3 ms·
You're a direct target for the article. Quoting: "brighteyed beginners who believe that the old ones must have been doing it wrong" People have been trying a
by bryanlarsen 15y ago
You're a direct target for the article. Quoting: "brighteyed beginners who believe that the old ones must have been doing it wrong"
People have been trying and failing for 40 years to improve CS teaching. Granted, most professors don't try and just teach the way it's always been taught, but some, like you, do.
The big question then becomes: is this an impossible problem, or simply a very hard one? When you start teaching, you will find that a certain percentage of your students fail to "get it". Will this be your fault? Probably not. At the very least, to "get it" requires effort, and some of your students won't put in that effort, and you can't force them to. There are many ways you can encourage the effort, but you can't force it.
What we can do, though, is shift the goalposts. Turn a 70% failure rate into a 30% one into a 10% one into a 2% one, et cetera. It looks like csunplugged is one of those tools that will shift those goalposts.
- gatlin 15y agoTo start, I agree with you 100% on all accounts. Some students may truly never succeed but I think that by declaring the case closed and assuming it's purely a function of student ability, we lose out on valuable information about humans learn because: what if that's wrong? The fact that the goalposts can be moved is awesome and a testament to what can happen if we assume that it's a communication or motivation problem, not student ability. There are lots of fringe students who just think oddly. Living in cooperative housing in Austin has really driven this home. They require odd teachers.