3 ms·
10 million 'registered users' not 'daily active users' in 7 years. Even in some of the comments in the post are skeptical about the usage of those registered ac
by rvz 4y ago
10 million 'registered users' not 'daily active users' in 7 years. Even in some of the comments in the post are skeptical about the usage of those registered accounts.
In comparison to Twitter (Since Mastodon zealots often pitch it as a 'Twitter alternative' somehow) 7 years after it launched, it had well over 250M+ total users with well over 150M daily actives. [0] Even Nostr has 6M total users in less than 7 years. [1] Either way, total registered number of users tells us nothing about the usage of the network.
Yet we have daily actives much less than 1.5M with a large drop in users this year since they don't stick around on Mastodon. [2] It only tells us that there are very loud crickets screaming about migrating to Mastodon which accounted for less than 1% of Twitter's total number of users. (And most of them never stuck around)
7 years is not early days with this. Matrix launched in 2014 and reached 10M in less than 5 years and multiplied by up to 8x to 80M in less than 4 years [3] and it is highly competitive against Signal. There is no excuses for such sluggish user numbers for Mastodon with even less monthly active users.
Thus, I think we have given Mastodon enough time and it is clear that it hasn't taken off. Perhaps it is time to stop pretending about users caring about signing up to a over-engineered discord forum promoting pseudo-federation.
[0] https://backlinko.com/twitter-users https://backlinko.com/twitter-users
[1] https://stats.nostr.band/#total_users https://stats.nostr.band/#total_users
[2] https://www.wired.com/story/the-mastodon-bump-is-now-a-slump/ https://www.wired.com/story/the-mastodon-bump-is-now-a-slump...
[3] https://news.itsfoss.com/matrix-sixty-million-users/ https://news.itsfoss.com/matrix-sixty-million-users/
- gyudin 4y ago+1 Even monthly non-unique visits continue to decline. 6.9M in November, 3.9M in December, 3.4M in January. And personally every time I’ve tried to use it didn’t work properly as people would have problems with hosting and supporting it for free.
- jeromegv 4y agoWhere are you getting the non-unique visits data?
- tptacek 4y agoThe years Mastodon operated before Musk chased millions of people off Twitter don't count. In the status quo ante of Musk's takeover, Mastodon may never have been viable, but Musk did take over Twitter.
- rvz 4y ago> The years Mastodon operated before Musk chased millions of people off Twitter don't count. I'm sure you know those previous years of operation does certainly count. Mastodon launched in 2016 (7 years ago). Not in November 2022.
- c23gooey 4y agoAgreed, there's a few instances of this sort of thing that come to mind. Sometimes you have a good thing, but it's not until some external thing changes that the right conditions for uptake are met. One such example is the game Among Us which was out for two years before covid hit and it found exponential growth after that.
- cogwheels 4y agoTwitter's daily active user count has gone up since Musk took over. If people were chased off, they either came back or others filled up the numbers. Anecdotally, I've enjoyed Twitter a lot more since his takeover. They've relaxed their rules and unbanned a lot of people who I'd missed seeing on the platform. Musk does seem to be at least partially keeping his promise of improving the free speech aspect of the site.
- input_sh 4y ago> Twitter's daily active user count has gone up since Musk took over. Hello brand new account, do you work for Twitter? If not, how do you know? In another comment you ask to see Mastodon's active user count. Where's Twitter's? Personally I'd love to see a line chart of Twitter's DAU for the past six months. Like way more than I'm interested in Mastodon's.
- nforgerit 4y agoFood for thought for you: Mastodon doesn't have to care about growth rate. It's really weird to compare its growth rate to Twitter since it doesn't care at all about pushing interaction KPIs up to sell ads and emotions. What I can see, it grew a lot in the last 6 months and if a user's timeline is all empty then it's because the user missed to actively grow their network which is a bit annoying (search and hand-pick) but all in all is absolutely worth the time.
- lapcat 4y agoMost of my former Twitter followers/following in the Apple developer ecosystem have migrated to Mastodon and are very active there now. These are the people I joined Twitter for in the first place, back in the 2000s. Mastodon is definitely a Twitter alternative for us. I personally don't care about "sports Twitter" or "political Twitter" or "weird Twitter", etc. They can all stay on Twitter as far I'm concerned. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ My own opinion is that Twitter itself was much better in the early days, before all of the celebrities invaded.
- FireInsight 4y agoas far as weird twitter and progrssive political twitter is concerned, mastodon is a viable alternative don't know about sports, though
- rakoo 4y agoWhy does it matter how fast it is growing ?
- UberFly 4y agoI'm guessing you want people actually coming to the mall or all the businesses will leave.
- rakoo 4y agoFor the n-th time: the Fediverse is _not_ a commercial product. It is a tool. A tool needs only be useful to its users and doesn't care about extracting the most revenue. It is exactly this sick mindset of profit-making that made Facebook, Google, Amazon, Microsoft, Apple, Instagram, ... what they are today: dopamine machines giving 10s doses to the users to feed the datasets and make profits. It does not serve the user. It is not a model to follow, but one to reject wholly and fully.
- kalleboo 4y agoThe businesses leaving is a feature, not a bug.
- sussmannbaka 4y agoI don’t really care if it has taken off - I get WAY more engagement on my posts and so does pretty much everyone on my timeline despite having a fraction of the followers we had on twitter. I guess it hasn’t taken off for celeb gossip or professional brainworm-havers but somehow I can press the button and somebody gets to actually see my post.
- kalleboo 4y agoHacker News only has an estimated 300,000 active users, you better stop posting on this dead, useless platform.