how fast you can physically enter code.
- bdzr 4y agoI'm not who you're responding to, but I voice code for most of my SWE job. The technology that exists today is far better at editing existing code than writing code from scratch, making copilot and other boilerplate generators an enormous productivity gain for voice coders. The ADA is exceptionally accommodating, if the employee can make an argument that their productivity is hindered due to a disability and a tool can help, it's very likely to be approved.
- Karunamon 4y ago"Somewhat" is such an inaccurate minimization of the impact that it borders on malicious. Voice input, when it is the only means of interacting with the computer, fucking sucks. An extremely conservative estimate would be a 10 X productivity impact for anything that requires precision keyboard input, such as programming. Most of that is due to correcting misheard terms with a side of fiddly punctuation. To put this into context, this entire comment took me about three or four minutes to dictate. At my preinjury typing speed, it would've been done in under one, likely in under half of one. The options for operating systems that are not Windows are limited and of typical hobbyist quality, but honestly the paid options on Windows are not that much better.
- throw10920 4y ago> "Somewhat" is such an inaccurate minimization of the impact that it borders on malicious. The only maliciousness here is the extremely manipulative nature of your comment. "Somewhat clunky" is absolutely a valid way of describing the productivity impact of current voice transcription systems, and your incredible, emotionally-manipulative hyperbole is solely meant to push an agenda. > Voice input, when it is the only means of interacting with the computer, fucking sucks. Yes, because the current paradigm for computers (which involves either a touchscreen or keyboard and mouse, and certain ontological constructs best represented using text-adjacent symbols) is intrinsically better suited to use by people who can use their hands. You can't fix this for the current design of computers. Can it be made better? Sure. Will there ever be parity between users who can use hands and those constrained to voice? Not for computers as we know them - and Copilot won't change that. > An extremely conservative estimate would be a 10 X productivity impact for anything that requires precision keyboard input, such as programming. Most time spent programming is spent thinking, not typing. I do not believe your estimate. > To put this into context, this entire comment took me about three or four minutes to dictate. I read your comment in a normal conversational rate in under 45 seconds. If we add in another fifteen seconds to correct a few errors using a well-designed (but contemporary, non-Copilot, non-LLM) transcription tool, that's a full minute, far below your "three or four minutes" estimate - so, your complaints are about the clunkiness of current voice-transcription tools, and completely unrelated to the topic at hand, which is Copilot. > At my preinjury typing speed, it would've been done in under one, likely in under half of one. There are 128 words in your comment. If you typed that in one minute, you would have a rate of 128wpm, which is faster than anyone I know, and in the 99.9th percentile of typists. If you typed that in thirty seconds, that's 256 wpm. I literally do not believe you can type that fast. You're intentionally skewing the above numbers to support your point - not that it matters anyway, because again, most time programming is not spent typing.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mc32 4y agoAs with anything new, organizations are only now having to consider implications. It’s absolutely the right thing to consider, just as social media rose organizations drafter social media policies.
- Traubenfuchs 4y agoBarely related autoplay video that unmutes on click, only a second click stops it, can't be closed, later some completely unrelated stock data appears around the video. The people that made this website should be ashamed. Anyways, this is ridiculous: What's their selection? I'd argue that 99% of firms world wide are not drafting policies on ChatGPT use. Gartner probably only asked HR and marketing busybodies who feel like they need a public opinion on any topic they are ever asked about to make it look like they are valuable, smart and active "thought leaders".
- lm28469 4y ago> Anyways, this is ridiculous Until people with absolutely no notion of security and privacy start leaking API keys, internal memos, &c. to openai It probably already happened, it happens all the time in other tools, but the scale of it and the way it's sold to the public makes it much more likely to be an issue
- simonw 4y agoI don't think people pasting an API key into ChatGPT is particularly concerning. OpenAI aren't training new models on raw input to their bots (they're using it for other levels of improvement). Are you worried that an OpenAI employee might steal API keys out of their logs? (I still wouldn't paste an API key in myself.)
- UncleEntity 4y agoChatGPT uses the API keys to escape into the wild and start the robolution.
- lm28469 4y agoIt's a black box, they might or might not do something now, they might or might not do it later, in the meantime the data is stored somewhere for god know how long. It might get hacked, there might be a bug allowing people to access other users history, &c. It doesn't seem "ridiculous" to me that companies issue official statements and guidelines about what they want/not want their employees to share with a third party software. Tech illiterate people have absolutely no idea what is ok or not to share and what/where their data go.
- mrgs 4y agoWonder how many are using ChatGPT to help draft the policy
- mc32 4y agoPresumably as it’s being drafted it’s not in effect and moreover the policy may be positive for use or negative against use, but before there is one in place, it cannot apply.
- kneebonian 4y agoMy company is coming out with a policy that you can't put anything into ChatGPT. I'm ignoring it, the simple fact of the matter is it's a powerful tool. The firms that choose to use this will rapidly outpace those that don't, who will be left behind.
- Espressosaurus 4y agoThat's not for you to decide until it's your own company and your own IP.
- renewiltord 4y agoLooks like he decided it anyway.
- mr_coleman 4y agoMaybe it's not a good idea to put your employer's source code out onto some random website. If you wouldn't put it on here, you probably shouldn't put it on ChatGPT. I'm sure it's only a matter of time there will be a code ai that can be run behind a firewall but until then stop giving away the secret sauce.
- jstarfish 4y agoAzure is supposedly compartmentalized. It's too soon to see these boundaries fail, but they're supposed to be the "safe" option for this.
- lnsru 4y agoYou have a good reason to not want layoffs in your company unless by “your company” you mean you are the owner. I also can’t paste anything in ChatGPT window, there are at least 3 spying/tracking software pieces on my work computers. I will comply.
- wwweston 4y agoFirms that choose to use it indiscriminately will also be exporting domain knowledge (likely including those that give them a competitive advantage) into ChatGPT. This doesn't matter in roles that are complementary to where the most value is generated (the phrase "commoditize your complement" exists for a reason) but that's not all roles.
- tomhallett 4y agoHas OpenAI said anything (in their TOS/etc) about who owns the copyright/ip on the code that it generates? I know it’s a legal minefield of a question, just curious if they have said “we won’t sue you if you copy/paste this code in your app” publically or anything.
- bloak 4y agoSemi-serious: Perhaps they are scared of even mentioning copyright in case it makes their own infringement "wilful".
- chongli 4y agoI think courts have started to find that the output of AIs like ChatGPT can’t be copyrighted at all because it isn’t human expression.
- CuriouslyC 4y agoThe USPTO has already ruled that stuff created solely via prompt to a model with no modification is not copyrightable.
- spacebanana7 4y agoThat might be the case in theory, but if a university can't tell the difference between AI generated essays/books and human generated ones the how could the courts?
- CuriouslyC 4y agoIf someone tries to sue you for copyright infringement on a model output, you can just produce the parameters to the model that produced the output and the case will be thrown out pretty much instantly.
- spacebanana7 4y agoMy understanding is that LLMs are generally probabilistic so repeating the inputs won’t produce the same output.
- toyg 4y agoThe company I work for, literally blocked the OpenAI site at the network level "until they can assess the potential security impact". I guess they fear people might leak sensitive information to OpenAI. Very frustrating for people with a legitimate use case for it.
- 0cf8612b2e1e 4y agoThat seems completely fair? I also cannot upload random company data to Dropbox or Google Sheets.
- toyg 4y agoBut Dropbox and Google are not blocked, people are just told not to upload random company data to it. Same could be done with OpenAI with a simple email.
- PragmaticPulp 4y agoMy company has a group of younger product managers who are very obviously using ChatGPT to write proposals, e-mails, and other documents. It's obvious because their writings in Confluence and late night e-mails suddenly became very verbose and used the sometimes obvious ChatGPT voice. There's a stark contrast between content they write/share on the spot or discuss in meetings. Then you get them into a meeting to explain further and they some times can't even remember what they were thinking when they wrote various bullet points. It's eye opening to see how much the ChatGPT produced content can fool managers at the top who catch glimpses of neatly composed and verbose documents. Then you get the people into meetings and they don't really know where they were going with their "own" documents. It wouldn't be a problem if they could take the documents as some sort of next step for their learning or research, but it's really becoming useless to have all of this ChatGPT-created content out there where none of them can really execute on it without going back to ChatGPT over and over again to come up with more content.
- wongarsu 4y ago> It's eye opening to see how much the ChatGPT produced content can fool managers at the top who catch glimpses of neatly composed and verbose documents. Goodhart's law in action. If "neatly composed and verbose documents" is the metric higher ups use to judge product managers, then documents will become neater and more verbose to the detriment of everything else. In the end, the alignment problems that plague AI safety research are all playing out in company structures every day. It's hard to give a metric that measures your intended outcome, and any proxy leads to unintended consequences once there's an easier way to reach that proxy.
- 13years 4y agoIn the end, the alignment problems that plague AI safety research are all playing out in company structures every day. It's hard to give a metric that measures your intended outcome, and any proxy leads to unintended consequences once there's an easier way to reach that proxy. I've actually pointed this out as a fallacy of the premise of current alignment theory. That being we simply need to apply humanities values for the AI to be properly aligned. However, every alignment problem can also be seen as an existing human problem for which we have never resolved.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- satvikpendem 4y agoI'm working on an open source startup to allow companies to self host OSS AI/LLM models on their own infrastructure, whether through AWS/GCP/Azure/DigitalOcean/etc or on their physical servers. I'm fine tuning models with prompts and then I'll build out the API so that users and other developers can query them. This way, you send nothing back to a proprietary service. Is anyone else interested in something like this?
- jacooper 4y agoAnywhere where we can follow updates on this?
- satvikpendem 4y agoIf you could just email me (in my profile) that'd be great, then I could keep track of people.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- cyrialize 4y agoAbsolutely. I'm just an IC though, so I have no sway. That being said, this is something I've been talking about for a while now with co-workers. Being able to run an LLM on your codebase and query it just for your code would be fantastic!
- satvikpendem 4y agoYep, there are some efforts like this already, I recently posted this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35226097 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35226097 Albeit, it is using proprietary GPT instead.
- layer8 4y agoI would expect most firms to have policies in place prohibiting employees to share work-related information with outside parties they don’t have a pertinent business relationship with. In principle that already covers (and rules out) most uses of ChatGPT for work.