3 ms·
Actually not. That's why I was careful to speak of the effect of trading equity on the "average outcome" rather than e.g. "average valuation at liquidity." Wh
by pg 19y ago
Actually not. That's why I was careful to speak of the effect of trading equity on the "average outcome" rather than e.g. "average valuation at liquidity." What I'm literally saying is, does the trade improve your odds of getting what you want? That subsumes both your risk aversion and your utility function for money.
- cperciva 19y agoYour math is still wrong, because of the non-linear utility of money. If I give up 6% of my company, it costs me 6% of any MONEY I might end up getting, but it doesn't cost me 6% of the UTILITY. If I have a utility-of-money function of sqrt($), you don't have to increase my chance of success by 6.4%; it's enough if you increase my chance of success by 3.2%.
- pg 19y ago"Outcome" means the output of the utility function, not the input.
- cperciva 19y agoThen you're still wrong. I quote from the article: "For example, suppose Y Combinator offers to fund you in return for 6% of your company. In this case, n is .06 and 1/(1 - n) is 1.064. So you should take the deal if you believe we can improve your average outcome by more than 6.4%." If by "average outcome" you mean "expected value of the utility function", and assuming that my utility-of-money function is sqrt($), I don't need to improve my "average outcome" by more than 6.4% for the deal to be worth accepting; it's enough if I can increase my "average outcome" by 3.2%, since that's how much UTILITY giving up 6% of the MONEY costs me.
- palish 19y agoIf a man is wrong, you don't need to tell him so. Just give it a rest and let others form their own opinions. Seriously, these issues, and a lot of other issues, are covered in "How to Win Friends and Influence People". Read it. If I could figure out a way to get you to feel like you came up with the idea to read it, I would, but I can't, so just read it.
- pg 19y agoActually, if someone is wrong about math you probably should tell him so.
- palish 19y agoI agree. In private.
- davidw 19y agoYou should tell him he's wrong, but you shouldn't be a jerk or gloat about it, which cperciva wasn't.
- palish 19y agoNo, really.. It is wise to never publically tell someone they are wrong, unless you're defending someone. You should wait until his friends and colleagues have left his side, then whisper your opinion into his ear. In the Internet world, that means sending him an email. To not do so is bad karma in every sense of the word.. My post above was modded down because I publically pointed out that he was wrong to point out Paul's percieved flaws in public; maybe I should have sent him an email instead. This wisdom is proven true over and over. My #lisp fiasco convinced me of that (long story).
- staunch 19y agoYou're wrong to tell people they're wrong to publicly tell people they're wrong. Most mature and intelligent people love it when someone is able to offer useful critiques of their work, as long as they're civil about it. For example: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socratic_method http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socratic_method
- palish 19y agoI don't see in there where you should prefix everything with "What an oversimplification! You're wrong, wrong, wrong!" Seriously, would you want this guy making a few million? Not only would he be a douche, but he'd be a rich douche. Imagine how he'd treat his waitresses and waiters then. Or his local cops. Or anyone not as smart as he is, which is, apparently, EVERYONE. I'd even call him a detriment to our society, because the child just seems to act like a Paris Hilton with brains. Smart people can be civil, and it's just silly to watch everyone go "Cperciva you're so awesome! You should do X with your life!" and him go "Oh ho ho, didn't you think I already considered that? I turned down a headhunter yesterday, in fact. Now go make me a sandwich." The dude's a genius, but he could learn a little humility. But he's obviously not going to learn until some event wakes him up to it, so I'm done caring that maybe one more nice person could exist in the world.
- pg 19y agoSuppose your present hope of future utility from your startup varies linearly with the number of shares. (This is not a radical assumption; essentially all startup shareholders feel this, at least for numbers near that of shares they own.) Suppose you trade 6% of your stock in a deal that will increase your average future utility by 6.4%. You've made a straight trade of hope of future utility for future utility. We don't even have to introduce money.
- euccastro 19y agoNot to split hairs, but at different points you said - that for essentially all startup shareholders, the present hope of future utility varies linearly with the number of shares, and - that the utility function for most founders is a step function. Both sound right to me separately, but don't they contradict each other? Maybe most founders just live with this paradox without realising?
- pg 19y agoNo, I don't think they contradict one another. The reason is that the most likely outcome is just to the right of the step. Most startup founders (initially at least) hope to get a few million, and wouldn't risk that to get a few billion. That's the step. And the most common form of liquidity event is a small-scale acquisition that gives the founders just that level of wealth, since otherwise they won't sell. So in the most common (and most commonly hoped for) good outcome, happiness varies linearly with the number of shares.
- dpapathanasiou 19y agoSince you're talking about step functions and expectation, the final equation should be framed with a binary parameter in mind: x=0 (no liquidity event occurs), x=1 (liquidity occurs).
- euccastro 19y ago"The reason is that the most likely outcome is just to the right of the step." "So in the most common (and most commonly hoped for) good outcome [...]" Isn't the omission of good in the first paragraph a lapsus, i.e., do you mean most founders think success is the most likely outcome? Or do you mean founders should ignore the possibility of failure for the purposes of making these decisions about stock?
- create_account 19y agoSince you're good at math and know something about finance, why not just get a job at a hedge fund? You'll get rich, and you won't get heckled by a bunch of startup founders.
- cperciva 19y agoI know something about economics, but far less about finance. :-) In any case, finance really doesn't interest me. I routinely tell Wall Street headhunters to stop bothering me because I would rather create something impressive than own something impressive. I'm not in this for the money.
- palish 19y agoWell, your demeanor is very ingrained into your personality. I doubt you can change it without a lot of effort. Even saying little things like "I routinely tell Wall Street headhunters to stop bothering me..." comes off as arrogant. Do you really not see that? Or do you just not care? Let's put it this way: How arrogant you are perceived as can be measured by how many times you say "I".