4 ms·
I am objecting to practice not theory. Hedonic adjustments are argued about quite often because they let the BLS change inflation numbers almost arbitrarily.
by Retric 4y ago
I am objecting to practice not theory.
Hedonic adjustments are argued about quite often because they let the BLS change inflation numbers almost arbitrarily. Your Google Maps example is replacing something that was very cheap with a slightly better version of it that was also very cheap it’s got negligible impact on inflation compared to big ticket items.
Here’s one issue that stuck with me: “While there are arguments that the new goods do exhibit atypical price behavior—entering at a high price and following a “U-shaped cost curve”2—this aspect of the new goods problem is an issue more for sampling than for quality adjustment procedures. Nevertheless, we will argue below that the existence of differential price trends within item categories does have implications for the way in which hedonic regression techniques are implemented.” https://www.bls.gov/pir/journal/gj17.pdf https://www.bls.gov/pir/journal/gj17.pdf
The BLS uses improving outcomes to adjust for healthcare costs. In terms of new treatments that’s perfectly reasonable, but it undermines increased costs for basic treatments like broken bones. People may enjoy higher quality but not if they are priced out of all options.
- gruez 4y ago>Hedonic adjustments are argued about quite often because they let the BLS change inflation numbers almost arbitrarily. except that BLS lists which CPI categories have hedonic adjustments applied[1] and even how it's calculated for some categories[2], so they can't decide to arbitrarily sink energy inflation by saying that gasoline has gotten 50% better. Likewise, because they break out CPI by components, you can calculate a hedonic-less or food-only CPI if you so desire. > Your Google Maps example is replacing something that was very cheap with a slightly better version of it that was also very cheap it’s got negligible impact on inflation compared to big ticket items. It also replaced nearly all the electronics you bought from radio shack back in the day (eg. computer, alarm clock, radio, calculator, cd player, camera/camcorder, cordless phone, tape recorder). Quality improvement also applies to other categories as well, like appliances or cars. Finally, like I said before, the BLS breaks out all the inflation figures by category, so if you really wanted to you could make a "bare minimum to survive" index or whatever, although your initial comment seems to take issue with how the individual categories are calculated rather than how the categories are weighted. >Here’s one issue that stuck with me: I'm not sure what the actual issue is from your quote. Can you reexplain using your own words? >The BLS uses improving outcomes to adjust for healthcare costs. In terms of new treatments that’s perfectly reasonable, but it undermines increased costs for basic treatments like broken bones. People may enjoy higher quality but not if they are priced out of all options. But the CPI seems to be capturing healthcare just fine? Look at how high "hospital services" rose compared to overall inflation. https://www.aei.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/cpi2020-875x1024.png https://www.aei.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/cpi2020-875x1... Moreover, the core issue seems to be "what do you do if things in a category are getting better but people are spending the same or even more on it?". The whole idea behind CPI is that you're supposed to measure price changes for the same goods. In that sense it's obvious that we should lower the CPI even though people are spending more on it. However, I can see where you're coming from given how people conflate "CPI" with "inflation" and "inflation" with "cost of living", the latter of which ignores like-for-like comparison for goods and only looks at cashflow. If you want to measure how has that changed, you'll need to come up with another metric, but I suspect that opens a whole can of worms. eg. how do you compare costs for phones between 2005 and today, if people in 2005 were buying $200 flip phones and today are buying $1000 iPhones, even though a $100 android would totally be serviceable and blow the $200 2005 phone away? [1] https://www.bls.gov/cpi/quality-adjustment/ https://www.bls.gov/cpi/quality-adjustment/ [2] https://www.bls.gov/cpi/quality-adjustment/hedonic-price-adjustment-techniques.htm https://www.bls.gov/cpi/quality-adjustment/hedonic-price-adj...
- Retric 4y ago> It also replaced nearly all the electronics you bought from radio shack back in the day (eg. computer, alarm clock, radio, calculator, cd player, camera/camcorder, cordless phone, tape recorder). Quality improvement also applies to other categories as well, like appliances or cars. Finally, like I said before, the BLS breaks out all the inflation figures by category, so if you really wanted to you could make a "bare minimum to survive" index or whatever, although your initial comment seems to take issue with how the individual categories are calculated rather than how the categories are weighted. Alternatively, multiple cellphones are required to replace a single calculator because they don’t have nearly the lifespan. They need constant recharging as they aren’t solar powered. And that’s not even getting into the UI issues due to a lack of keys etc. Objectively cellphones are a different compromise not a strictly better replacement. (let alone vs a computer.) So again these comparisons are very subjective especially when something has upsides at the cost of dramatically reduced lifespan. The simplest argument for the BLS’s bias is comparing how often they accused of over vs under estimating inflation. PS: Did you consider how fragile that 100$ Android phone is in your comparison? If so how much should you adjust the equivalent price for that fault? Which is the core problem as it’s easy to compare numbers while ignoring say Windows 11’s built in advertising when comparing equipment over time.
- gruez 4y ago>So again these comparisons are very subjective especially when something has upsides at the cost of dramatically reduced lifespan. Yeah a phone might be more fragile than a pocket calculator, but if you need a phone anyways and it comes with a calculator for free, the "replacement" calculator is effectively free and has infinite durability. You can knock off some points for not having tactile buttons, but then again it being effectively weightless and volumeless seems like a benefit. > The simplest argument for the BLS’s bias is comparing how often they accused of over vs under estimating inflation. That's a poor heuristic because even assuming the BLS was 100% accurate, you'd expect more people to complain about CPI being higher than lower. Squeaky wheel gets the grease as the saying goes, and there simply isn't much to complain about for low inflation. There are certainly downsides, but those are more academic/abstract than having to pay for bread with wheelbarrows full of bills. Same goes for conspiracies, eg. "everything is getting more expensive and the government is covering it up!". From there, motivated reasoning takes over and it's just a numbers game.