3 ms·
> Because if Google's appropriation of Oracle's API IP without a license is fair use, what uses of an API would be protected by copyright? Well, copying the im
by dragonwriter 4y ago
> Because if Google's appropriation of Oracle's API IP without a license is fair use, what uses of an API would be protected by copyright?
Well, copying the implementing code of the API rather than only the declarations, or copying the declarations for a purpose that was not supporting an implementation for a very different underlying platform constraints could be distinguished on grounds central to the core of the Supreme Court decision. The former would very likely fail Fair Use analysis without some new factor not presebt in Google v. Oracle, the latter is less certain. (And any of the other points of the fair use analysis could be basis for distinction, the analysis is complex and doesn’t boil down to a short, simple rule.)