3 ms·
> If the US had proportional representation, all of those policies would have been enacted at earlier points through the same mechanic that is in effect in Euro
by rayiner 4y ago
> If the US had proportional representation, all of those policies would have been enacted at earlier points through the same mechanic that is in effect in Europe.
The U.S. is much more socially conservative than Europe, which has to do with being much more religious than Europe: https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2019/05/01/with-high-levels-of-prayer-u-s-is-an-outlier-among-wealthy-nations/ https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2019/05/01/with-high-l....
Proportional voting would probably make the U.S. even more conservative. Currently, the Democratic Party is a coalition of more socially liberal whites and more conservative/moderate minorities and immigrants. For example, here is the Democratic mayor of New York City complaining about the 1962 Supreme Court that banned school prayer: https://www.christianpost.com/news/nyc-mayor-says-it-was-a-mistake-to-take-prayer-out-of-schools.html https://www.christianpost.com/news/nyc-mayor-says-it-was-a-m.... A multi-party proportional system would give this segment more independent political power and weaken liberals.
> Harvard and Yale graduates are among the conservative segments of east coast old money types that keep the reactionary traits of the US society going since early 19th century.
Incorrect. The "east coast old money types" are among the most socially liberal of the subgroups of the U.S., and Harvard and Yale are extremely liberal on social issues.
> If you said MIT, Berkeley, Caltech etc, your shaky proposition about 'liberals' could have been more credible.
Engineering schools like MIT and CalTech are actually more socially conservative than schools like Harvard and Yale. STEM workers in general are more conservative on average: https://scholarworks.unr.edu/handle/11714/2246 https://scholarworks.unr.edu/handle/11714/2246
> But as it stands it now contradicts itself by proposing that the conservative types of the old aristocracy who spearheaded the Reaganite movement have legislated progressive legislation against their own voter base.
There was no legislation, but that's close to what happened. The Reagan GOP was a coalition of often socially liberal big business types, and religious conservatives in the midwest and south. Nixon and Reagan appointed a bunch of libertarian-leaning Supreme Court justices, who's often defected to the liberal side on social issues. Roe was written by a Nixon appointee (and a Harvard grad). Casey was written by a Reagan appointee, joined by another Reagan appointee (and Harvard grad). Obergefell was written by a Reagan appointee and Harvard grad.
Now that the Democratic Party is friendly to big business, most of the “old money” types are democrats. 90% of Wall Street donated to Hilary Clinton.
> The behavior of far-right nationalist and religious fundamentalist groups anywhere on the planet are identical: If there wasn't these 'issues' that you speak of, they would be mad about something else just like how similar groups elsewhere in the world are.
Not so. In my home country of Bangladesh, there hasn't been much of a "reactionary" movement since Islam was reinstated as the official religion in the 1980s. "Reactionaries" are by definition are reacting to change. That’s where the term comes from—reactionary movements rise in response to revolutionary movements.
> I dont know which one is your home country. However even speaking in the context of the US, secularism was and still is one of the fundamental tenets of the Age of Enlightenment that made the modern society, more importantly, the scientific revolution, possible. Before that, religious institutions and the religious elite and power groups were intervening in both politics and science and hampering the scientific progress. Any society that was not able to adopt it before 19th century started, was retarded in development and they either were conquered or made satellites by the countries that did adopt it. Which means that this is an excellent example of how it is necessary for society to prevent such fundamentalism and the fundamentalists that propagate it from sabotaging itself.
You're conveniently forgetting the U.S., which was founded by a bunch of religious fundamentalists that quite consciously distanced themselves from the European enlightenment. But became much more successful than continental Europe. Meanwhile, continental Europe has become so culturally decrepit that they have lost the will to perpetuate their society and are being replaced by Muslims.
But I'm not debating religion with you. My point is that if went into Bangladesh and legalized same-sex marriage by court order because you think your morality is better than the morality of stupid villagers, you should expect a "reaction." That's basically what liberals have been doing in America for decades. The reaction to that isn't some Bircher conspiracy, it's a natural cause-and-effect.
- unity1001 4y ago> The U.S. is much more socially conservative than Europe, which has to do with being much more religious than Europe Thats a misconception. The main conservative voting blocs in both locations have the same kind of weight and cloud if reflected in a proportional system. > A multi-party proportional system would give this segment more independent political power and weaken liberals Nope. Like the above, the main driving blocs would remain mostly the same in their talking points, while many separate parties would align, cooperate and make coalition with the main drivers. You are also missing the fact that the reason why people coalesce in such big 'broad umbrellas' in the US is because they have to do it. > Incorrect. The "east coast old money types" are among the most socially liberal of the subgroups of the U.S., and Harvard and Yale are extremely liberal on social issues. The recent finance/media cliques can be said to be so. However we were talking about the traditional heritage of the US. And in history, it is as I described. > Engineering schools like MIT and CalTech are actually more socially conservative than schools like Harvard and Yale. STEM workers in general are more conservative on average: https://scholarworks.unr.edu/handle/11714/2246 https://scholarworks.unr.edu/handle/11714/2246 We were not talking about social conservatism. We were talking about anti-intellectualism, secularism. A MIT grad being more socially conservative on gay marriage or LGTBT rights does not mean that he or she will be tolerant to anti-intelectualism or will support anti-intellectual, anti-scientific policies of middle America. > Roe was written by a Nixon appointee Again, you are getting stuck on peripheral social issues while losing the gist of the argument. Anti-intellectualism is something that has a much bigger scope than the abortion debacle or LGBT rights. > Not so. In my home country of Bangladesh, there hasn't been much of a "reactionary" movement since Islam was reinstated as the official religion in the 1980s. My good man, if the islamism has already taken over, it means that you reactionary movements have already won. Which means that they existed way before that, and they were at work to achieve precisely that objective. Which means that your secular society did not encompass everyone and did not try to bring all the amenities of modern science, technology and social advance to those people through education, social programs, employment and the like. They remained poor and destitute, seeking help from religious groups instead. Which is a perfect fit for Islam since Islam already has such charity/solidarity organizations built into the religion. Again, its a perfect case that fits the pattern I described. > You're conveniently forgetting the U.S., which was founded by a bunch of religious fundamentalists that quite consciously distanced themselves from the European enlightenment That's false. The leaders of the American Rebellion were followers of the Enlightenment, and some even were way beyond just being followers. Thomas Paine even served a few terms in French Revolutionary parliament as a MP. From Washington to Jefferson, the leaders of the rebellion were way too radicals for their time, even in the issue of slavery. The sole reason that the concept 'America is not founded on religion' exists is because of those radicals. And it was one of them who explicitly said that. > Meanwhile, continental Europe has become so culturally decrepit that they have lost the will to perpetuate their society and are being replaced by Muslims This sounds like your personal opinion fueled on your personal perceptions without any statistical or historical basis. The percentage of muslims in Europe is 6%, and this includes those who dont practice. The reason Europe is faltering is precisely because the center-right conservative types are implementing Reaganism for the last 40 years and their projects of privatization, profiteering are finally having their effects visible. > The reaction to that isn't some Bircher conspiracy, it's a natural cause-and-effect Anti-intellectualism and gay marriage are not things that are in the same rank. Anti-intellectualism existed before anyone 'forced' anything on anybody and it wanted people to live like the Amish or Mormons then, and it does so even today. If the late 19th century seculars have not forced secular modernism on the society, they would succeed to do so, as can be seen from how backwards the Middle East remained due to rejection of science. Your personal biases are causing you to make extreme extrapolations and lose sight of the core subject.