4 ms·
The default has to fit these requirements: - The OS/desktop manager-specific stuff needs to be there, or else you fragment the overall UX for the computer. -
by dsr_ 15y ago
The default has to fit these requirements:
- The OS/desktop manager-specific stuff needs to be there, or else you fragment the overall UX for the computer.
- The browser needs to give immediate access to the actions that a typical user will use all the time.
- Tab mode has won out over separate windows, so you need a visual indicator of what tabs are open and which one is active.
- And the contents of the web page are the contents that you care about right now, or else you're looking for a way to navigate away.
Modern browsers do a pretty good job with all of those requirements. I'm surprised that Bray is even interested in a notional "home" page, since everyone I know, technical or not, either wants their session restored from last time (on startup) or a very fast search page to come up when they tap for a new tab. People don't reset tabs -- they close them or go somewhere in specific.
Best of all, this behavior is all customizable by normal people who never have to type about:config.
- jameshart 15y agoNo, it doesn't have to be that way, and on mobile devices it often isn't. In a mobile browser a lot of this layering is invisible or only available when called upon by the user. And consider also whether this excessive contextualisation might have something to do with the success of the 'app' model for accessing services, where the device focuses solely on the task at hand and all that framing goes away completely.
- dsr_ 15y agoMobile devices have their own UX expectations, and a browser has to fit into that model. You don't get a titlebar plus minimize/maximize/kill buttons because that's not the metaphor that the device uses. If everything on your desktop has a titlebar + buttons, your browser had better have those as well, or else it's a distraction. Don't break the metaphor. Use local system libraries. Don't make maximizing the window a surprise. If you want a nonframed experience on a desktop, it can't be the default. You can make it as easy to access as one keyclick to enter kiosk mode. Better provide a clean way of exiting, though, and best is to tell the user how to exit when they enter. (Take a YouTube video fullscreen, FF reminds you to 'Press ESC to exit'.)
- alexis-d 15y agoI'm not sure we really need all those bars. I mean I use this http://i.imgur.com/0U1yW.png http://i.imgur.com/0U1yW.png everyday and it's perfectly fine/usable (ok we may need to add an url/toolbar for most people, but at least it merge the tab bar and the title bar). Edit: It also merges the file/tools/help bar in the left button.
- alien_acorn 15y agoHow do you get the Firefox icon instead of the word "Firefox" in the orange drop-down button?
- kibwen 15y agoThere are probably several addons and themes to that end, here's one that seems reasonably popular: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/movable-firefox-button/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/movable-firef...
- alexis-d 15y agoIt looks like it's Pentadactyl (an addon to use Fx with Vim-like key bindings) which provides this behaviour.
- kijin 15y agoFirefox on Windows tends to be more space-efficient than Firefox on Linux or OSX. I don't know why Firefox doesn't draw tabs in the title bar area in Linux (Chrome does), but I heard that it might have to do with some opendesktop standards.
- nuclear_eclipse 15y agoIf you want any chance of a Linux app looking at all "native" to the user's currently selected theme, your best bet is to let the window manager draw the window frame, which includes the title bar and minimize/close buttons. Chrome specifically doesn't try to look native in its default state, but also gives the user the option to let the window manager draw the window frame, to fit in at the expense of using more space overall. This is a side effect of X11 and window manager APIs, as well as the proliferation of competing window managers and widget toolkits like Qt, Gtk, etc.