5 ms·
I come from a south Asian immigrant family in the US. Nearly every single person I know in my extended cohort of immigrants followed the script (because we were
by rayiner 4y ago
I come from a south Asian immigrant family in the US. Nearly every single person I know in my extended cohort of immigrants followed the script (because we were socialized to do so): we studied hard in school, pursued financially lucrative majors, eschewed dating at an early age, got married in our 20s, and had kids. My brother is having his first kid at 31–and my dad and I were frankly getting pretty antsy. And for every single one of us that followed the script it paid off, including those whose parents came here without white collar jobs.
And of course none of us talk about that in public because we want to seem illiberal to our educated white American friends. For a long time I reconciled myself to that cognitive dissonance. But my wife is American, from a deep blue state. And it’s been eye opening to watch the aftermath of the 1960s social revolution on Americans outside the economic elite. It seems like everybody’s parents are divorced. They hang around any stable family they can find. Nobody is willing to guide their kids: they’re supposed to “discover themselves” on their own. The parents are too scared to impose values: this is what we expect, this is what constitutes a good life, this is what your purpose and function and role is. It’s a mess. If American culture has been this way 200 years ago we would be living in a third world country.
- xyzelement 4y agoThank you for the brave statement. I am an immigrant from the former USSR and have the same exact observations. Somehow the boomer generation convinced themselves, when young, that youth was wiser than age, and then neither their kids nor grandkids got any guidance.
- lapcat 4y ago> If American culture has been this way 200 years ago we would be living in a third world country. How do you figure? Did third world countries have current American culture before we did (I ask rhetorically)?
- rayiner 4y agoYou can look at the cultural characteristics of different American groups that were here but didn’t build civilization. Look what the places the Puritans, Germans, and Mormons built. These are cultures that lean towards communal rule following. Contrast that against Appalachians, or the frontiersmen who populated the Oregon coast, and what they built. These are cultures that have emphasized individual self determination.
- lapcat 4y ago> but didn’t build civilization I don't know what this is supposed to mean. Anyway, you avoided saying anything about third world countries, so maybe I need to repeat my question non-rhetorically.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 4y agoI’m saying that Appalachia is more like a third world country than other parts of the US, and drawing an inference about what the US would be like if Appalachians had populated the whole country.
- lapcat 4y agoYou still seem to be missing my question, which is, how did third world countries become how they are? Certainly not by adopting something like contemporary American culture, right? Furthermore, you've made a very strange pivot: first you were talking about how "it’s been eye opening to watch the aftermath of the 1960s social revolution", but now you're talking about "what the US would be like if Appalachians had populated the whole country". The former and the latter seem to have very little or nothing to do with each other. It's also pretty weird that you contrast for example Germans and Appalachians, because "Germans were a major pioneer group to migrate to Appalachia". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Appalachia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Appalachia And: "Since its recognition as a distinctive region in the late 19th century, Appalachia has been a source of enduring myths and distortions regarding the isolation, temperament, and behavior of its inhabitants."
- FrontierPsych 4y ago3rd world places are just places that used to be everywhere. When people come together into larger and larger communities, then more specialization can take place over longer periods of time. This is if you have a stable situation, of course. Additionally, writing and schools are critical, so knowledge can be passed down systematically. Not randomly by "tribe elders." And the schools should be fairly open, meaning being able to be open about what they say and teach. To be able to push boundries. Ancient Athens had writing, they had schools. They passed down architecture and philosophy in regular schools. If you are in hunter/gatherer mode, nobody really is a schoolteacher. The smartest hunter/gatherer, even if he or she was legit Einstein smart, is going to be out hunting for rabbits or deers or planting rice. You must have "extra." Extra population that supports scholars. That's why in medieval times, the Catholic Church was the keeper of scholarship. They had a lot of priest for the laypeople, but they had money to support a lot of people who hung out and did intellectual work. And, those who WERE Einstein smart joined the Catholic Church, because they figured out where they should go with their talents, just like a super smart student today knows to apply to MIT or Harvard or Princeton, etc. Once you have the modern type university (as opposed to one or two subjects like law and religion, for example), then it all starts to snowball. Technology starts to snowball. This is one of the reasons why the Western world surpassed all others. It started in ancient Greece, and continued. England created the first modern universities at Oxford and Cambridge. Some claim it was University of Al Quaraouiyine, Morocco, but it was not a modern style university in the subject offered. This is why England dominated the world. It passed on knowledge from generation to generation until it was absolutely the top. England's geography of being an island and cut off from mainland Europe also helped a lot. "Third world countries", meaning hunter/gatherer, tribal, herdsman cultures, just don't have the critical mass. They simply do not have the numbers of people to make it. The USA is the 4th most populated nation on earth. With this great population, if one out of a million is a tippy-tippy top person in some area of study, then there are going to be 330 in each area of the USA, since we have 330 million population. In every endeavor. On the other hand, if you are in a country that has 2 million people, your odds of having that one in a million person are 3 in every area of endeavor/industry. 330 vs 3 is a big difference when you are talking about near-einstein level. Except in a very populous country, these exceptional people will find their way to other exceptional people (usually via universities), but those in "3rd world" countries who are 1 out of a million might be stuck doing subsistence farming or shit like that. And even IF one of those 1 out of a million in Sudan, let's say, were to somehow find their way out, they would move to England or USA or Germany or France, and not stay in their poverty country. And, those countries would GLADLY give them citizenship if university was to line up behind a super skilled person. . Culture is important. Population density is important. Inculcation of education is important (which is part of culture, I guess.). If a culture spurns education, they will never self-actualize. People talk about islam and how they "saved" all the knowledge, and that's all great and stuff, but what have they done for us lately? The reality is that the super religious anti-education conservative elements of islam took over and fucked over the learned islamic peoples, and the conservatives of islam destroyed the smart part of islam. The same that is happening in the USA right now. So to answer your question directly, their world countries did not "become" how they are. They are exactly like they were 10,000 or 50,000 years ago. In order to change, you have to change. If someone is conservative and does not like change, then they will want to be like it was 100, 1,000 or 10,000 years ago. There are many, many people today who don't thing viruses or germs are a thing, for example. There are many who still believe in "gods"...like, 96% of the world believe that gods are real. Meanwhile, the most educated do not go for that. You look at those with science degrees and only 50% believe in a god. Look at the NAS, Natural Acadamy of Science her in the USA where only top scientists are admitted, only 4% accept that a god exists. So it's like that. Culture. Education. Knowledge. Population. Wealth. Etc. It is a web of interconnected stuff that takes a long time to put together. England started Oxford in in 1200, and it took 800 years to make it to the peak of their Empire. Their empire fell apart because of the spread of knowledge to other parts of the world. Knowledge. Nothing else. Not war. Not WwI or WWII. Knowledge. Education.
- hotpotamus 4y agoIt's interesting to have it called a script; implying that it is fixed and out of your control. For what it's worth, I was given the same script by my parents and especially the Catholic Church, but it all seemed pretty ridiculous on its face; even to a child it was pretty clear that it was a nice delusion, but we all end up gone and forgotten once the script runs out. I have zero desire to put children through any of it.
- devolve848392 4y ago[flagged]
- hotpotamus 4y ago5 billion years of little more than random biochemical interactions. It hasn't felt like much of a gift so far, though I suppose the pain of living with a crippling illness might color that view a bit. Still if I could choose to continue to exist, I might actually, but unless there are some serious technical advances (or if you believe those Catholics), then extinction is coming for me and all of us. Creating children consigned to suffer the same fate in some futile quest for immortality seems like far too heavy a burden to place on them. I am however intrigued that you appear to have created an account just to reply to me. That is a novel experience.
- devolve848392 4y ago[flagged]
- jfowief 4y ago[flagged]
- Auracle 4y agoI’m a fairly new father. It was hard fought for my wife and I. Three years of trying, rounds of IUI, I had to be on different medications that entire 3+ that made me feel shitty, and eventually we succeeded with our first round of IVF. We now have an 18 month old daughter, and we just tried with one of our frozen embryos to get her a sister. I say tried because while my wife got pregnant, we found out a few days ago that it was an anembryonic gestation. My wife passed what embryo there was today. We aren’t exactly rich and my parents helped with the funds. But you know what? It’s all been worth it. Hell, I’ve been stressed like crazy because I want to change careers back to using my degree in computer science instead of the photography I’ve been doing and I don’t have the time to get my skills up to snuff because of her… But my daughter makes me the happiest I’ve ever been in my life. It’s a joy I never had before. I wish I could somehow let my friends that have decided not to have children experience it.
- soderfoo 4y agoSo sorry for your loss. Regarding wanting to get back in to CS: I became a dev in my mid 30s, and found my first job in a country where I don't speak the language. Received plenty of rejections and embarrassed myself during both whiteboard and take home coding challenges. Even when I went above and beyond for a take home challenge, the offer went to someone else. But something stuck out to the hiring director (grit, belligerence in the face of the odds?) and I was offered a position mainly on my intangibles. Sometimes I tend over think and catastrophize, but every now and then I catch lightning in a bottle and defiantly ignore that skeptical voice. So I hope you can take something from my rant.
- Auracle 4y agoThank you. It's a bit hard in my case as we want to stay in our rural area, so that would mean probably a remote job. What's worse is that weddings are booked pretty far out, so I would need to not take any (more) bookings for 2024 and desperately hope I can get a job after wedding season is done in November. There's no way I could take on a full time job in addition to a full summer's worth of weddings. I work 15 or so hours a day during the worst of it already. I've been working on a VR game in my free time so right now my hope is to (somehow) finish that this year and then at least I'll have something to show...which I guess might be that lightning in a bottle that I need.
- onos 4y agoI think everyone knows at some level that the cookbook for the success you highlight is correct and works, as south and eastern asians have demonstrated so systematically. Yet, sadly, many groups avoid it… I think often for intentionally self-defeating or other pathological reasons.
- red-iron-pine 4y ago> as south and eastern asians have demonstrated so systematically. I challenge this. With 1.5 billion people the cream of highly motivated and intelligent people will of course rise to the top. Anyone not razor focused on getting out, getting up, and pushing successful traits wouldn't make it; survivor bias.
- rayiner 4y agoExcept it applies to their kids too. Asian Americans growing up in the bottom 1/5 of the income distribution are more than twice as likely to end up in the top 1/5 as adults compared to white Americans. You can say that’s because their parents are highly motivated—but you can’t gift your kids motivation. What you can do is pass on certain culture and values, which brings us back to the point above.
- onos 4y agoYeah good point.