4 ms·
> You still seem to be missing my question, which is, how did third world countries become how they are? Certainly not by adopting something like contemporary A
by rayiner 4y ago
> You still seem to be missing my question, which is, how did third world countries become how they are? Certainly not by adopting something like contemporary American culture, right?
Sure, but that’s besides the point. Countries can fail to develop for many different reasons. Third world countries, like the one I’m from, have different cultural problems. It’s hard to climb out of that well. But you can compare a more individualistic subgroup of Americans to other subgroups that are in broadly similar circumstances and draw an inference.
The 1960s social revolution turned up the individual self determination aspect of American culture to 11. Seeking pleasure, prioritizing personal satisfaction, rejecting social rules in favor of individualized morality, etc. That individualist streak has always been latent in American culture, but it’s most apparent in Appalachia. For example, even 100 years ago Appalachians had higher rates of multiple marriages than the rest of the country: https://ifstudies.org/blog/the-appalachian-go-round-family-instability-in-americas-highland https://ifstudies.org/blog/the-appalachian-go-round-family-i...
There were lots of German immigrants in Appalachia, but they didn’t build the place the way they did the Midwest. Many went to established cities like Cincinnati and Pittsburgh.
The distinctive culture of Appalachia isn’t a “myth.” For reasons tracing all the way back to the types of British immigrants who founded the place: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Albion%27s_Seed https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Albion%27s_Seed.
As Lee Kuan Yew says, culture is destiny: https://www.jstor.org/stable/20045923 https://www.jstor.org/stable/20045923. If you want to understand what works and what doesn’t, look at the culture of the people who made things work contrasted against the people who didn’t.
- lapcat 4y ago> I’m using “third world country” as a generic reference to low standard of living. Um, ok, here's a tip: if you want to be understood, maybe try using words like everyone else uses them, instead of repurposing existing words with your own private definitions? > That makes it impossible to develop government and rule of law. [You seem to have deleted this sentence in editing.] In other words, we're doing a lot right, otherwise we wouldn't attract so many immigrants, and thus our culture isn't as bad as it's portrayed by, ironically, immigrants. > That individualist streak has always been latent in American culture, but it’s most apparent in Appalachia. I... am speechless. I don't know how to respond to this, at least without saying something that will get me downvoted or flagged. So I guess our conversation may be over. > For example, even 100 years ago Appalachians had higher rates of multiple marriages than the rest of the country From your own linked article: "Whether this was due to divorce or higher mortality, I can’t say". Also: "Even with these higher divorce rates, the share of Appalachian women currently married is nonetheless higher than women in the rest of the US." Your article doesn't even show what you seem to want it to show. > There were lots of German immigrants in Appalachia, but they didn’t build the place the way they did the Midwest. I'm a lifelong Midwesterner. There's a very strong, deep rooted progressive streak in the Midwest, for example in Wisconsin and Minnesota, notably, which both have large populations of German ancestry. Frankly, your comments seem to be imbued with with overgeneralization and stereotypes. A major reason why divorce rates have increased in the past 50+ years is that over this time period, women have achieved a great deal of financial independence from men. They don't have to be married anymore. They have more choices, can be more selective. This is, I would say, good. I don't want to go back to a past where women were subservient.
- rayiner 4y ago> Um, ok, here's a tip: if you want to be understood, maybe try using words like everyone else uses them, instead of repurposing existing words with your own private definitions? Referring to the law standard of living is the common usage of the term "third world country." Nobody is referring to alignment vis-a-vis NATO and the USSR. > In other words, we're doing a lot right, otherwise we wouldn't attract so many immigrants, and thus our culture isn't as bad as it's portrayed by, ironically, immigrants. We immigrated to the America of Jimmy Carter, and Ronald Reagan, and George H.W. Bush. The country is still riding the inertia of that. Moreover, immigrants are generally insulated from the larger culture. Affluent, educated immigrants can count on joining the top quantile, where as the article observes marriage norms remain strong. And whether affluent or not, immigrants have their own communities with their own social structures. Rampant divorce in Oregon doesn't affect Bangladeshis in Queens. > I'm a lifelong Midwesterner. There's a very strong, deep rooted progressive streak in the Midwest, for example in Wisconsin and Minnesota, notably, which both have large populations of German ancestry. Yes, but it's mainly a collectivist form of economic progressivism. As we saw with 2012-2016 shifts, when cultural issues predominate, the alignment runs in the other direction. > A major reason why divorce rates have increased in the past 50+ years is that over this time period, women have achieved a great deal of financial independence from men. Except the women who have the most potential for independence have the highest marriage rates. The marriage rate of people in the top quantile is the same today as it was in 1979: https://www.brookings.edu/research/middle-class-marriage-is-declining-and-likely-deepening-inequality/ https://www.brookings.edu/research/middle-class-marriage-is-.... Marriage rates for women with a bachelor's degree were pretty close to those without a high school disagree in 1968: https://www.brookings.edu/blog/social-mobility-memos/2016/08/19/the-most-educated-women-are-the-most-likely-to-be-married https://www.brookings.edu/blog/social-mobility-memos/2016/08.... Today, marriage rates in the former group have dropped about 10 percentage points, but have been stable since the mid 1980s. (If you account for the fact that way more people have bachelors degrees today, there might not be much real change at all.) Meanwhile, marriage rates for the other groups have dropped 20-30 points and are still declining. The data supports an alternative hypothesis. Social norms around marriage and taboos against divorce function as guard-rails that encourage normal people to do something that's good for them--getting and staying married. High-IQ, high impulse control people (the folks who go to college and end up in the top 20%) don't need those social guard rails, and have done fine without them. That is consistent with other social trends too--for example, college educated people are far less likely to be obese than everyone else.