3 ms·
As an industry, if we can consider software broadly as one industry, it is disappointing that we simply do not have a quality and correctness and safety culture
by jeffbee 4y ago
As an industry, if we can consider software broadly as one industry, it is disappointing that we simply do not have a quality and correctness and safety culture. It has been true for decades and still appears to be true that the more hidden a program is from the user, the more slapdash its implementation will be. Device firmware is universally garbage. It's just like that TPM 2.0 reference implementation thing that was on HN earlier this week. It's just written by clowns in clown language and when they find the flaws instead of fixing the process that led to the flaws they just put in one more line of ClownLang to hack around it. Something from outside the industry needs to come in with some reform mandates.
- _trampeltier 4y agoJust pure and real pain will bring changes. So the only way is more ransomeware.
- baal80spam 4y agoWell... Microsoft ditched its QA unit a while ago. My employer posts multiple (10+) marketing and sales job openings currently on Linkedin but there is no money for an additional "QA resource". The list goes on, and this is one of the effects.
- wkat4242 4y agoYes. Over-reliance on automated tests and telemetry (aka testing on the users) is a problem in the industry and Microsoft is big into these. Unit tests are great but mainly look for things you expect and focus on the low having fruit. Not complex interactions between components. Their QA teams used to test on all kinds of hardware but most of it was replaced by automated VM stuff.
- jeffbee 4y agoThe firmware industry has a variety of problems and "over-reliance on automated tests" is decidedly not among them.