3 ms·
Cheers. On a related note, are there any examples of magnetic field coupling having a significant effect (for some time scale) on orbiting masses? Mercury, aga
by defrost 4y ago
Cheers.
On a related note, are there any examples of magnetic field coupling having a significant effect (for some time scale) on orbiting masses? Mercury, again, might be good case for such a thing.
In a similar vein as
> (searching) "solar radiation pressure satellites"
is "Magnetorquer satellites" - small effects for attitude adjustment with a complicated "surfing" twist as the field fluxes so much on a daily basis.
I'm under no illusions that these (solar particle pressure, magnetic coupling) would be significant - but theis is a thread about a paper on the evolution of small perturbations :-)
- raattgift 4y agoWe are straying far from my area of expertise. :-) (except at the end). > Mercury, again, might be a good case In our solar system I'd look to Jupiter, whose magnetic strength is tens of thousands of times stronger than Earth's, and which has lots of bodies of various sizes orbiting it. There are magnetic interactions with several of the moons explored by recent space probes, but they are very small. Ganymede is probably the most interesting case. I would be surprised if there were significant orbital perturbations from magnetics on the Galilean moons, or even the mid-size ones. Smaller, especially grain-sized bodies, I don't know. I know next to nothing about Jupiter's rings, but on general chemistry grounds there will be electromagnetic interactions with the planet's magnetosphere. (I suspect these are dwarfed by radiation pressures though; the biggest forcing radiation will be tangential to the ring-components' orbits around Jupiter, and as those objects are small the effect will be relatively large, causing illuminated grains to tend to spiral inwards to Jupiter, but how long does a ring particle stay illuminated rather than in shadow? And there are likely forces that push grains outward, too). None of this likely needs corrections to classical Newtonian gravitation. (The authors of the paper linked at the top do not consider any of the solar system's moons or smaller objects). I'd start here <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetosphere_of_Jupiter#Interaction_with_rings_and_moons https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetosphere_of_Jupiter#Inter...>, notably the paragraph starting, "The icy Galilean moons, Europa, Ganymede and Callisto, all generate induced magnetic moments in response to changes in Jupiter's magnetic field", and visit the various citations in that paragraph and the following two. > evolution of small parameters You've hit on the right word, "evolution", which is much more important than "small". Can we apply perturbation theory? Do we get a nice Taylor-series-like expansion where higher order terms can be treated as marginal or negligible, in the style of Wilsonian effective field theory? See Clifford Will's article, <https://www.pnas.org/doi/pdf/10.1073/pnas.1103127108 https://www.pnas.org/doi/pdf/10.1073/pnas.1103127108>, which is probably close to accessible. It is mainly interested in "quite relativistic" systems, however, and we do not have those in our solar system. Almost nothing in the solar system needs even 1PN (see what that means in the article, or in e.g. the wikipedia article on the post-Newtonian expansion) correction. The work linked at the top is neat because PN effects may actually matter for the ultimate fate of Mercury. Finally, this beautiful paper by Soffel (Past President of IAU Commission 52 Relativity in Fundamental Astronomy) discusses the (ir)relevance of higher-order post-Newtonian corrections to the Earth's gravitational field. <https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00190-016-0927-4 https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00190-016-0927-4> (find it on sci-hub.ru). ("Above, we have demonstrated that the first post-Newtonian approximation is completely sufficient for a description of the Earth's gravitational field and also for a description of satellite orbits."). Table 3 lists the various accelerations on the LAGEOS satellite. Solar radiation pressure, thermal re-radiation, and even albedo pressure (at 3.5e-19 m/s^2) are in the table; nothing like like "magnetotorquer" effects even appears.
- zyrxvo 4y agoThis article by Lhotka & Gale (2019) <https://arxiv.org/abs/1911.02778 https://arxiv.org/abs/1911.02778> is a little beyond my patience for understanding, but they have an excellent parameter space plot in Figure 1 relating a bunch of different effects with respect to dust grain size. Their figure only goes up to grains 1 cm in size though. However, it's a detailed paper on the relative "importance of the interplanetary magnetic field on the orbital evolution of dust". I met Lhotka at a conference where they presented this work. I think this discussion is really fascinating, and it's certainly something that I didn't consider when working on the paper. However, I think the results that we found can be generalized to better understand how a small effect might impact the stability of the solar system on a statistical level, even if we can't say much about the effect in specific cases. For example, I expect that as the total mass of the sun decreases due to solar wind the secular frequencies would all change by the same amount, proportional to the decrease in mass <https://arxiv.org/abs/1811.07135 https://arxiv.org/abs/1811.07135>. This would mean that the difference between the g1 and g5 modes would be closer by the same amount. However, we wouldn't expect the secular diffusion to change so it would be more akin to dashed line in Figure 2 of our paper. So stellar mass loss could cause Mercury to go unstable sooner than without mass loss, but we wouldn't expect the effect to be significant.
- raattgift 4y ago"In the planetary system, solar gravity determines the orbits of all bodies larger than dust particles for which other forces become important. But even for dust, gravity is an important factor. Near planets, planetary gravity takes over", §3.1 of Krüger & Grün's Chapter 29 in Encyclopedia of the Solar System (2014) <https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-12-415845-0.00029-3 https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-12-415845-0.00029-3> (it's on scy hob :) ). See Table 29.4. Where dust is gravitationally interesting at the present age of the solar system is probably in ring/moon interactions, but mostly with the moon acting on the ring dusts as with Saturn's Daphnis and Pan (Cassini). Of course there was a lot more dust doing a lot more interesting things gravitationally much earlier in the solar system's history, which might be interesting if you decide to use your approach to simulate the solar system's past (some of that dust could be related to your link to the massive early sun hypothesis paper). :-) Your other paper on stellar flybys provokes an interesting question: could a fly-by deposit a significant mass of trans-Neptunian dust? I'd wager a lot of fresh dust captured out there could increase the eccentricity of planetary orbits through your 0.9 threshold. Although not plausible for the solar system, relatively high mass-density dust around compact binaries can drive the compact binary's orbital evolution. See for example the very fresh Siwek, Weinberger & Hernquist (2023) <https://arxiv.org/abs/2302.01785 https://arxiv.org/abs/2302.01785>, reasonably summarized at <https://astrobites.org/2023/03/13/will-it-merge-investigating-how-gas-disks-can-determine-the-future-of-a-binary-black-hole-system/ https://astrobites.org/2023/03/13/will-it-merge-investigatin...>.