3 ms·
> Over the past year, electricity prices have gone up 2.5 times I wonder if the people who constantly yell about the obvious superiority of self-hosting over c
by jeffbee 4y ago
> Over the past year, electricity prices have gone up 2.5 times
I wonder if the people who constantly yell about the obvious superiority of self-hosting over cloud can internalize this information. The costs of hosting your own computers has often increased. Cloud costs, so far, have only gone down.
When they launched them 13 years ago, EC2 "micro" instances cost 1.4¢/hr. Today, they are twice as large, much faster, and cost 0.53¢/hr. In real dollars, the instance cost has declined 73%, and more like 95% in specific throughput. Meanwhile colo prices have gone nowhere but up.
- bsder 4y ago> The costs of hosting your own computers has often increased. Cloud costs, so far, have only gone down. If that's true, it's only true because cloud pricing was highway robbery to begin with. Hurricane Electric (who I chose simply because they always put their price online--other colos should take note) is at $400/month for a cab & GigE. It doesn't take very many online servers to put that in a rounding error. In roughly 20 months, you win against the cloud even if you count CapEx. And, do remember, the cloud companies all charge egress by the byte. Sure, most people don't care, until they become successful and suddenly wind up with a $10K bill in a month. The "cloud" is useful two ways: 1) Pop up servers quickly However, this is should be "I use servers and can transfer them to another provider quickly if I need to." Any provider should work as well as bare metal. 2) Lean heavily into specific services on in the cloud provider. The goal here is that you are cheaper specifically because you don't have a fixed "baseline" that you are always utilizing. In this way, you are completely relying on the fact that the provider can shuffle things to be uber cheap.
- bsder 4y agoI think you are off on your math somewhere or you aren't accounting for something. $0.0053/hr would be roughly $4 per month. Even the uber cheap providers like Hetzner aren't that good.
- jodrellblank 4y agoUnless you are suggesting that Amazon is getting free electricity, then must be either: - Profiting enough from micro instances to pay for the electricity of running them. If so then when you get to using a server full of micro instances you can save money by doing that yourself and not paying Amazon's profit. - Eating the loss and subsidising it from other income. This is convenient for you but not anything to do with the cloud, more to do with the power of a huge company. - Big enough to have arm twisted a fixed price for a long time ahead, pushing the extra cost onto the supplier, so the supplier will go bankrupt and be bailed out by the taxpayer. Again convenient for you but nothing to do with the cloud. - Other? What's your explanation for Amazon not charging customers more despite rising energy costs? You switched "self-hosting" to "colo" which aren't the same things. One can imagine a big non-tech company negotiating fixed prices on their power for their datacenters. One can imagine a big non-tech company investing in regular server refreshes to converge down on more power efficient servers over time.
- bsder 4y agoAmazon is subsidizing base charges with network bandwidth charges.