11 ms·
San Francisco Bay Area to phase out natural gas heating appliances
- voisin 4y ago> The rules do not apply to cooking appliances such as gas stoves. You either care about air quality or you don’t. This makes no sense.
- timbit42 4y agoMaybe they realize forcing people to switch from gas ranges would cause a huge uproar. People love gas ranges even though they pollute the air in your home and induction ranges are superior in almost every way except price. This is a pretty good video to convince people to switch from gas: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X440BHdy35g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X440BHdy35g
- x3n0ph3n3 4y agoLife isn't binary. Most everything has trade-offs and sliding scales.
- tristanb 4y agoThis doesn't make a lot of sense when my PGE bill is already $700 a month and gas is a tiny fraction of that. Fix the energy supplier first.
- sagarun 4y agoYou sure? Gas bill has been astronomically high lately.
- triceratops 4y agoIf your bill is $700/month it's more than likely your fault. Either your house is quite large. Or you run it very inefficiently. In mild Northern California there's no reason for your bill to be that high.
- georgeburdell 4y agoYears of the electricity provider being liable for record breaking wildfires and passing the buck on to the consumer is what’s happening
- pdx6 4y agoIt's pretty easy to get to $700/mo. There's a lot of old housing stock without good insulation, leaky windows, etc. Leaving a typical server on is like $70. I can see a 3bd 2ba apartment easily hitting $700/mo with an active family living in it. Add in an EV, that's another $50/mo right there, maybe more!
- triceratops 4y ago> There's a lot of old housing stock without good insulation, leaky windows, etc That is very fixable. With $500/month of potential savings the return on investment is very high. > Leaving a typical server on is like $70 1. That'll cut down on your heating bill. 2. How many people need a server that expensive? To do what?
- tristanb 4y agoTenants don’t have the ability to make landlords fix things unfortunately
- sn0wf1re 4y agoNo kidding. In Northern Canada in the winter my apartment is $50/mo electricity, including heat. Caveat, new building.
- seiferteric 4y agoAre you a PGE customer? I only have them for gas, but this winter has been crazy expensive.
- tristanb 4y agoI am unfortunately.
- renewiltord 4y agoInteresting. My last month bill from PG&E was $100 ($60 after generation credit). It's a 1900 sq. ft. flat in SF.
- proc0 4y agoJust a few weeks ago there was a big power outage that lasted 24 hours because of a storm. I'm glad I have a gas stove because I could still cook and prevent food from spoiling. Making everything dependent on the power grid is just putting more strain on an already unreliable infrastructure. I don't think politicians are thinking clearly about this. They seem to want net-zero energy at any cost, even if it means people will suffer. Meanwhile we can't control what other countries do so it might not even make a difference anyway.
- CameronNemo 4y agoThey seem to want net-zero energy at any cost This is about indoor air quality too, though.
- adamredwoods 4y agoBy 2030, and only applies to heating. I hope by then, we begin to have efficient home-energy storage solutions, for the purposes of outages.
- giarc 4y agoYour gas stove isn't a heating appliance and therefore is probably exempt. "In a vote held late Wednesday, the board of directors of the Bay Area Air Quality Management District (BAAQMD) adopted rules that will require new water heaters and furnaces to have zero emissions of nitrogen oxides, or NOx."
- mercyandgrace 4y agoLooks like the AVG low in the Bay Area is about 45? I suppose that isn't that cold, however, in the event of an extended electrical outage, those with gas appliances can still heat their homes. Those without cannot. I think the merit of the parent comment still stands. I live in New England and utilize heating oil primarily. Even that won't work without electricity.
- fsh 4y agoA forced air gas furnace doesn't work without electricity.
- Overtonwindow 4y agoIt only makes sense politically.
- pdx6 4y agoSFBay doesn't have big freezes like Texas, but I have to wonder the wisdom of eliminating gas heaters entirely. The blower fan on a typical gas heater uses 120v and doesn't consume nearly as much power as a ~20a 240v heat pump. During a typical PG&E power outage a much larger back up battery will be needed to keep a home heated. Over the last couple of years, I've had 4-5 power outages that lasted over 4 hours and I live in the middle of San Francisco. I do have a wood burning fireplace as a backup, but those have all sorts of restrictions on use and new ones aren't permitted. Imagine what a chilly 20 unit Tenderloin apartment is going to be like! Unless cheap battery tech, microgrids, and major subsidies are put into place, it's going to be a cold winter when PG&E is out for hours at night in 2032.
- inglor_cz 4y agoThe sheer amount of third-world problems concentrated in a rich state like California just never ceases to amaze me. You will get better power supply in rural Bulgaria.
- 4dayworkweek4u 4y ago[flagged]
- fsh 4y agoOr the US could start burying its residential power lines like the other industrialized countries do. Day-long power outages just do not happen there.
- pdx6 4y agoBurying is a good idea and I'm a fan of it for sure. The issues I've seen on my block is the transformer out on the pole fails about every 7 years. As an aside, it's an interesting failure scenario because there's a loud explosion outside my window, then I get 120v 50hz power from whatever is left of the transformer so half the house lights work at an odd warm glow. :D
- goda90 4y ago
- darth_avocado 4y agoThe gas prices recently have been sky high, but earlier that was not the case. Gas heaters are cheaper and are in general more efficient than electricity. My hvac was down this winter for a couple of weeks and despite the high prices of gas, it was still more expensive (orders of magnitude) to heat the whole house using electric heaters (that my landlord graciously arranged). This makes no sense.
- mirashii 4y ago> Gas heaters are cheaper and are in general more efficient than electricity. If you count heat pumps as electricity, this hasn't been true for a long, long time.
- HDThoreaun 4y ago> Gas heaters are cheaper and are in general more efficient than electricity. No longer true, especially in moderate climates such as the bay.
- darth_avocado 4y agoYou don’t run heaters when the weather is moderate.
- HDThoreaun 4y agoSf does get cold enough to use heat, but yes, it doesn’t make sense to have a furnace that you rarely use. Even still though heat pumps are cheaper over lifespan than furnaces until you get to consistently sun zero temps.
- urbanhole 4y agoI lived in central SF for many years. I prefer a cool house (some visitors might say “cold”). I was able to go months at a time, winter and summer, without using gas heat at all. Of all the areas that could manage this, SFBA seems up there in terms of feasibility at least.
- laweijfmvo 4y agoI go all year (since July is the coldest) with just a 750w space heater, but I also prefer cold.
- s1gnp0st 4y agoIt's notable - if not outright suspicious - that banning gas appliances hit the news cycle after a major source of European natural gas was cut off.
- mbgerring 4y agoA lot of people seem to think we can only accomplish a transition away from fossil fuels after alternatives for fossil fuel driven appliances are available, fully scaled up, and cheap. That won’t happen without demand. Given that nobody cares about their furnace as long as it works, and that in the Bay Area these decisions are made by landlords about every 20 years, who are just trying to get the job done as fast as possible at the lowest price, just banning the gas burning version is a great way to create the necessary demand to accomplish this transition on schedule.* *”on schedule” here means “in enough time to mitigate climate change enough to prevent the release of exotic diseases from permafrost”
- CoffeeOnWrite 4y agoIt’s not about the appliances, it’s about the energy supply. The California electric grid isn’t super reliable.
- hnav 4y agoprobably need the full 20 years for the grid to catch up, no? this is think global act local taken to an absurd. is burning methane for heat in the bay area really going to melt permafrost? if doing this, why not at least tax the methane to make heat pump TCO seem lower and redirect the extra money into funding crumbling public transit which might actually reduce greenhouse gas from driving.
- Decabytes 4y agoThe only major problem I have with things like this is when you get electricity disrupted do to inclement weather. This is a common problem in my area, and not being able to heat your home or cook food is not great
- timbit42 4y agoThis doesn't affect gas stoves.
- Tiktaalik 4y agoHave had this ban in place for new buildings in Vancouver since 2022. 54% of emissions in the city are from burning gas for home heating so it's really the biggest way to lower emissions. Good for SF. (the next biggest chunk of emissions is 39% from vehicles)
- BeLoSmc 4y agoI am on my second round of 5 days with no electricity and no heat in the Santa Cruz Mountains. It is 50 degrees inside and trying to function is futile. Wood-burning stoves are banned, I am in an all-electric structure - no hot water, no way to cook unless I use a camp stove inside (horrible for health), no heat - we bought toe warmers for the 82 year-old I live with. This makes no sense, if the grid can’t handle it, then it should not have been legislated this way. At the very least, an allowance for back-up systems during emergencies should be in place.