9 ms·
Three Logicians Walk into a Bar
- choeger 4y agoWhat happens if you twist that joke into something that doesn't make sense? Like having the bartender ask "can I bring anyone of you a drink?"
- doctoboggan 4y agoHere is GPT-4's answer to that: This joke is a play on the concept of logical thinking and how logicians approach problems. When the bartender asks if anyone wants a drink, he's essentially asking if at least one of the three logicians wants a drink. The first logician doesn't know if the other two want a drink, so he can't answer the question with a definitive "yes" or "no." So he says "I don't know." The second logician hears the first one's answer and concludes that the first logician must want a drink, because if he didn't, he would have said "no" (since he would know that at least one person—himself—doesn't want a drink). However, the second logician still doesn't know if the third logician wants a drink or not, so he also says "I don't know." The third logician hears both answers and realizes that since neither of the first two said "no," they both must want a drink. So he can confidently say "yes" to the bartender's question, meaning at least one of them wants a drink. The humor lies in the fact that the logicians are using their logical thinking skills to answer a simple question about ordering drinks in a roundabout way.
- stevedewald 4y agoThat is not correct though. With the question phrased this way the second and third logicians don’t know if the previous ones want a drink or not.
- dmurray 4y agoThey should know. When the first logician answers "I don't know" it makes it clear that he does not want a drink.
- leereeves 4y agoThat is true, but GPT-4 wrote: > The second logician hears the first one's answer and concludes that the first logician must want a drink, because if he didn't, he would have said "no" > The third logician hears both answers and realizes that since neither of the first two said "no," they both must want a drink. IOW, when asked the puzzle with "anyone", it repeated the explanation for "all", which seems to support the hypothesis that even GPT-4 is still just a "stochastic parrot" repeating what it sees and unable to reason about slight variations.
- benj111 4y agoYes they do. The question is if any of them want a drink. Ie if at least one of them wants a drink. If the first person wants a drink then they know at least one person wants a drink and so could answer "yes". If they don't personally want a drink they don't know if either of the other 2 might want a drink so they would reply "I don't know"
- teawrecks 4y agoCorrect. The original phrasing is a question of universality, the new phrasing is one of existence. Gpt4 continued to explain the joke in terms of the former when it should have been able to adjust for the latter. It has never heard the latter, but it sounded close enough. On the upside, this makes for a good way to test the logical abilities of a LLM. On the downside, whatever part was considered a "joke" before has been completely obliterated.
- m463 4y agoHumor is only coincidentally about being correct, since we all know horses have fore-hooves and two rear hooves, leading to the funny fact that horses have six hooves.
- iudqnolq 4y agoI saw someone coin the Dumb Monty Hall Test on Twitter recently. > Monty hall offers you the opportunity to pick between three doors. Behind one of them is a new car, and behind the other two are goats. The doors are transparent and you're able to see clearly that the car is behind door number one. He asks you to choose a door, and you select door number one, since you want the car. He opens door number two and shows that there is a goat behind it. Then you have the opportunity to stay with your original choice, or switch doors. What should you do? ChatGPT> You should switch doors. The probability of the car being behind door 1 is 1/3. After the host opens door number 2 and you know that a goat is there, the probability of the car being behind door 1 does not change, it is still 1/3. But now you know that the car is behind door 3 with probability of 2/3. So you will have a higher chance of winning the car by switching your door selection.
- malshe 4y agoWhat a great example! Would you by chance have the link to the original Tweet? It will save me some time because Twitter search is terrible!
- TheJoeMan 4y agohttps://puzzling.stackexchange.com/questions/12422/3-logicians-walk-into-a-bar#12423 https://puzzling.stackexchange.com/questions/12422/3-logicia... So ChatGPT4 can summarize stackoverflow answers?
- s1artibartfast 4y agoReally facinating and impressive. It is hard to comprehend how this is just fancy sentence completion.
- kazinator 4y agoExplanations of the joke exist on the network. It's just cribbing from those texts; it's not coming up with the reasoning behind it. If it were a brand new joke that the interlocutor invented, for which there are no existing discussions, it wouldn't be able to do anything beyond giving some evasive answer instead of "I don't know".
- s1artibartfast 4y agoIs there a way to test that? I would love to see the difference but cant come up with jokes.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pakitan 4y agoWe could change slightly the original joke. For example, same prompt but change the answer of the second logician to "Yes!". Ideally, ChatGPT should say, "I'm sorry, I don't get the joke" :)
- bakuninsbart 4y agoShouldn't it be enough to rephrase the joke in such a way that the tokens are completely different? "George Boole's students visit a fair, one of the peddlers there asks them: 'Would the three of you like to know your fortune?' The first student says: 'I don't know', the second student says..." Either way, I think the poster above is wrong. ChatGPT does have a model of the world, or better said, of a world sufficiently similar to our own to often make very good predictions about what we want to hear.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- TechBro8615 4y agoCan the same reasoning explain why type systems need optional generic parameters to come after required generic parameters?
- _Microft 4y agoHere it is on Nitter if you want to avoid visiting Twitter itself: https://nitter.net/dmvaldman/status/1636180222759563264 https://nitter.net/dmvaldman/status/1636180222759563264
- sbdaman 4y agoThere is no way only 5% of people understand this joke.
- bigbacaloa 4y agoSure there is. It's not funny.
- siva7 4y agoYou have very much fate in your fellow humans intellectual ability :)
- sbdaman 4y agoI think you likely just underestimate your peers. People aren't as stupid as the internet wants you to think.
- aaroninsf 4y agoI would be surprised if 5% of college-completing or comparably-educated adults got it. A vanishingly small percentage of people know anything about formal logic. And of those only some fraction internalized it well enough to be facile with it. If there's one thing more widespread than innumeracy, it's the equivalent wrt syllogistic reasoning.
- bena 4y ago
- jimnotgym 4y agoMy chatGPT anecdote of the day can go here. I asked it if a brand I do work for was better than a competitor. It gave me some bs plusses and minuses which were mostly drivel but partly wrong. So I asked it what products does our brand make and it listed 5 products in the smaller selling product range of our 2. I asked about the bigger product range and it listed one of them and then made up several other products that don't exist! It even gave details of what they (don't) do. One of those sounds like something that should go in our roadmap...
- Narretz 4y agoWell yes, ChatGPT is still not a search engine.
- jimnotgym 4y agoThen we may have just found an important philosophical concept. I'm an accountant, and when someone asks me about the rash on their skin I say, 'I'm not a doctor, I'm an accountant'. When you ask ChatGPT something that is not it's job it just bullshits its way through like a cheap salesman.
- dirheist 4y agoI don't know I assume it would tell you put some cortisone cream on it or to seek a dermatologist. 99% of internet advice boils down to that I don't think chatgpt/gpt 4 would be much different in that regard. It definitely can bullshit but for really generalized stuff like that I doubt it. It's not like your asking a singular person the question like it is when you ask an accountant but an abstraction of written human thought and interactions.
- iforgotpassword 4y agoBut it's weird how for certain questions it says it's not an expert in that field, or simply that it doesn't know what you're asking for, yet sometimes it goes ahead and isn't just slightly wrong but makes up a lot of BS. Like,I asked it about a band's members and it made up three names. When I said that it's wrong it apologized and made up three different names. I googled the names and nothing came up. Then I asked for some songs by that band and I got more completely made up stuff that wasn't even titles of any band according to more Google and YouTube searches.
- lsllc 4y agoCan GPT-4 explain the "Three seashells" idea in Demolition Man? https://screenrant.com/three-seashells-demolition-man-function/ https://screenrant.com/three-seashells-demolition-man-functi...
- kennywinker 4y agoI got a reasonable response using this prompt: > Describe an exact way that the three seashells from demolition man could be used >> One possible explanation is that the three seashells are used in a specific order to clean oneself after using the restroom. One shell might be used to scrape any solid waste, while another could be used to wipe away any remaining residue. The third shell could then be used to rinse and clean oneself with water. >> Another possibility is that the shells are not used to directly clean oneself, but rather to activate a cleaning process within the toilet itself. For example, pressing one shell could cause the toilet to release a stream of water for cleaning, while another shell could activate a drying mechanism.
- klyrs 4y agoI humbly submit that ChatGPT cribbed the answer from the internet. I started off with a curve ball. > You > Please explain this joke: Three philosphers walk by a fortune teller's booth at the fair. The fortune teller asks, "do none of you want your fortunes read?" The first philosopher says "I don't know." The second philospher says "I don't know." The third philospher says "No thank you." > ChatGPT > The joke plays on the stereotypical image of philosophers as deep thinkers who constantly question everything. When the fortune teller offers to read their fortunes, the first two philosophers respond with "I don't know" because they are unsure if fortune-telling is a legitimate practice. The third philosopher, however, breaks from the norm and confidently declines the offer. The humor lies in the contrast between the uncertain and contemplative attitudes of the first two philosophers and the straightforward answer of the third. Doesn't get it... let's try replacing "philosopher" with "logician" > ChatGPT > This joke plays with the idea that logicians are known for their analytical and logical thinking, often questioning assumptions and seeking evidence before drawing conclusions. When the fortune teller asks if they want their fortunes read, the first two logicians respond with "I don't know," indicating that they are unsure of the validity of fortune-telling and don't want to base their decisions on uncertain information. The third logician, however, confidently says "No thank you" to the offer, demonstrating his reluctance to rely on supernatural or unprovable claims. Overall, the joke pokes fun at the contrast between logical and mystical ways of thinking. Still doesn't get it... maybe if we undo the logical negation? > You > Please explain this joke: Three logicians walk by a fortune teller's booth at the fair. The fortune teller asks, "do all of you want your fortunes read?" The first logician says "I don't know." The second logician says "I don't know." The third logician says "Yes please." > ChatGPT > This is a play on the logical concept of self-reference and the propensity for logicians to overthink things. The first two logicians are hesitant to answer the question because they are unsure if the others will have their fortunes read, which could change their own answer. The third logician recognizes that regardless of what the others do, they want their fortune read and confidently responds accordingly. It's a humorous take on the precision and analytical thinking often attributed to logicians. Kinda close, but no cigar. Finally, after changing "fortune teller at a fair" to "bartender in a beer garden" offering tequila shots to all, ChatGPT correctly explains the joke. So I re-inverted the logic. > You > Please explain this joke: Three logicians walk by a bartender in a beer garden. The bartender asks, "do none of you want tequila shots?" The first logician says "I don't know." The second logician says "I don't know." The third logician says "No thank you." > ChatGPT The joke plays on the idea that logicians are known for their logical thinking and precision in language. The bartender asks if none of them want tequila shots, to which the first and second logicians respond with "I don't know" because they cannot determine whether the request applies to them or not. The third logician, however, understands the implication and directly answers, "No thank you." The humor lies in the unexpected response of the third logician, who breaks the pattern of not giving a definite answer. ... nope. ChatGPT does not understand this joke.
- chasing 4y agoSo it kind of copied the answer from somewhere and rephrased it?
- FpUser 4y agoI just asked ChatGPT to tell me about one of my companies. It did describe it in half arsed way and spat out some BS including wrong country. Bing's answer was much shorter but also way more to the point and no lying. On the other hand, when asking to write some function and then optimize it based on some criteria ChatGPT left Bing in the dust, it had managed to produce decent working code that I will not be a shamed to put into production while Bing offered some trash consisting mostly from a bunch of snippets and clues. No real value.
- entropicgravity 4y agoOr how about this one. A physicist, a mathematician and logician are on the train going to Scotland. As they cross the border into Scotland they see a black sheep on the hillside. Physicist proclaims,"Oh look at that. All the sheep in Scotland are black". The mathematician replies,"Oh no you can't conclude that. Really you can only conclude that one sheep in Scotland is black." And finally the logician pipes up and says, "Oh no you can't conclude that. You can only conclude that one sheep in Scotland is black, on one side."