6 ms·
Rippling raises $500M in emergency funds after SVB fails
- yuppie_scum 4y agoRippling is great. Doing everything we need from HR with none of the usual jank. I hope it will scale.
- whitepoplar 4y agoAny other companies you'd recommend as part of the "startup stack"?
- dopeboy 4y agoGusto is an alternative that works well for us.
- dgacmu 4y agoWe moved to Justworks recently and have been happy with them. We considered Gusto on the basis of strong recommendations from friends, but their insurance package for Pittsburgh didn't satisfy. (They're likely totally fine elsewhere or if your company has other needs.) We used to use TriNet. Moderate ugh - we spent two months with them trying to fix an incorrect 401k contribution and their flow is a bit ... Stale? It feels like using workday. We use ADP Canada since Justworks doesn't go there yet. Not as smooth as either Justworks or gusto. We use TravelBank for reimbursements. They're pretty good.
- evntdrvn 4y agoA previous employer used it, and it was dramatically better than any other system that I’ve used. It’s one of those rare providers that I’m happy to promote, and even more remarkable since it’s in a space that is traditionally awful.
- whitepoplar 4y agoAre there any other companies that you would put in the same league as Rippling? (for any products, not just competitors in the same space)
- renewiltord 4y agoGusto is also pretty damn good. These companies handle edge cases poorly but otherwise are okay. For example, we restructured and had to move people to a different LLC and Gusto deleted everyone from GSuite (which had no reason to move). Their FSA administration is total junk. But otherwise it's been great.
- djbusby 4y agoGusto's integration with Human Interest (401k) is pretty crap too. Keeps marking the money in the wrong classification. Good job my accountant found it. Been working for months trying to get it corrected. Gusto can't even follow the thread and each contact I have to start over.
- jlund-molfese 4y agoI actually lead the payroll integrations team at a competitor of Human Interest, and we just finished building out a Gusto integration using the Gusto API. You've tried reaching out to Human Interest, right? Your 401(k) provider should have direct access to Gusto engineers, but most likely, it's a problem on HI's side.
- djbusby 4y agoAll the numbers in HI are correct. Gusto shows the wrong thing.
- jlund-molfese 4y agoYup, but Gusto provides a payroll API, which the benefits provider (in this case, HI) is responsible for using in order to accurately set payroll deductions (and other data) at Gusto for particular employees. Maybe someone who works at HI will see this and chime in—but HI should be able to fix this.
- starkparker 4y agoYeah, because all the "jank" is sent down the pipe to employees. Busted alerts, busted training automations, busted integrations with insurance providers, rounds of incorrect W2s. Maybe it's good for a 50-person company, but it sucks here at 500+.
- cashsterling 4y agoOverall, Rippling is a nice solution. There are some bugs with their authentication and IT hardware management software. Rippling routinely decided to not let employees into MS 365 at the worst times. I had to login to Rippling twice a day on my phone and my business computer... extremely annoying. Their remote management software bricked one of our computers. So... we stopped using Rippling for IT management and authentication. As just an HR platform, there are less expensive options that work fine. We ended up switching away from Rippling a little while ago.
- neonate 4y agohttps://archive.md/v4jnv https://archive.md/v4jnv
- rvnx 4y agoI don't get it, if all SVB clients recovered their funds "thanks" to the government intervention 0 (or 1) business day after the collapse, then how is their money needs related to the situation with SVB ?
- bagels 4y agoI had the same question, which is answered in the article. These events took place before it was known that they would regain access to the funds.
- rvnx 4y agoThanks :) I would take it as a bad news though, because if they raised in a rush, it means they had likely unfavourable conditions, but why not. And if it's money that they didn't need, it means they are paying interest for something they don't use.
- jgalt212 4y agoSo legitimate use do they have for the funds now?
- moralestapia 4y agoQuite impressive to just go out and raise $500M "in a hurry". As other commenters said, it was probably under unfavorable for terms for them. That's bad but if I were an investor w/ them I would be fine with their actions, history could've been different and this same thing would've been an amazing feat. to keep Rippling afloat after "losing" $300M. Great leadership, I think they'll do well!
- Etheryte 4y agoYou're overlooking the minor fact that in the process, SVB as a company functionally ceased to exist. If you're a company and want to keep existing you don't want to end up in that situation.
- PragmaticPulp 4y ago> The deal came together in about 12 hours after Rippling went scrambling when it couldn’t get $300 million that was frozen at SVB when it collapsed on Friday, according to Rippling co-founder Parker Conrad. Raising $500 million emergency cash after just because they lost access to $300 million doesn’t quite add up. This feels more like another funding round that was maybe pushed forward due to SVB concerns.
- lowkey_ 4y agoDuring the SVB crisis, Rippling was holding $300M in SVB, much of which was actually Rippling customers’ money that had been stored by Rippling for March 15th payroll. I’m no lawyer, but when Rippling started emailing me “hey, your payroll money is actually with SVB and we need you to contact your bank to try and reverse the payment,” my first thought was “isn’t it your job to make sure my payroll safely reaches my employees?” I imagine they had to make sure all their customers were made whole and quickly even if SVB money wasn’t able to be recovered, and then decided it would be a good plan to always have more than enough cash to cover the payroll they’re holding for customers.
- ucm_edge 4y agoAt my company they still initially failed to make payroll. Eventually around 6 pm Pacific on the 15th the direct deposits started landing for most people. Although not everyone. I think they did it via some kind of one off point process since I didn’t get an email and the Rippling web app didn’t show me as paid until midday on the 16th. Normally those occur at the same time I see the direct deposit hit. Very unhappy with Rippling here and will advocate my company change processors. They initially acted as if they would cut over to JPMorgan and be fully up on Monday, but as time goes on it becomes clear they had to do a lot more than just change the account they staged payroll through. They also failed to have a secondary banking relationship in place, credit revolvers or other contingencies that let them handle this in house, etc. In 30 years of getting paid and working through times like 2008 when major disruption to banking and credit availability occurred, to me Rippling stands alone as the only company that failed to run payroll on time and it took a single point of failure to make them fall.
- the_cat_kittles 4y ago[flagged]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- coding123 4y ago[flagged]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- spawn_camp 4y ago[flagged]
- gkoberger 4y agoThere was no "bailout". As of right now, the government hasn't spent a dollar on SVB. It might have to eventually, if SVB continues to see a run, but as of right now the government hasn't put any money into the bank.
- landemva 4y agoFDIC has spent funds. Drawdowns in FDIC reserves will be caught up with future assessments on insured banks. Anyone with a bank account will pay, though silently. Edit: I am interested in seeing something published by FDIC which shows precise amounts, if anyone has that. I presume it could be ~ 250k * count(accounts).
- ivalm 4y agoNo, for now SVB assets are enough to pay for all of the drawdown. It is unclear if SVB will actually run out of assets.
- landemva 4y agoFor now the Fed's newly created bank funding term loan mechanism is plugging the hole by having the Fed take underwater bonds at face value. SVB was solvent two weeks ago with mark-to-maturity accounting of their underwater bond holdings. SVB, from a bank accounting perspective, became insolvent when they sold the long duration bonds for a loss. At market prices of the bonds, SVB could not continue within bank accounting regulations. I suspect they will recover 90%-some.
- ivalm 4y agoI suspect they will repay 100% as they will find a buyer/not have to actually liquidate. Remember, they had net positive interest, so as long as they can continue holding to maturity they are entirely solvent.
- triyambakam 4y agoIsn't it crazy to hold $300M just sitting in the bank? I have pennies for a net worth comparatively and I was taught to keep my money spread around, and not all of it just in cash in the bank. But also, I am ignorant to how a start up operates.
- sparker72678 4y agoRippling processes payroll for many companies, so they often have substantial amounts of money (which came from those companies) sitting in the bank, about to be paid out to employees.
- ucm_edge 4y agoYou don’t have to use a singular bank to this. You have can have numerous banks in and sweep the money around to control exposure to any one bank. A single bank is not the norm for this kind of setup. Sweep accounts are a thing for this very reason.
- x0x0 4y agoFor long term holding, sure. For funds that move in and out in 48 hours? I doubt any bank wants money bouncing in and out like that. They probably pay svb, and now jpm, to be allowed to do that.
- makestuff 4y agoYeah my first thought was I am absolutely shocked that they used SVB exclusively until 9 months ago. Now they use JPM, but what if JPM has an issue? You would think a payroll company would integrate with at least 2-3 of the bulge bracket banks…
- dig1 4y agoUsing sweep accounts is considered an investment (of client funds), which must be clearly stated in TOS. This also pulls tons of regulations for the company. There is also a higher chance that one of the sweep account investments goes badly than a bank collapses where you hold client funds.
- m3kw9 4y agoThought the money was available guaranteed by fed by following monday
- muzz 4y agoThe whole article appears to be about a few hours on Friday The entire SVB situation was made to be much ado about nothing by self-promoters. You didn't see veterans from Sequoia, Kleiner, etc, screaming on Friday.
- 71a54xd 4y agoVC's are licking their chops - SVB fallout even though most of the fire was put out is leading to many of these companies forfeiting more equity to raise quick cash.
- nntwozz 4y agoThe Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) closed 465 failed banks from 2008 to 2012. In contrast, in the five years prior to 2008, only 10 banks failed. Things could get much worse.
- elijahbenizzy 4y agoRippling is awesome, no complaints as a founder. That said, does anyone know how much of this sale was Parker conrad’s own shares?
- lxgr 4y agoWhat do you mean by "sale"? The article reads to me like a normal funding round, i.e. issuing additional shares. A shareholder selling shares wouldn‘t increase equity.
- gnicholas 4y agoFrom the TC article [1], which is a bit more detailed: > Though Conrad might have tried backing out of the arrangement, instead, says Mehta, Conrad called him three minutes after the Federal Reserve made its statement on Sunday, reaffirming it. So he didn't end up needing the funding but knew it was the right thing to do to move forward with the investment (and the dilution it undoubtedly entailed). Good to see this sort of honorable behavior, even in the worst of times. 1: https://techcrunch.com/2023/03/17/a-500-million-term-sheet-in-12-hours-how-rippling-struck-a-deal-as-svb-was-melting-down/ https://techcrunch.com/2023/03/17/a-500-million-term-sheet-i...
- ilrwbwrkhv 4y agoHe’s also a big fan of Conrad’s, who resigned from corporate software startup Zenefits amid accusations of skirting regulations and ultimately settled with the US Securities and Exchange Commission. “I would shout from the rooftop that this is a person who operates with high integrity,” Mehta said. Lol. Seems like another Sequoia style fanboy in the making.
- simonebrunozzi 4y ago> Rippling’s existing investors include Kleiner Perkins, Sequoia Capital, Coatue Management and Founders Fund.
- ilrwbwrkhv 4y agoAah the good old squad.
- tomhoward 4y agoHe went too far with regulatory shenanigans - nearly a decade ago, and paid a big price (lost the company he built and loved, personally paid half a million in fines). People do stupid/risky things when young/desperate, and most learn and grow. That seems to be the case here and is normal and healthy. Not every case of wrongdoing is equivalent to the worst known/imaginable cases of wrongdoing.
- jiveturkey 4y agoSo Rippling took on an extra 4% dilution, without an increase in valuation to show for it, because of SVB liquidity? Why didn't they just take an emergency loan?
- matt3210 4y agoDo they handle harassment? Or just financial sides of HR?
- rvivek 4y agoWow, I'm surprised at the level of cynicism here. As a startup, the last thing on your mind is trying to optimize for a situation when a major bank collapses that too in a matter of days. There are many more urgent fires to put off. Sure, as a payroll company, you may wonder if this is indeed an edge case they need to take care of but the way the team, VCs harnessed in such a short period of time to delight customers is commendable. Think about all the things that needed to happen. --> Move the primary banking provider from SVB to JPMC. --> Get a set of engineers to have all-nighters to ensure the new payment system actually works. This is hundreds of millions of dollars worth of risk. --> Raise $500m(?!!) in 48 hours to fund the payroll without any assurance from FDIC whether depositors are going to get the money back or not. --> While doing all of this, respond to a massive influx of support tickets. What this really shows is they are willing to go to a crazy extent (raise $500m in 48 hours!) to delight customers. FWIW, I'm not affiliated with Rippling in any way but I do have a ton of respect for Parker for his ability to bounce back after the Zenefits debacle.
- voganmother42 4y agoAs a customer, are you delighted if the outcome is effectively that they did not fail to provide service? Glorifying heroes and all nighters…more like celebrating a near miss/catastrophe
- rat9988 4y agoCoud they have done any better?
- voganmother42 4y agois that your standard for delight? As a customer I am not sure I would even be delighted to not have to worry in the first place? Like great your business didn’t fail and cause me more issues - do I get a discount now for all the stress? As James Acaster might say, I am too good for a free banana, and il reserve my delight for situations where I am actually delighted, not just delighted to not be up a creek ;)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sroussey 4y agoFor god sakes, why did they have to wire the money to themselves first, then to employees rather than run the payments from their customers’ accounts?
- lxgr 4y agoHow would they initiate payments from their customers' accounts? That would require a level of access that probably few companies would be comfortable with, to say nothing of dozens or hundreds of banking integrations, since I don‘t think there is a universally supported standard API for this type of thing in the US…
- muzz 4y agoThe article seems to be at odds with Garry's assertion just 20 seconds in to this clip: https://www.cnbc.com/video/2023/03/10/y-combinators-garry-tan-estimates-hundreds-of-startups-will-be-unable-to-make-payroll-after-svb-closure.html https://www.cnbc.com/video/2023/03/10/y-combinators-garry-ta...