5 ms·
There is something fundamentally wrong with a UI/UX that takes a literal year to master. I can’t think of a better argument against learning emacs than the titl
by adastra22 4y ago
There is something fundamentally wrong with a UI/UX that takes a literal year to master. I can’t think of a better argument against learning emacs than the title of this submission.
- djaouen 4y agoI guess programming [1] isn’t worth learning, then? [1] https://norvig.com/21-days.html https://norvig.com/21-days.html
- adastra22 4y ago“UI/UX”
- omnicognate 4y ago"Mastering" emacs (certainly any version of "mastering" it that takes a whole year) requires learning a programming language, elisp. This is because emacs isn't an editor. It's a language and environment for rapiy developing textual user interfaces (TUIs) and "customising" or "configuring" it is programming. To just learn to operate it as a text editor certainly doesn't take a year, but if that's the approach you're going to take I wouldn't recommend emacs. Use VS Code or a JetBrains IDE or whatever instead. The linked article isn't very good, BTW. If you're interested in actually mastering emacs, the book "Mastering Emacs" [1], whose author comments here regularly, is the place to start. [1] https://www.masteringemacs.org/ https://www.masteringemacs.org/
- illiarian 4y ago> To just learn to operate it as a text editor certainly doesn't take a year, but if that's the approach you're going to take I wouldn't recommend emacs. Use VS Code or a JetBrains IDE or whatever instead The way this sentence is constructed, it makes VS Code and Jetbrains IDEs sound like just text editors :) In all seriousness though, for the vast majority of programmers Emacs (or vim for that matter) has no value compared to, say, Jetbrains IDEs. You need dozens of plugins and an unknown number lines of arcane configurations just to have a semblance of a small part of functionality that those IDEs have out of the box.
- omnicognate 4y agoThat certainly wasn't the intention of that sentence. Re "has no value" - wevs. It has massive value to me and to a community large enough to have continually supplied me with new and useful functionality and resources for 20 years, most of which have been spent using it alongside either Visual Studio (not "Code") or a JetBrains IDE (mostly Rider, some PyCharm). You use whatever tools you like and I'll decide what tools have value to me.
- bigpeopleareold 4y agoI think a programming language can be viewed as a UI and having a UX: - UI: It's a text based UI that is lazily evaluated (that is, there is always some compilation and/or execution to specifically run for the commands to execute. This UI would fit a certain model of computation, itself being a domain and use-case. - UX: The ergonomics of a programming language, like it's usefulness, accessibility of concepts, its surrounding toolchain, is part of the experience of using this interface to the computer. There is also talk even here on HN about PL features and their utility. That, to me, is a form of user experience. I say this because I think about a programming language's toolchain as the make-or-break aspect of its utility of a language. Can I interface with it well enough without anxiety or anger? :) But, these "lazily evaluated" tools I think form in an aggregate as a user interface to me.
- blahgeek 4y agoIt’s a productivity tool. It also takes months or years to master a professional video editing software like Adobe Premier, or 3D graphics software like Blender. People take time to learn because it’s worth it.
- adastra22 4y agoIt’s a text editor, mail reader, todo manager, etc. none of those things should take a year to master, even in aggregate.
- diffeomorphism 4y agoYep, exactly. So obviously that is not the case.
- otabdeveloper4 4y agoIn reality, Emacs has the gentlest UI/UX of any Unix tool. Emacs has tutorials built-in, is 100 percent documented and all of the moving bits and pieces are discoverable.
- ParetoOptimal 4y agoThe problem is people don't use it's disoverability or built-in help. They do a web search that quickly gives bad to poor advice.
- diffeomorphism 4y agoNonsense. Just like with any software you can be perfectly productive in an afternoon but actual mastery takes time. For instance, for Microsoft Excel the title would probably be "Master Excel in two years"
- wolpoli 4y agoI have read plenty of anecdotes on HN about people choosing the wrong platform. In my opinion, Emacs displays characteristics of a wrong platform to invest time in. I know that Emacs is a very powerful and completely open-source platform, but I have questions about its long-term viability. It's not commonly introduced in CS programs/bootcamps so it'll lead to a declining market share, and its most powerful capabilities require knowledge of LISP, which is not a popular language. Time and energy spent learning Emacs is also non-transferable as it has a one-of-a kind shortcut/user interface. The student will be locked in to Emacs. Students should invest time learning VSCode instead. At least it'll be easy to switch to other products.
- jb1991 4y ago> it has a one-of-a kind shortcut/user interface The system-wide OS keyboard shortcuts for basic text editing in macOS are the same as emacs. I discovered this accidentally and people wonder why I can navigate basic stuff on the mac so well and my answer is "I used emacs for many years."
- wolpoli 4y agoThanks! I was not aware of that.
- mvdwoord 4y agoGNU readline is also all over the place and has emacs like keybindings. https://tiswww.case.edu/php/chet/readline/rltop.html https://tiswww.case.edu/php/chet/readline/rltop.html
- leobg 4y agoWhich shortcuts? You have a link to a list? I only know Cmd-left/right to skip words. But anything more fancy?
- jb1991 4y agoif you are using left/right arrow keys, that is not emacs. Control with F, B, A, E, K, etc are the ones I'm talking about.
- Iridescent_ 4y agoI would not imagine mastering VSCode or any Jetbrains suite product to take any less time.
- jb1991 4y agoThis. Jetbrains is also awesome but you don't just pick it up and msater it in short time.
- raverbashing 4y agoYeah, do they really think "learn in one year" is a compliment? Interesting how they claim it's compatible with vim was an advantage, oh well but aren't you trying to get me away from it? Sure it's a "shorter learning curve" (if they somehow get rid of all the emacsism before getting to that mode and learn nobody has a "meta" key in their computer) I could learn a lot of more fulfilling things than emacs in a year. Guess I'll just stick with vim and vscode
- u801e 4y ago> There is something fundamentally wrong with a UI/UX that takes a literal year to master. You can learn basic navigation in about 5 to 10 minutes reading through emac's built in tutorial. Mastering it means finding a configuration that works for you, or writing your own implementation. I don't use emacs regularly (other than as an info page browser), but I have been using vim for the last 20 years and am still learning new things about it.
- spindle 4y agoI agree. But you should learn Emacs anyway, because mastering such a powerful tool, even if it takes a long time - and even if you don't really need it - is FUN!
- adastra22 4y agoI did and I regret it.
- textread 4y agoWould you please show me a tool with a better UI/UX that can do all the things that emacs can do? Orgmode Magit Dired EXWM . . . this rabbit hole is an endless pursuit of higher and higher efficiency. BTW, the UI/UX is quite customizable with basic elisp fu, using say Helm, Ivy etc.
- oldsecondhand 4y agoI prefer JEdit to Emacs for a programmable editor, but I mostly just use IntelliJ anyway. JEdit carries the philosophy of Emacs, but the UI isn't stuck in the 70s.
- textread 4y agoI just read the JEdit.org homepage. I am really intriuged by this comment over there and also your recommendation: jEdit is a mature programmer's text editor with hundreds (counting the time developing plugins) of person-years of development behind it. Would you please point me to a good resource to learn more about JEdit for someone with Emacs/Vim background.
- adastra22 4y agoFor code editing, pick your IDE. For mail reading, pick your mail reader. For todo, pick your favorite todo app. They’re all better UI/UX.