15 ms·
Elixir: Docker now charges open source orgs $300
- foepys 4y agoIn an ideal world every project had its own registry. Those centralized registries/package managers that are baked into tools are one of the reasons why hijacking namespaces (and typos of them) is even possible and so bad. Externalizing hosting costs to other parties is very attractive but if you are truly open source you can tell everybody to build the packages themselves from source and provide a script (or in this case a large Dockerfile) for that. No hosting of binary images necessary for small projects. Especially since a lot of open source projects are not used by other OSS but by large organizations I don't see the need to burden others with the costs for these businesses. Spinning this into "Docker hates Open Source" is absolutely missing the point. Linux distributions figured out decades ago that universities are willing to help out with decentralized distribution of their binaries. Why shouldn't this work for other essential OSS as well?
- adql 4y agoThat's one reason I like Go's model of "import is just an URL path" Sure it has some problems but it's far preferable than to be slaved to single entity controlling repo
- bioemerl 4y agoWe need some sort of system that's both distributed (anyone can host) and centralized (one url for a download that doesn't require someone to keep a server up with an ssl certificate needing monthly renewal until the end of time). We also need to set it up so that the default is that your server using the project also helps host the stuff it needs to run.
- AlchemistCamp 4y agoDocker’s not obligated to host open source, but they sure worked hard to convince open source projects to jump on their free offerings in their earlier years. I can definitely understand how it could be frustrating for project maintainers.
- orbz 4y agoI’m more worried about the second order impacts here: what about all the container files that referenced these open source images? I imagine there are a lot more of those than those pushed to DockerHub.
- j45 4y agoMy hope is the last versions are frozen in place and new versions require the updated accounts. It’s a gentle way to not break peoples setups and instead alter them to it needing to be updated.
- nickjj 4y agoI don't understand why there's so much backlash on this. Let's be honest here. Docker has been directly involved with creating a container runtime and has provided this for free with no strings attached for about 10 years. They've also hosted Docker images on the Docker Hub for free this whole time. Using Docker's runtime and official images are still free for everyone after this change. Now they are removing some of the free bits for hosting repos for teams but at the same time they offer a form you can fill out to continue to get free hosting for open source projects https://www.docker.com/community/open-source/application/ https://www.docker.com/community/open-source/application/. Why didn't Jose fill out this form? We've all benefited from Docker and in my opinion their pricing strategy is pretty reasonable around team licenses. I mean you could be a $500 million dollar company with 100 developers and end up paying about $10,000 for the year on Docker Desktop licenses, meanwhile your payroll on those devs will be like $20,000,000.
- insertnamehere_ 4y ago[flagged]
- girvo 4y agoYou’d be right if Docker Desktop wasn’t still the first class way to get Linux containers with nice file mapping/networking/etc. on Windows and macOS. I do not miss the days of running my own Xhyve based virtual machine and all of the pain and horrible performance that came with it.
- toyg 4y agoDocker Desktop is not that valuable, docker exploded before that even existed. In fact, it's probably the easiest bit of Docker to clone. The real value is in the repository, dockerfiles, and the deployment practices they enabled.
- girvo 4y agoDocker Desktop is absolutely valuable. It might seem easy to clone, and yet Rancher/Podman Desktops aren’t even close to feature parity and the deep integration with other tools that Docker Desktop has, sadly. Not yet anyway. I’m hopeful these dumb decisions light some fires under some bums to get that work done.
- favaq 4y agoCharging for a hosting service is now being "actively hostile". Talk about entitlement.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ajsnigrutin 4y agoIt is, if you offer a free tier for some, to get momentum and passive advertising, and then push them off your platform. I understand companies have to make money, but imagine if gmail started charging all of their users for email, while probably a billion of people has all their accounts tied to that address.
- rvense 4y agoThere was a lot of theories in the early days that this is what Google would do, as I recall. I'm actually sad they didn't. Imagine what the world would look like if gmail (and Facebook) had cost a dollar or three per month, though. The companies' incentives would be completely different, and we'd maybe have some actual competition in those spaces.
- insertnamehere_ 4y ago[flagged]
- counttheforks 4y ago[flagged]
- insertnamehere_ 4y ago[flagged]
- counttheforks 4y agoNo, it's using those features to provide a convenient to use tool to bundle applications. Sure, you can reinvent the wheel. Have fun.
- insertnamehere_ 4y ago[flagged]
- dang 4y agoPlease don't respond to a bad comment by breaking the site guidelines yourself. That only makes things worse. We've banned the other account, but it's not ok to break the site guidelines regardless of how someone else is behaving. If you'd please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stick to the rules when posting here, we'd appreciate it.
- counttheforks 4y agoYou should clarify which site guidelines were broken. Just pointing at a bulleted list and handwaving "Dont break the rules!" is not very helpful. Thanks. Also, the word here is "guidelines". Maybe rename them to "rules" if you are going to enforce them? Reading through them, it seems you are breaking at least one of them yourself here: > Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work. A good critical comment teaches us something.
- josevalim 4y agoI was not expecting this to make Hacker News, so before I come out as being entitled (hey, perhaps I am!), I think it is worth adding some context now that I have more characters. First of all: yes, I agree, it is completely fine if Docker wants to charge for this. As it is completely fine for me to be frustrated with the unclear communication around this (there is a HN discussion on it [1]). The biggest issue is: I actually won't be affected by this. I don't use images from Docker Hub, the community does. Any large open source community has likely asked, at some point, for Docker Images and they are the ones to be affected. And in a month (or not, the messaging has been unclear), they may find their deployments pipelines broken. Any company that depends on Docker Hub images should be triple checking their Dockerfiles right now because they may need to update them within a month. Others have mentioned Docker for open source projects [2], but the terms are, honestly, very disappointing. If you have any prospect of making any money, regardless of the amount, then you are automatically rejected. And most open source projects take several years (if ever) to become profitable (for Elixir, that took about 6-7 years). Again, they don't have to provide an open source grant, but I also don't have to pretend the grant will be useful to most. I can (thankfully) afford the yearly fee but I am drawing a line at paying for distributing the software I write for free (and another line on the extremely limited open source grant application). Have a good one. :) [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35154025 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35154025 [2]: https://www.docker.com/community/open-source/application/ https://www.docker.com/community/open-source/application/
- xcdzvyn 4y agoThanks for Elixir buddy.
- weatherlight 4y agoDefinitely an argument for URL based registries/imports. This is bad, has Docker responded to any of this yet?
- tinus_hn 4y agoGlad I decided quite a while ago that Docker is a licensing mess I don’t want to touch with a ten feet pole.
- snapplebobapple 4y agoIt was always weird to me that we let the index and the source stay co-mingled for so long, as it just built up technical debt that is now coming due because docker's profitability isn't what it was expecting.