4 ms·
Think of people who have jobs like archaeology, digging up bones. The only way these jobs can exist is if technology has taken over much of the grunt work of pr
by WalterBright 4y ago
Think of people who have jobs like archaeology, digging up bones. The only way these jobs can exist is if technology has taken over much of the grunt work of production.
As for human translators, the need for them far, far exceeds the number of them. Have you ever needed translation help? I sure have, but no human translator was available or was too expensive.
- layer8 4y ago> was too expensive. This is probably the real problem. Translators are payed shit nowadays for what is a really high-skill job. I have translators in the extended family who had to give up on that line of work because the pay wouldn’t sustain them anymore.
- adelie 4y agoyep, exactly. the issue isn't that there will no longer be a need for human translators - machine translation makes subtle mistakes that legal/technical fields will need a human to double-check. the issue is that many translation jobs will, and already are, being replaced with 'proofread machine translation output' jobs that simply don't pay enough. translation checking is careful, detailed work that often takes almost as much time as translating passages yourself, yet it pays a third or less of the rate because 'the machine is doing most of the work.'
- layer8 4y agoI don’t think it’s really because “the machine is doing most of the work”, but because there’s no good way for clients to assess the quality of the supplemental human work, and therefore the market gets flooded with subpar translators who do the task sloppily on the cheap, in a way that still passes as acceptable.
- achr2 4y agoWhich is exactly what this new breed of AI does - create a facsimile that is good enough to devalue the human equivalent.
- carlosjobim 4y agoAI translation is good enough to get business done. And it is instant, which opens up completely new opportunities and markets. Getting e-mail in a foreign language, translating it, writing a response, translating that back and closing a deal. Using a human translator would take much more time, because they cannot always be on call. An adequate AI translation is a lot better than no translation.
- nidnogg 4y agoWhen you have to use any documents within another country that doesn't list their original languages as official, not much, if anything at all, is machine-translated AFAIK. Is this not the case for most legal paperwork as well? You almost always need certified translation (by a human), for which you have to pay out a reasonable sum. And if it's not a good translator, you pay double. e.g. Italian citizenship can cost as much as a brand new car in Brazil and almost half of that cost could come from certified translation hurdles.
- amirhirsch 4y agoFunny you mention archaeology. Humans used to apply our excess productivity to building pyramids!
- gregable 4y agoJobs like archeology could probably also be automated further. Somewhat limiting this is possibly the fact that the "market size" for automation here is small.