10 ms·
French bulldogs are taking over America
- AlbertCory 4y agohttps://archive.ph/NuJdD https://archive.ph/NuJdD
- perfmode 4y agowhat is the name of this style of visualization? and for what types of data does it excel?
- AlbertCory 4y agoI don't doubt the AKC's numbers, but I think the Economist is missing the -doodle dogs. Maybe because they aren't recognized breeds? I see them constantly: labradoodles, goldendoodles, bernadoodles Edit: I think "they don't shed" is the attraction of the -doodle. Well, my Lab doesn't shed, either, and he's never had a haircut.
- philwelch 4y agoAre there any French bulldoodles?
- RandallBrown 4y agoYup. https://www.petguide.com/breeds/dog/french-boodle/ https://www.petguide.com/breeds/dog/french-boodle/
- coreyisthename 4y agoThey’re lovely, smart, healthy, happy, energetic, fun, and cute.
- bayesian_horse 4y agoLovely maybe. Smart less so. Certainly not healthy. And being "energetic" is a problem when your legs are short and deformed, your spine and vertebrae are deformed and you can hardly get enough air to run for longer distance.
- verall 4y agoWhich doodles does that apply to?
- mgarfias 4y agoCorrect, AKC only Gives data for the breeds they recognize. They’re not going to count any of the “non breeds” like a doodle, or even breeds they don’t recognize that FCI does.
- labster 4y agoMan who invented labradoodle says it's his 'life's regret' > Wally Conron says he created a ‘Frankenstein’s monster’ as unethical breeders now make hybrids with serious health problems https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2019/sep/26/labradoodle-inventor-lifes-regret-frankenstein-monster https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2019/sep/26/labrado...
- bayesian_horse 4y agoThe bigger problem in the US is that dog owners are in general less educated about the relevant topics than in some other countries (like Germany). They will usually prefer to go to a breeder rather than adopt, and in terms of breeders they prefer cheap prices over other qualities of the breeder. I recently learned "Amish Puppy Mills" are a thing... In Germany, people will usually go to a shelter first. But there are usually no dogs in a shelter suitable for the average dog owner (no extreme medical or behavioral problems, not too big, and "fighting" breeds can be a regulatory hassle). It's gotten so bad the shelters are screening applicants like job seekers. It's gotten so bad we import tens of thousands of "street dogs" from the mediterranean and Eastern Europe. Yes, also with plenty scammers. It got worse during the Covid years. And now all the "unsuitable" dogs get dumped in a shelter again.
- vincnetas 4y agoI am a bit triggered by calling them a "amish" puppy mills. why not just call them puppy mills. of course they are run by amish, but they are also run by humans. So even if 90% of them are run by a amish, that does not mean that 90% of Amish people are running puppy mills. Does using ethnicity in this case adds to the definition?
- theshrike79 4y agoI'd call it a probability definition. If you're buying a dog from Amish people are you more or less likely to get a puppy-mill dog compared to buying from non-Amish?
- bayesian_horse 4y ago
- stephenboyd 4y agoIt looks like the recent popularity of hybrid poodle mixes explains the decline of purebred retrievers.
- AlbertCory 4y agoPossibly. Judging only by my own (heavily Asian) neighborhood, little white dogs gave way to (Goldens / Labs and -doodles). I can't even remember all the yellow Labs' names anymore.
- cafard 4y agoThe hypoallergenic quality is a big attraction. My neighbors have allergies, and might not be able to tolerate a different breed.
- bayesian_horse 4y agoFrench bulldogs are designed and bred to have health problems. They should be verboten to breed at all, but that's not possible. The nose is so short that they have breathing problems, also their teeth don't fit into the shorter snout, and the ears are getting infected more often because of ... geometrical changes for lack of a better word. Also the genetics that makes the tail so cute and small messes up the other vertebrae and leads to a higher incidence of issues with the spinal column. Which are expensive to treat, more expensive than buying a new puppy, usually.
- csours 4y agoI absolutely adore French Bulldogs, but I would never buy or adopt one due to this. If they were more common and proven to be healthy, I might consider a mix, but getting a 'hype' dog has it's own ethical problems.
- bayesian_horse 4y agoI think adoption is OK from an animal welfare standpoint. Just don't create extra demand and don't breed them. Of course, they may cause more medical expenses than others, so if you have a choice...
- bobbylarrybobby 4y agoIn adopting a French bulldog, you take one off the market, forcing a would-be adopter to instead buy one, which incentivizes the mills.
- zumu 4y ago> French bulldogs are designed and bred to have health problems. They should be verboten to breed at all, but that's not possible. Well, to a certain extent all the AKC dogs have health problems. Even big dogs have stuff like hip dysplasia. Some breeds are healthier than others, but the most important bit is buying from an ethical breeder if you must get a pure bred. Sketchy breeding practices are what exacerbate the health issues in popular breeds.
- mertd 4y agoWow, Japan really likes tiny dogs.
- bayesian_horse 4y agoCould be a cultural thing, but can be a smart choice. A smaller dog will enjoy living in an apartment and a "limited" (from a canine view) urban life more than a bigger dog. They're also easier to entertain, especially because many people don't know how to entertain/exhaust their dogs without getting exhausted themselves. No, you're not supposed to run marathons with your dogs. It's much easier to train them to fetch stuff like frisbees and you can sit in a chair all day for all they care.
- Doxin 4y agoMy dog has a knee problem so the vet told me to not fetch with him. Fine by me but it makes tiring him out all sorts of tricky. Training him for treibball at the moment as that's one of the few dog sports I've found that doesn't involve quick direction changes or jumping. Fingers crossed he'll take to it.
- xref 4y agoWell poodles can be decently large, though I’m impressed with the sheer consistency of breed popularity there, no ebb and flow of top breed’s compared to the other countries
- midoridensha 4y agoIn Japanese cities, it's nearly impossible to find a place to rent that allows large dogs. Landlords have strict weight limits on pets. Out in the countryside, you can get away with big dogs, but most of the population lives in the cities. There's other problems too: if you have a tiny dog in the city, you can put it in a carrier and bring it on the train/subway with you. You can't do that with a large dog, so you're barred from using trains, which means you have to drive when you want to go somewhere with your dog, or take a taxi ($$$$, assuming you can find one that allows the dog). A large portion of the population doesn't have a car, because it's very expensive to park it, and even if you do have one, where are you going to go? There's very little parking and it's expensive. So having a large dog is a huge restriction on your lifestyle. Basically, a large dog in the city is a huge luxury and a status symbol, because it shows you're really rich. A small dog is also a luxury and status symbol, but it's much more affordable and doable for middle-class people.
- angmarsbane 4y agoThey are apartment sized.
- conductr 4y agoWhen people can’t afford homes or kids. Frenchy it is.
- bayesian_horse 4y agoNobody can afford children. Or maybe everybody? In most western societies there is now a totally overblown standard of what you are supposed to provide to a child. Yes, it's good to talk about what children need or even to argue what is optimal. But the best you can do is all you can do. My personal opinion: If you feel an honest need for children and have the opportunity, don't wait. Maybe there are some reasonable caveats or reasons to wait a few years, but not many. People with a desire to have children (some people like me don't have it) won't be much happier without having at least tried than in a "suboptimal" situation after becoming parents.
- theshrike79 4y agoIdiocracy was a documentary. The intro scene about having children is still 100% valid: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sP2tUW0HDHA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sP2tUW0HDHA
- conductr 4y agoI wish I had kids earlier (I was almost 40 when becoming a parent). But it’s hard to come to that conclusion until you have kids and realize you’d rather have more shared time on earth than whatever you were doing prior.
- ripley12 4y agoEhh, I feel like people use that as a justification for tiny dogs but it's not a great one. I have an 80lb greyhound in a not-very-large apartment and life is easy. Energy levels are more important than size (greyhounds sleep a lot) when it comes to apartment living for dogs.
- irrational 4y agoThe dog-to-human and dog-to-dog charts were the most interesting to me. My golden retriever loves people, but is indifferent to other dogs.
- eyelidlessness 4y agoMy chihuahua-pit mix loves people, and gets excited about other dogs just to try to get people introductions started. Once she’s met the other dog she loses interest and just wants to hang out and see how the humans get along. She’s clever, because she knows I don’t much like random people but she knows I like dog people.
- jordemort 4y agoWe rescued a French Bulldog/Pug/Jack Russell mix. I think he was a attempt to breed a more robust/less unhealthy pug - failed in that he's not very pug-like, but successful in that he's a delight and very healthy.
- theshrike79 4y agoIt's because Jack Russells are practically bulletproof and live forever :D And that's because they've been bred for use, not for looks for tens of generations. As is proven by the high variance on dogs you can call "Jack Russell". You get tiny ones with stubby-ish legs, you can tall ones with long legs, you have completely smooth haired ones and the ones that look like a ball of wire wool. =) Source: have owned JR's and still do.
- taylodl 4y agoMy JR died in 2021 - at 16 years of age! Yes, she was bulletproof! Failing eyesight, stage 4 heart failure - but she kept chugging along! Super smart, too!
- hiyer 4y agoBetter them than pitbulls I suppose.
- bayesian_horse 4y agoPitbulls are in general healthier than French Bulldogs, they certainly have a better anatomical configuration. They can be socialized to be excellent companions. I've heard a famous German dog expert recommend them for children, because they let children do virtually anything to them without getting pissed. Just make sure you get one that is socialized properly or when a puppy, that you socialize and train him properly and with enough effort.
- briantakita 4y agoStrange, because I don't see many French bulldogs but I do see plenty of *doodle breeds. Golden Doodles in particular are very popular.