9 ms·
Docker should have been a neat tool made by one enthusiast, just like curl is. Instead it has a multi-million dollar company behind it, and VC's who demand pro
by londons_explore 4y ago
Docker should have been a neat tool made by one enthusiast, just like curl is.
Instead it has a multi-million dollar company behind it, and VC's who demand profits from a thing that shouldn't have ever had a business plan.
- aviramha 4y agoI think that Docker can have a viable business plan but they had terrible execution. At my previous position, I wanted to use DockerHub more heavily but the entire experience was like a bootstrap project someone did as a university assignment. Many advanced features for organizations were lacking (SSO/SAML) that we would have happily paid for.
- MandieD 4y agoThat, plus not being willing to accept Purchase Orders, doomed them with my employer. It's as if they had no idea how things work at large enterprises that are older than most Docker employees.
- pydry 4y agoI think they potentially could have made a decent business out of it but they made a lot of bad business decisions. I find myself shaking my head at a lot of their technical decisions too. Podman seems to me to be a case study for how to do this right.
- aviramha 4y agoI am usually an early adopter but I keep coming back to Docker since Podman is still very rough around the edges, especially in terms of "non-direct" usage (aka other tools)
- vladvasiliu 4y agoAs someone who's been bitten by this, I'm not sure if it's an issue with podman itself as much as the tools which expect docker. It could be argued that podman is not a docker drop-in replacement, but I expect more and more tools to pick it up.
- laserlight 4y ago> It could be argued that podman is not a docker drop-in replacement This is an unfortunate part IMHO. podman is not a docker drop-in replacement, but it is advertised as such.
- evilduck 4y agoBesides the advertising, it's very close to being a drop-in replacement but their pace isn't closing that gap quick enough (or maybe they don't want to, or it isn't possible, idk I'm just a user) so you get a false sense of confidence doing the simple stuff before you run into a parity problem.
- actionfromafar 4y agoWorth remembering is that Docker supports Windows containers. That’s a hard requirement for many enterprises.
- Kye 4y agoIs this a matter of developers constantly relearning the lesson of the folly of only supporting the current top thing, or is it a lot harder to support more than one?
- vladvasiliu 4y agoI don't know how "hard" it is, but in my particular case I wanted to use this from intellij. It actually works, but the issue is that the docker emulation socket isn't where the ide expects it, and I haven't found a way to tell it where to look for. Once I simlinked the socket, everything worked.
- yrro 4y agoThis worked for me: Connect to Docker Daemon with -> TCP Socket -> Engine API URL -> unix:///run/user/$UID/podman/podman.sock
- orthoxerox 4y ago
- throwawaymanbot 4y ago[dead]
- windexh8er 4y agoPodman is interesting. I like the architecture problems it solves with respect to Docker but the way they went about it was typical big business Red Hat. Dan Walsh, Podman's BDFL it seems, basically stood in front of RHEL / OpenShift customers for years bashing Docker even when a majority of the things he was claiming were less than half baked. RHEL made sly moves like not supporting the Docker runtime, even at a time when it put their customers in an awkward spot before containerd won the k8s runtime war. Podman is backed by much larger corporate machinery. If anyone thinks that Podman "winning" is a good thing then you've played right in to Walsh's antics. RHEL wants nothing more than to have no friction when selling all the "open source" tooling you may need in your enterprise. Podman wasn't built out of necessity but out of fiscal competitive maneuvering. And it's working. I see so many articles on the "risks" of Docker vs Podman. The root wars are all over the place. Yet... The topic is blown way out of proportion by RHEL for a reason: FUD all in the name of sales. Is there merit to the claim? For sure. Docker's architecture was originally built up as client/server for a different purpose. That didn't play out and the architecture ended up being a side effect of that. But we don't see container escape nearly as much as Red Hat would like us to believe. I keep paying Docker because I don't want to live in Red Hat's world, with their tooling that they can just lock out of other platforms once they feel like it. No thanks.
- javajosh 4y ago>I don't want to live in Red Hat's world, with their tooling that they can just lock out of other platforms once they feel like it Explain please. This sounds like you're accusing RH of sabotaging Docker, or planning to. That's a very serious accusation requiring proof.
- mikepurvis 4y agoSome of it also sounds a bit like leftover angst from Red Hat winning the systemd war too. Turns out hanging out in someone else’s cathedral can have some pretty big benefits.
- Gibheer 4y ago
- voytec 4y ago> Docker should have been a neat tool made by one enthusiast, just like curl is. I have nothing but mad respect for Daniel Stenberg. 25 years of development of great software, for which he had been threatened[1] and had ridiculous US travel visa obtaining issues[2]. [1] https://daniel.haxx.se/blog/2021/02/19/i-will-slaughter-you/ https://daniel.haxx.se/blog/2021/02/19/i-will-slaughter-you/ [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26192025 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26192025 [2] https://daniel.haxx.se/blog/2020/11/09/a-us-visa-in-937-days/ https://daniel.haxx.se/blog/2020/11/09/a-us-visa-in-937-days...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- elbigbad 4y agoI read the travel issues post you linked, but am not seeing the causal link you’re drawing between development of software and visa issues. Was there more to the story?
- voytec 4y agoI may have remembered incorrectly, which post was it. Here[1], in the paragraph titled "Why they deny me?" (unlinkable), Daniel hints at the possibility that this may have been due to development of (lib)curl which is used for malware creation by 3rd parties. There was no proof though. [1] https://daniel.haxx.se/blog/2018/07/28/administrative-purgatory/ https://daniel.haxx.se/blog/2018/07/28/administrative-purgat...
- elbigbad 4y agoAh, that makes sense. I have no dog in the fight and am far from the emotion of having a visa delayed in this circumstance. I would say that it was much more likely to be some level of incompetence than malice, having dealt with large government bureaucracies myself.
- kzrdude 4y agoThe most superficial (and likely) reason to me seems to be that he uses haxx.se. I really wonder what kind of investigation they do. If they just start with Google, this one might come up immediately.
- wvh 4y agoIn all fairness, curl is purely a software tool. Docker is arguably more like a service. As such, it creates costs for and direct dependency on the entity behind it.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoDocker is a software tool. Docker Hub is a service. If Docker didn't stand up Docker Hub the equivalent services from GitHub, Google et al would have competed on a more even playing field.
- jehb 4y agoIt's almost like they created intentional ambiguity here when they renamed the company (dotCloud) to match the name of the open source tool, then renamed the open source project behind the tool to something else (Moby), but kept it for the command line tool, while also combining the name Docker into their product offerings, including Engine and Deskop, that handle completely different parts of managing containers. That's not even including registries, dockerfiles, Compose, Swarm, etc. and the ambiguity around where those sit in the a Venn diagram. That's some Google-level naming strategy there.
- mikepurvis 4y agoLots of orgs figure out how to piggy back the “service” part of whatever they’re doing on free or sponsored infrastructure, though. Homebrew, for example, has been doing a lot of the same stuff on Travis and GH Actions since forever.
- steveBK123 4y agoIt seems like another symptom of zirp/cheap money. Lots of ideas that could have been a neat feature or tool somehow ended up raising $500M of funding with no viable plan on ever monetizing. The fact that the product is successful but after a decade they barely make $50M/year of revenue against $500M of lifetime funding is crazy. As a user, you can work at a company with a billion in revenue and barely owe them a few thousand/year. Or you might just use Podman for free, and prefer it due some of the design differences. At the very least, a lot of these firms, with VC pressure, overstayed their welcome as private enterprises and should have sold themselves to a larger firm.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bydlocoder 4y agoSome time ago I learned that Postman Labs that produces a nice but not-a-rocket-science HTTP client raised $433M at multi-billion valuation and has 500 employees. Isn't it astonishing?
- nine_k 4y agoPostman's strength is not in the HTTP client part. It is in the SaaS part, ad I think their valuation (even though overblown) mostly reflects their corporate penetration and the willingness of many companies to pay a small amount for their services.
- bydlocoder 4y agoThe SaaS part being the offering for creating developer.acme.com type pages?
- nine_k 4y agoNo. Centralizing and sharing your API descriptions, test suites and plans, the various ad-hoc queries people usually keep in their notes or on Slack (and lose), handling involved auth stuff which is a hassle with curl, etc. I think they gravitate towards the same area as swagger.io or stoplight.io, but from the direction of using the existing APIs.
- jzb 4y agoIndeed. Docker should've been plumbing. They could've had a really nice business with developer tools on top of the core bits, but they decided to try to jump straight to enterprise and did a number of things to alienate partners and their broader community. Instead of adding value to Docker they're just trying to find the right knobs to twist to force people into paying. And I think people should pay for value when they're using Docker substantially for business. But it seems like a very short-minded play for cash disregarding their long-term relationship with users and customers. All that said: They have to find revenue to continue development of all the things people do like. I'd encourage people to ask if the things they've gotten for free do in fact have value, and if that's the case, maybe disregard the ham-fistedness and pony up if possible.
- streetcat1 4y agowhat do you mean "demand profit"? Last time I check rent is not free, food is not free, bus ticket is not free. No reason why software should be free. Open source was invented by big co as a "marginalized your complement" strategy, not the ideal that is marketed as. As an evidence, I do not see any cloud vendor open source their code?
- vorpalhex 4y ago> Open source was invented by big co as a "marginalized your complement" strategy, not the ideal that is marketed as. > In 1983, Richard Stallman launched the GNU Project to write a complete operating system free from constraints on use of its source code. Particular incidents that motivated this include a case where an annoying printer couldn't be fixed because the source code was withheld from users. from https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_free_and_open-source_software https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_free_and_open-sou... > Last time I check rent is not free, food is not free, bus ticket is not free. No reason why software should be free. You are welcome to sell your software. You are welcome to be replaced if you can't compete. You don't have to sell your software and we don't have to buy it. You can and will be competed with. Trying to build a multimillion dollar venture off a UI - even a good UI - is probably unwise. It does not seem to be going well for Docker who has gone from no competitors to multiple and all of those competitors are open source.
- IncRnd 4y agoFrom your very link, 1983's GNU Project was not the first piece of Open Source software. From your link: The first example of free and open-source software is believed to be the A-2 system, developed at the UNIVAC division of Remington Rand in 1953
- vorpalhex 4y ago> Software was not considered copyrightable before the 1974 US Commission on New Technological Uses of Copyrighted Works (CONTU) decided that "computer programs, to the extent that they embody an author's original creation, are proper subject matter of copyright" FOSS before 1974 looks.. funny. It existed! But it did not look like the modern FOSS movement. Even post 1974 and pre-GNU, FOSS-ish text editors and such existed. This was still the era when licenses were often non-standard and frequently did not exist. Handing your friend a copy of a program was the norm, regardless the actual legal situation (which itself was probably vague and unspecified).
- kajaktum 4y ago> Instead it has a multi-million dollar company behind it, and VC's who demand profits from a thing that shouldn't have ever had a business plan. But you don't have to host curl? Who's gonna put the money to host all the images and bandwidths that ten of thousands of companies use but never pay?
- londons_explore 4y agoIt could have been designed with a self-host option or a torrent/ipfs backend for near-zero hosting costs and still be 'just works' for the user.
- bmurphy1976 4y agoEven dumber, it should have just been pointers to encrypted files hosted on any arbitrary web server.
- npn 4y agopretty sure you haven't used ipfs before. for users to download resources from ifps you either need to install the client (which quite resource intensive) or use the gateways (which is just a server and cost money to run). also the speed and reliability are nowhere good enough for serious works.
- lyind 4y agoTHIS! Alternatives: - Virtual registry that builds and caches image chains on-demand, locally - Maybe a free protocol like Bit Torrent to store and transfer the images
- codexb 4y agoYeah, but curl is used to access and download all sorts of data, which are all hosted by multi-million dollar companies. Just like git downloads and uploads data to git repositories. curl and git are valuable, but so is GitHub, and websites in general. The problem is that they haven't found a way to monetize docker hub.
- krmboya 4y agoThe VCs offered free bandwidth and storage to gain market share. Bandwidth and storage is not ultimately not free, it has to be paid for.
- ollien 4y agoFWIW, Docker was not intended originally to be a tool for commercialization; it grew out of dotCloud, which open sourced the tool as a last-ditch-effort of sorts, if memory serves.
- waynesonfire 4y agoYeah! I should be able to get 50x value from software and not pay for it /s The open source community that carrier Docker on its back and is now bending over. Let this be a lesson to you. If you're building open source, maybe stick to open source solutions in your tech stack and if it's not there build it. This is what Apache does for the Java ecosystem. I don't have sympathy, the writing was on the wall and this isn't the first time it's happened to the community.
- yencabulator 4y ago> If you're building open source, maybe stick to open source solutions in your tech stack and if it's not there build it. This is what Apache does for the Java ecosystem. You mean this Apache: https://github.com/apache https://github.com/apache ?
- ihucos 4y agoComing trough: https://github.com/ihucos/plash https://github.com/ihucos/plash 90% done and useful
- wslh 4y agoYes, even when it was launched was obvious because used they packaged and configured existing solutions. It was like a company behind 'ls' (irony).
- 0xbadcafebee 4y agoDocker was created by dotCloud for a different purpose than it ended up as. I think they are owed credit for what has become an incredibly elegant solution to many problems, and how great the user experience has always been. Compare it to other corporate-managed tools like Terraform and Ansible. Both of them have horrible UX and really bad design decisions. Both make me hate doing my job, yet you can't not use them because they're so popular your company will standardize on them anyway. Docker, on the other hand, is a relative joy to use. It remains simple, intuitive, effective, and full of features, yet never seems to suffer from bloat. It just works well, on all platforms. There were a few years of pain on different platforms, but now it's rock solid. And to be fair to them, their Moby project is pretty solidly open-source, and if Docker Inc dies, the project will continue.