3 ms·
Timing is only one aspect of creativity. In most settings a video camera’s output is copyrighted because of how you select the location and angel to film. Mot
by Retric 4y ago
Timing is only one aspect of creativity.
In most settings a video camera’s output is copyrighted because of how you select the location and angel to film. Motion capture has all of those elements, and simply doesn’t capture 99.9% of the possible images. ie: Someone picked a log crossing the river as a place where something interesting will happen and they setup the shot to look interesting.
Which is the general argument why such setups fall under copyright. Though as always there are many edge cases.
- World177 4y agoThere was a case last year where a person sued a content creator on YouTube for distributing parts of their accidental livestream. [1] The argument for fair use was that there was no creative input, so fair use. Though, I really do not know, as I think images and videos can be copyrighted exactly for the reason in your comment. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Uk1Tzqc5vk4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Uk1Tzqc5vk4
- hammock 4y agoHow is setting up a motion camera on a log not similar to setting up a prompt for ChatGPT?
- brookst 4y agoThe camera doesn’t decide what to put on the picture?
- hammock 4y agoIt does… or at least the human doesn’t.. it’s motion activated
- Retric 4y agoMotion capture rigs are doing capture whatever trees/rocks/buildings etc the person setting it up aimed at. The only thing motion capture does is pick interesting times, but you can write software that does the same thing with a video.
- olyjohn 4y agoThe camera is not making a decision. The human made the decision to set the camera up to take pictures when motion activated.
- Natsu 4y agoYeah, I think in the general case there's going to be a significant amount of selection and arrangement of the works from the AI, though I guess that even then none of the underlying images (or such) of the AI get protection. I wonder if they know about the "inpainting" technique where the human generates an image, erases parts of it, then adds another image and has the AI fill in the blanks and make a new image based on the resulting image? I think that'd be harder to disentangle the way they do right now to say these parts are copyrightable because the human did them and those parts are not because the AI did them since you can't really separate the inputs at that point.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 4y agoI would argue that location and angle to film are analogous to specifying that you want a poem (as opposed to an essay) about copyright law (as opposed to quantum mechanics) in the style of William Shakespeare (as opposed to John Milton). Basically, those are very broad parameters specified, and the machine is the one that decides to produce the output. You aren't even picking the timing or the subject or likely even the focal length. The machine is doing that based on its algorithms (and with autofocus) even the focal length.
- Retric 4y agoIt’s not just location and angle but where to aim the motion capture sensor, what if any bait to use etc. There’s effectively infinitely many possible ways to set of these things. With chat bot’s every possible response is predetermined when the algorithm is setup. Saying you should get copyright is like saying you should own the results of a search engine response to your query.
- phire 4y agoThere is so many places to inject creativity into the process. Before the capture you have: Chosing the location, posing the camera, adjusting objects in the background, setting up bate to attract wildlife, choosing optimal camera settings. Even selecting a camera could be considered a creative input. After the capture, the artist can choose which of the thousands of captures best fits their vision, crop it and applying color correction. I don't think a single one of those actions can make it a creative work on its own. But when you combine a few of them along with intent, it becomes a creative work.
- nickthegreek 4y agoYou can do most of that with prompting and tools like control net in stable diffusion as well. And then take it into photoshop and do changes, feed it back into img2img and inpaint until your hearts content. One can spend multitudes more time than it too to tap the shutter button on an iPhone. In Midjourney of course, you have far less control.
- pmoriarty 4y agoThere's a ton of control that prompt crafting alone gives you. There's also the choice of which version of midjourney to use, and various meta options that it gives you. The copyright office clearly has not the slightest clue about what they're talking about when they claim that the AI is the sole creator here. AI generated content has always been a collaboration with humans, and there's always human creativity involved.
- Retric 4y agoYou can own the copyright to the prompt used to generate the output. But the algorithm isn’t collaborating, every possible outcome is fixed when the algorithm is finalized and users can’t actually change the possibilities. I clearly don’t own the copyright to my Google search results even if my query is quite unique.
- pmoriarty 4y ago