6 ms·
Imagine the devastation wrought by automatic looms, that put all the weavers out of a job! 97% of jobs used to be working on the farm. Now it's something like
by WalterBright 4y ago
Imagine the devastation wrought by automatic looms, that put all the weavers out of a job!
97% of jobs used to be working on the farm. Now it's something like 2%.
- moffkalast 4y agoCan't wait for the economy that is 97% twitch streamers because that's all what humans are left qualified for. /s
- msm_ 4y agoYou joke, but an economy that is 97% artists (aka content creators) sounds... good? Isn't this the utopic end goal after we automate the scarcity out of our lifes?
- jordanbeiber 4y agoSure, with UBI. Otherwise not so much.
- moffkalast 4y agoIn theory it's great, in practice... who knows. The cynic in me would expect it to go worse than anyone could ever imagine. If everything is automated, why do you still need humans?
- pixl97 4y agoWe have more technology and more stuff than ever, yet it seems we've accomplished about zero in solving the human problems of greed and narcissism. Ted Faro is alive today. We just aren't sure which of the FRANK'S he's at.
- trafficante 4y agoHorizon: Zero Dawn was so compelling (to me) because of the outright horrifying plausibility of a gassed up tech CEO, convinced that software safeties were infallible, unleashes the consequences for their hubris upon the whole of humanity. Ted Faro was a horrible human being blinded by delusions of grandeur, but he wasn’t “evil” - he was even convinced he was saving humanity by ending the threat of both war and climate change. I don’t see GPT itself as representing a new Faro Plague, but I do see a lot of wannabe Ted Faros making the decisions at the top. If LLMs come even close to achieving their short-term potential, we’re unleashing a bigger destabilizing force on the world than the smartphone/social media combo - and the world of 202x seems blatantly incapable of absorbing that level of disruption.
- salad-tycoon 4y agoHave you seen some of that content? This sounds like a level in Dante’s inferno, all day everyday all “these” (and myself probably ) people going blah blah blah into the either. Navel gazing to the extreme.
- tremon 4y agoAnd who is going to pay those artists? Entertainment professions usually serve those who have money to spend.
- bumby 4y agoAn automation tax can replace the income tax to fund social needs.
- hyperliner 4y ago[dead]
- jnwatson 4y agoI saw a stream the other day that was just the output of an AI trained on a popular streamer’s past streams. It would select a random clip for video, respond to viewers’ comments in the voice of the streamer. It even superimposed roughly corresponding lip movements on the video.
- WalterBright 4y agoI've listed to some popular podcasters. Over time, they all run out of material and their newer podcasts are just rehashes of the old ones. I suppose AI will take over that job!
- htrp 4y agoAI will take the twitch streaming jobs too
- 1attice 4y agoThis hoary take irks me. There were still places for human endeavour to go when the looms were automated. That is no longer the case. Think of it instead as cognitive habitat. Sure, there has been habitat loss in the past, but those losses have been offset by habitat gains elsewhere. This time, I don't see anywhere for habitat gains to come, and I see a massive, enormous, looming (ha!) cognitive habitat loss. -- EDIT: Reply to reply, posted as edit because I hit the HN rate limit: > Your job didn't exist then. Mine didn't, either. Yes, that was my point. New habitat opened up. I infer (but cannot prove) that the same will not be true this time. At the least, the newly-created habitat (prompt engineer, etc.) will be miniscule compared to what has been lost. Reasoning from historical lessons learned during the introduction of TNT was of course tried when nuclear arms were created as well. Yet lessons from the TNT era proved ineffective at describing the world that was ushered into being. Firebombing, while as destructive as a small nuclear warhead, was hard, requiring fantastic air and ground support to achieve. Whereas dropping nukes is easy. It was precisely that ease-of-use that raised the profile of game theory and Mutually Assured Destruction, tit-for-tat, and all the other novelties occurrent in the nuclear world and not the one it supplanted. Arguing from what happened with looms feels like the sort of undergrad maneuver that makes for a good term paper, but lousy economic policy. So many disanalogies.
- WalterBright 4y ago> There were still places for human endeavour to go when the looms were automated. Your job didn't exist then. Mine didn't, either.
- harold_b 4y ago[dead]
- WalterBright 4y ago> the same will not be true this time This prediction has occurred with every technology revolution. It hasn't been borne out yet. > the sort of undergrad maneuver It's a variation of the broken window fallacy.
- 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- veqq 4y agoThat was very bad for the weavers. Well earning middle class jobs were replaced by toiling in the mills, It then took a few generations for the work act to put a 10hr maximum workday etc. The luddites were trying to defend their livelihoods, communities etc. It's the same rational thing people are looking at now: How to survive
- WalterBright 4y agoConsider how expensive textiles were before weaving machines. People wore their one set of clothes until they disintegrated. Fast forward to today. I received a solicitation for a charity in the mail the other day. They enclosed pictures of the poor kids. The kids were all wearing fashionable, spotless clothes in perfect condition. That's what industrial textile machines gave us.
- pixl97 4y agoAnd the luddites still starved to death in the street... tell me exactly what we're doing, especially in the US, to avoid the luddites 2.0?
- nickpp 4y agoThey did?! I thought they just had to learn and adapt doing something else eventually during a transition which was not very fast while also enjoying the new, better and cheaper products available to all. Any source for those starvation deaths? I would like to learn more about what prevented them from simply doing what the survivors did.
- WalterBright 4y agoI never heard they starved, either. In fact, average life expectancy increased in this period.
- alexvoda 4y agoAnd weaving machines have not fully trickled down to citizens. You can not easily buy a weaving machine (there are some second hand ones) or easily go to your local maker space and use the weaving machine to create the design you desire. Open source in the space of textile making is in its infancy even though there are some projects. I bet it is easier to get a low volume tape-out of some custom chips than it is to get a custom roll of textile. (you can get printing but that's not the same thing) Textiles have become way cheaper and both higher quality (when demanded) and lower quality (cost saving fast fashion) and available in far higher quantities. Some things were lost in this transition.