3 ms·
> We are committed to protecting the benefits we have, fixing historical disparities within and across departments, and promoting equitable conditions and econo
by andsoitis 4y ago
> We are committed to protecting the benefits we have, fixing historical disparities within and across departments, and promoting equitable conditions and economic stability for all of our colleagues. Whether it’s access to paid time off or the security of knowing our salaries will grow to meet economic necessity,
and
> When we use our voices, we do so because we care about the future of Bandcamp
These two "principles" are in tension with each other, so it will be interesting to see how selfless (do what's best for Bandcamp, even it means I need to lose my job or get paid less or get less time off etc. etc.) or how selfish this group will be.
- CuriousCosmic 4y ago> These two "principles" are in tension with each other, so it will be interesting to see how selfless (...) or how selfish this group will be. These aren't really in tension with each other at all. > (do what's best for Bandcamp, even it means I need to lose my job or get paid less or get less time off etc. etc.) Unions aren't particularly afraid of layoffs. They'll fight reductions in force (RIF) and unnecessary layoffs but the main focus is guaranteeing that those individuals who are let go get compensated adequately and are provided a sufficient cushion to bounce back and find their next job. When it comes to priorities, number 1 and 2 are equally that the company survives and benefits are not cut. If you have to let people go to meet those priorities that is fine but as soon as you start carving away at peoples' hard earned benefits, then all of a sudden any perceived bump in the road can be used to undermine the union and your benefits.
- zztop44 4y agoThere will be times when those principles are in tension, yes, but they’re not contradictory. Bandcamp is created by workers. In most instances, what’s best for the workers as a collective is also what’s best for Bandcamp as a company.
- andsoitis 4y agoRank and file employees are neither in a position (vantage point, perspective), nor have the judgment (should a new grad have equal “say” to someone more experienced) to make big strategic decisions. One “solution” is to make big decisions by committee / vote, but then there’s no accountability or responsibility. If workers want to control their destiny they should buy the company so they have real skin in the game, not tell shareholders/owners that they know what’s best…
- alex_sf 4y agoThis is complete fantasy. What's objectively best for the company is to get the most value from their labor for the least cost. This is not in the interest of the workers.
- porbelm 4y agoWell yes, and in the U.S. that "least cost" is slave labor. It doesn't have to be, though. Do you think the EU/western Europe has lower worker efficiency even though we have a five-day week, four or five weeks vacation time a year, and eight hour work days with relatively generous overtime compensation? And businesses pay more taxes on their workforce, the state spends lots on healthcare, etc etc. Many countries are even talking about doing four-day weeks or six-hour days. It is in the interest of the company to have happy, productive workers that stay because they enjoy their life and work. That is best done with generous compensation and whatever allows for a good work/life balance.
- alex_sf 4y ago> Do you think the EU/western Europe has lower worker efficiency even though we have a five-day week, four or five weeks vacation time a year, and eight hour work days with relatively generous overtime compensation? Yes. https://www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/jep.22.1.25 https://www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/jep.22.1.25
- scaramanga 4y agoBeware the people conflating efficiency with "productivity" productivity is just earnings divided by payroll. If you sack half of your workers, your productivity will approximately double. But not for long.
- scaramanga 4y agoThat is only good for the company if your notion of company ignores the needs of one faction of people (those who generate value) and prioritises the needs of another group (those who extract value). If we are going to have malicious and incompetent people in the society, I am of the opinion that they should sink to the bottom, not rise to the top. You, apparently, believe the opposite. Of course, you are quite free to continue with that preference.
- scaramanga 4y agoIt will be interesting. As we've seen, capitalism has constantly driven itself in to crisis with those at the top always managing to protect themselves. Maybe the rest of us will get a chance to insulate ourselves from our own incompetence rather than being simply crushed by management and laid off when their bad decisions have come home to roost. If we're going to have crises, I'd rather they be of my own making, and I'd rather be looked out for.