5 ms·
Really facinating and impressive. It is hard to comprehend how this is just fancy sentence completion.
by s1artibartfast 4y ago
Really facinating and impressive. It is hard to comprehend how this is just fancy sentence completion.
- kazinator 4y agoExplanations of the joke exist on the network. It's just cribbing from those texts; it's not coming up with the reasoning behind it. If it were a brand new joke that the interlocutor invented, for which there are no existing discussions, it wouldn't be able to do anything beyond giving some evasive answer instead of "I don't know".
- s1artibartfast 4y agoIs there a way to test that? I would love to see the difference but cant come up with jokes.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pakitan 4y agoWe could change slightly the original joke. For example, same prompt but change the answer of the second logician to "Yes!". Ideally, ChatGPT should say, "I'm sorry, I don't get the joke" :)
- bakuninsbart 4y agoShouldn't it be enough to rephrase the joke in such a way that the tokens are completely different? "George Boole's students visit a fair, one of the peddlers there asks them: 'Would the three of you like to know your fortune?' The first student says: 'I don't know', the second student says..." Either way, I think the poster above is wrong. ChatGPT does have a model of the world, or better said, of a world sufficiently similar to our own to often make very good predictions about what we want to hear.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jgeada 4y agoMake it N logicians, have the same structure: (N-1) x I don't know, one Yes!! And pick N so it is not 3 (which is the common version on the internets). If it can explain that version, then it is going somewhere. I tried it with 5 and the answer no longer indicates understanding of details of the puzzle: """ Explain this joke: 5 logicians walk into a bar. The bartender asks: "Do you all want a drink?" The first logician says: I don't know The 2nd logician says: I don't know The third logician says: I don't know The 4th logician says: I don't know The fifth logician says: Yes!! OpenAI:: This joke is a variation of a classic logic puzzle called the "liar paradox." In the joke, five logicians walk into a bar, and the bartender asks if they all want a drink. The first four logicians respond with "I don't know," indicating that they cannot answer the question definitively. The fifth logician's response of "Yes!" seems to contradict the previous answers, but it is actually a valid answer based on a logical interpretation. The joke plays on the idea that logicians are known for their precise and analytical thinking, and the unexpected response from the fifth logician adds a humorous twist to the traditional paradox. """
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI think that is still a valid answer, it just doesn't explain why as well. The fist for can not answer definitively but the 5th can. That said, i didn't bother to look up the liar paradox, so that part could be BS.
- nuancebydefault 4y agoCould you point us to an explanation of the joke on the internet? I would dare to say there is none, but there are a lot of explanations of other jokes that might have a similar pattern of explaining.
- thedanbob 4y agoCurrent top comment has one: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35185572 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35185572
- f6v 4y agoI think this misses a point. There’s no information about the model: how was it trained, on which data. It might be that it can actually “reason” in a human sense, or this particular joke is hardcoded, or… I feel that with OpenAI withholding the details the whole discourse turns into religious flame war.
- rgmerk 4y agoYes. This is just more of LLMs showing their impressive ability to regurgitate the appropriate bit of the internet in response to a prompt.
- Narretz 4y agoBut the Tweet said GPT 4 is the first model to explain the joke correctly. So in some area there must have been an improvement, even if it's just access to existing information. Or it's just a fluke.
- lamp987 4y agohere, ill correct it: GPT4 is the first model with enough parameters to remember and summarize the text found somewhere on internet correctly.
- mcphage 4y agoLike offering it puzzles from Raymond Smullyan books, and seeing what it comes up with.