4 ms·
Talk about a low effort post, many of the numbers used to support the narrative didn’t keep up with inflation. I can’t tell if this post was by the mathematica
by Retric 4y ago
Talk about a low effort post, many of the numbers used to support the narrative didn’t keep up with inflation.
I can’t tell if this post was by the mathematically innumerate or just crafted for the innumerate. For example: “$238 billion, according to a recent Oxfam report, and their wealth increased by $8.8 billion between 2020 and 2022” 208 Billion in 2020 is worth ~238 billion in 2022, so they effectively down ~20 billion. Exact numbers depend on when in 2020 and 2022 their wealth was calculated, but it’s very clear they lost wealth.
Some of these numbers do support their argument but many directly contradict it.
- ceejayoz 4y agoThe article cites lots of specific numbers that are well in excess of the 10% inflation we've seen. It also cites increasing margins.
- bravo22 4y agoYou can increase your margins by double digits and still account for a small fraction of the overall increase. The determining factor is net profit of the grocery industry which is usually 3-5%. If you eliminated that entirely it still wouldn't put a dent in food inflation.
- Jensson 4y ago10% inflation is average, many things will inflate a lot more, but people don't post about stuff that was inflated less.
- Retric 4y agoIf your margins are 4% and they increase by 16% that’s increasing prices by 0.64%. These are competitive industries with sub 5% profit margins being quite common. The simple reality is when companies hedge uncertainty they raise prices a little further than they expect their costs to rise. This is counterproductive when people buy less of their products, but staple food is a rather inelastic market.
- ceejayoz 4y agoThey're not all that low. Tyson's cited in the article: https://www.reuters.com/business/retail-consumer/tyson-foods-beats-revenue-estimates-higher-meat-prices-2022-02-07/ https://www.reuters.com/business/retail-consumer/tyson-foods... > The average price for Tyson's beef surged 31.7% in the quarter ended on Jan. 1, while the unit's operating margins jumped to 19.1% from 13.2% a year ago. Average prices for all of Tyson's products climbed by 19.6%.
- Retric 4y agoI said common not constant, one unit in one company did that well very briefly but overall that’s not abnormal. Some divisions have better quarters than others, and which is on top changes over time. Tyson’s net quarterly profits peaked at 7.9% 3/2022, but it was also 7.4% in 2018. https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/TSN/tyson-foods/profit-margins https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/TSN/tyson-foods/pr... And if you look at their most recent numbers, net profits were 4.5% all of which is very favorable compared to 1.5% in 2012. Overall the tendency is at or below 5%.
- aleksandrm 4y ago[flagged]
- paxys 4y agoGrocery prices aren't "keeping up" with high inflation they are causing high inflation.
- daze42 4y agoHow could grocery stores (and food supply chains) cause inflation?
- sokoloff 4y agoThey’re part of the basket of goods that is measured when stating the official inflation figures.
- daze42 4y agoAh, so you're talking about CPI. Then in that case I agree. It's not clear that CPI == inflation, though.
- dclowd9901 4y agoIn the general case, CPI is how they measure inflation.
- sokoloff 4y agoThings getting more expensive than they used to be is inflation. I can’t see any way that grocery stores raising prices doesn’t “cause inflation”. The act of raising prices is quite literally what causes inflation. (Having currency that devalues is a reason for vendors to demand higher nominal prices, but it’s two sides of the same coin whether the currency is worth less or the goods have a higher price.)
- daze42 4y agoThings in general across the board getting more expensive is a symptom of inflation, true. But I don't see how just a subset of businesses raising prices necessarily causes long term inflation. Even if all the existing grocery stores collude to raise prices together, that would just create market pressure for other grocery stores to pop up that can undercut and obtain a large amount of market share from the colluding businesses. So sure, there may be a blip of "inflation" while the market corrects and the new businesses start up, but overall it shouldn't cause actual inflation.
- Eumenes 4y ago[flagged]
- ctoth 4y agoI submitted this post, and so I suppose that would make me "mathematically innumerate" (which seems a bit like calling someone literately dyslexic.) I submitted it because I noticed that my grocery prices were vastly higher over the last year than the 10% quoted inflation would seem to predict and thought it would be interesting to see what this community thinks. Most of us are shielded from stuff like this, and so also I thought it would be useful to inject a little everyman perspective into our tech bubble :)
- Kiro 4y agoThe quoted 10% is a mean and doesn't imply that all prices are affected evenly.
- lend000 4y agoCPI is also a broken measure due to its inability to measure wealth inequality (sampling median purchasers only) and discretionary hedonic adjustments. Real inflation has likely been ~33% higher than reported for decades (the Big Mac index is probably the true gold standard).
- gruez 4y ago>CPI is also a broken measure due to its inability to measure wealth inequality (sampling median purchasers only) And that's fine, because the CPI's job is to measure how prices have changed (ie. inflation), not wealth inequality. Just because a given metric doesn't support your pet cause doesn't mean it's "broken". It's like complaining GDP is a broken metric because it doesn't measure how oppressed minorities are. > Real inflation has likely been ~33% higher than reported for decades (the Big Mac index is probably the true gold standard). I tried to confirm this and the results were far from conclusive. The big mac index data can be obtained from github[1] and gives a 129.9% increase between april 2000 (earliest data available) and july 2022 (latest data available). To compare this against the CPI data, I checked on FRED and the "Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers: Food Away from Home in U.S. City Average"[2] component of the CPI gives a 87.0% for the same time period. If you take those numbers and convert them to annualized rates, you will indeed find a 33.3% difference between them. Looks like your claim is confirmed, right? But not so fast. The CPI category listed above actually breaks down into more detailed categories, including "Limited service meals and snacks", which presumably the big mac falls into. That data isn't available on FRED but can be found on BLS's data viewer[3] and gives you a 105.8% increase for the same time period. If you convert that to an annualized rate the difference between that and the big mac index drops to 15%. I suspect if we try harder we can eliminate more of the discrepancy. For instance, the "Limited service meals and snacks" index was probably computed from a basket of items, not just big macs. Items that have fatter margins (eg. fries or drinks) might have inflated slower than big macs, thereby dragging the growth of the basket down and explaining the difference. [1] https://github.com/TheEconomist/big-mac-data/ https://github.com/TheEconomist/big-mac-data/ [2] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CUSR0000SEFV https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CUSR0000SEFV [3] https://beta.bls.gov/dataViewer/view https://beta.bls.gov/dataViewer/view
- flandish 4y agoCorrecting numbers is one thing but your post reads like it’s trying to say OP wasn’t good enough so the point is invalid. Let me state it clearer: For industry directly related to life, health, safety, shelter, food, and education, profit is theft via gouged prices mixed with stolen wage. Any amount. No “numbers” needed. This kind of stuff should be nationalized. Especially if the US is as “strong” and smart a nation as we claim we are.