7 ms·
This is all very sane and consistent with previous opinions on the matter. But it doesn’t answer any tough questions either, like: if an AI model outputs somet
by kube-system 4y ago
This is all very sane and consistent with previous opinions on the matter.
But it doesn’t answer any tough questions either, like: if an AI model outputs something very close to a training input, does the result infringe on the copyrights of the input work?
- kirubakaran 4y agoAnd how close is too close?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- petesergeant 4y agoYou can get ChatGPT to output copyright material very easily
- shagie 4y agoYou can get ChatGPT to output copyright material very easily. You can also copy and paste from an existing copyrighted work. In either case, it is you, the human - with agency to do so - who should be liable for the content that you publish.
- kube-system 4y agoThat’s the concern. You can easily identify when you are copying others work when done directly. If you use a black box that sometimes gives you infringing output, how do you use it with confidence?
- shagie 4y agoYou can use it, just don't use it for things that you publish without doing sufficient diligence to see if that work would be infringing on something else. I intend to make an e-ink panel that displays woodcut style images generated by stable diffusion (get a list of a 30 or so different descriptions of scenes, and have them slowly get generated over the day and display a different one each hour). So, here's the question - are any of those woodcut images derivative of some other work? Don't know - and it likely doesn't matter as it would be something hanging on a wall in a room. On the other hand, if I was to collect them and publish them as a book, then I, as the human who is publishing them, would need to do sufficient diligence to see if any of them are derivative works. They might be - but I am the one publishing it then - not Stable Diffusion. Likewise, if I was creating a collection of epic rap battles between historical figures as generated by GPT... then I should search to make sure that none of the phrases that are used in there are lifted directly from some other source. Again, it is me as the human with agency that is publishing it, not GPT. If you were to go to Fiverr and request 100 pictures of woodcuttings or people to write epic rap battles between Julius Caesar and Ghengis Khan - would it matter if it was a human lifted the text or GPT? It is still upon you, the person publishing it to do the check.
- kube-system 4y agoYou are right, but AI products are basically all currently being pitched as if that is unnecessary.
- karmasimida 4y agoThis article talks about what is copyrightable. Your question is about infringement of already copyrighted material.
- kube-system 4y agoYes, I understand it was out of the scope of this article. I’m just saying, these are the easier questions to answer.
- layer8 4y agoThat’s why they are being answered first. The others take more time.
- kube-system 4y agoA lot of these things are already addressed on USPTO’s FAQs and these answers are the same but “with AI” tacked on. eg: “only human works are subject to copyright”, “the work must be an original work of authorship”, etc. It’s just disappointing that they haven’t produced anything helpful yet. I suspect that the result will end up being permissive because there will be a big industry built up around people just kicking the can down the road by the time anyone authority issues a more specific opinion.
- lIl-IIIl 4y agoThe statement addresses this: >The Office recognizes that AI-generated works implicate other copyright issues not addressed in this statement. It has launched an agency-wide initiative to delve into a wide range of these issues. Among other things, the Office intends to publish a notice of inquiry later this year seeking public input on additional legal and policy topics, including how the law should apply to the use of copyrighted works in AI training and the resulting treatment of outputs.
- kube-system 4y agoI think that the answer they want to say is, “it probably does”, but they don’t want to say it and cause a big disruption to commerce until the courts intervene.
- lucubratory 4y agoThere is precedent in Authors' Guild vs Google and Perfect 10 vs Google that it doesn't, this isn't the first time things like this have come before the courts. There are also laws to consider. I know this is US law and the US doesn't have those laws, but copyright harmonisation is a thing and the EU, UK, Japan etc all have laws very explicitly stating that TDM is an exemption to copyright - some bodies would presumably consider that. And finally, there's national security. The US's current view is that it's in an existential great power competition with Chinese society, and needs to compete on every level to succeed. One of those levels is very explicitly AI, it's considered a main "battlefront" in the new Cold War. If the US significantly restricts TDM, that not only makes it less competitive compared to jurisdictions that don't like the UK, EU, Japan, and China, but it specifically improves the effectiveness of the Thousand Talents program which the US IC and analyst community view as a very serious threat. Academics want to be able to do their research, AI is critically important to US national security, and currently the US is statistically the best place to be an AI researcher. The government won't want to jeopardize that when China is already advancing in AI very rapidly and actively trying to tempt scientists to come over with better pay and conditions.
- eternalban 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- weavejester 4y ago> This is all very sane and consistent with previous opinions on the matter. Is that sarcasm?
- kube-system 4y agoNot at all. There’s literally nothing in this article that would go against ideas already covered in an introductory lecture in copyright law.
- weavejester 4y agoThanks for the clarification; I wasn't sure how you meant it.
- andreareina 4y agoAdding context: this decision for example follows naturally from the monkey selfie case.
- rhino369 4y agoI don’t think that question is very tough. It’s almost certainly copyright infringement. The method of copying doesn’t really matter.
- kube-system 4y agoWell, I more mean that the answer that many suspect is the case, is tough to swallow. In that case, the consequence would be: If you don’t validate that your AI model is producing something sufficiently different than all of the inputs, you’ve created a copyright infringement Russian roulette.
- rhino369 4y agoYep. And DMCA safe harbor doesn’t apply, so there won’t be much of a defense if it happens.