3 ms·
Maybe it's my non-Apple user perspective, but Catalyst has always been quite a strange product. The theory behind why Apple won't just add a touch screen option
by jeroenhd 4y ago
Maybe it's my non-Apple user perspective, but Catalyst has always been quite a strange product. The theory behind why Apple won't just add a touch screen option to their Macbooks already is that macOS wasn't designed for touch so the experience would be terrible, which I can understand, but then they released this tool to xopy/paste phone apps to their desktop plarfoem
Surely Apple has seen Windows 8 and realised these touch approaches will always be suboptimal at best for non-touch devices? Surely they realise that such platforms are doomed if you don't implement the same system APIs on every target OS?
Maybe I'm a bit cynical, but I don't understand why users would be interested in these applications. I'd much rather have an Electron app than a weird cross platform abomination myself.
- Dalewyn 4y ago>Surely Apple has seen Windows 8 and realised these touch approaches will always be suboptimal at best for non-touch devices? Windows 8's demise stems from its schizophrenic design language, something Windows still suffers to this day (though it's getting better). Touch interactions in and of itself on Windows is fine and sufficiently servicable. It's not as quick as keyboard nor as comfortable as mouse, but it certainly works and is by far the most intuitive to the touchscreen generation.
- jeroenhd 4y agoVery true, if you have a touch screen then Windows will work fine. However, macOS doesn't have touch screen support, so the change in paradigm will be as jarring as during the introduction of Windows 8, back when desktops and laptops had didn't get produced with touch screens except for extremely niche models. WinRT was an excellent platform to use (with no apps to take advantage of the hardware) but Windows 8 on a non-tablet is as jarring as mobile apps running on desktop. They work, but that's about all the good things you can say about them.
- favaq 4y agoI have never used one, but I will never understand in what situations does a touchscreen on a desktop or a laptop make any sense at all. Maybe if I used one it would click for me but I don't get it. I imagine myself poking the screen of a laptop, the whole thing wobbling, all full of greasy fingerprints... it makes me cringe.
- newaccount74 4y agoI thought the same until I got a surface studio. The touch screen itself is useful when multiple people use a computer. Much nicer if everyone can interact with the screen vs. asking the person holding the mouse to scroll down a bit. But the real game changer is the stylus. Annotating PDFs, signing contracts, kids doing school worksheets, the whiteboard app... It's amazing how much more naturally you can interact with a computer if you can just draw on it. I love my big iMac, I just wish it came with a stylus.
- Dalewyn 4y ago>But the real game changer is the stylus. Annotating PDFs, signing contracts, kids doing school worksheets, the whiteboard app... It's amazing how much more naturally you can interact with a computer if you can just draw on it. This is understated. Sometimes, you need to sign documents electronically, and let me tell you all: Trying to sign with a mouse is fucking miserable. I say that as someone who knows and breathes computer, too; the common man finds it downright intolerable. Scribbling with a finger, let alone writing/drawing with a freaking pen, is an astronomical leap in intuitive usability.
- jeroenhd 4y agoIt just makes sense sometimes. We're at the point where every web page and operating system control is large enough to be hit with a finger anyway, why go through the effort of getting a virtual pointer to hover over it when you can just tap it? The button is _right there_! For most of computer history, we've used tools to simulate putting our fingers on something (cursors becoming hands when tapping interactive elements, for example) and to get there, we've used a virtual finger controlled by a mouse, touch pad, track ball, or anything else that gets two dimensional movement across to the screen. We're finally at the point that we don't need the intermediate technology anymore, except perhaps for precision work. Windows 8 has had excellent gesture support since Windows 8 and if you enable the right settings (tablet mode, for one) browsing the web becomes quite tablet-like on a laptop. On a desktop I don't think it would make too much sense outside of a digital artist's environment. If your laptop has a flimsy hinge or a screen that stains easily, it probably won't make sense to use its screen as a touch screen (unless it folds all the way back). However, in my experience, most laptops that aren't designed to be as thin as possible will hold up quite nicely if you touch their screens. Our phones are perfectly usable when we put our greasy fingers all over them, so why would a laptop screen be any different? You don't need a lot of force to operate a touch screen, we're not constantly flinging our phones across the room when we need to tap something. It's just a matter of mounting and treating the screen right. If your screen gets to a reasonable brightness, you probably won't even notice the finger grease. Touch screens on computers aren't for everyone, but most people that have tried them don't seem to want to go back. I haven't used one for an extensive amount of time myself, but I can definitely see the appeal.