5 ms·
>But we were incredibly lucky that IT is the most amazing productivity cheat code humanity has come up with so far, so that all this BS was accepted as the cost
by coldtea 4y ago
>But we were incredibly lucky that IT is the most amazing productivity cheat code humanity has come up with so far, so that all this BS was accepted as the cost of doing business.
Aren't you seeing it backwards? Other professions should have the same "luxuries", in a humane working world. Instead people are treated like cattle.
IT being an "amazing productivity" boost, means those "divas" you describe just get small part of the value they create, especially since a heck of a lot of the rest ends as unprecedented profit levels...
Under a capitalistic labour market theory, employees are not and can't be "overpaid" (and surely not for decades on end). They are paid exactly what they are worth, as price is based on supply and demand equilibrium.
Under a marxist labour market theory employees still can't be overpaid if the company makes a profit on top of what it would re-invest in itself (infrastructure, etc.).
So, under neither theory workers can be overpaid under any normal circumstances.
At worst, under capitalism there can be a higher market rate that gets adjusted to a lower one, but at each point in time none of those was "overpaid", it was the best the market knew to set. The higher rate was appropriate supply-and-demand-wise for when it was applied (and it might raise again as IT companies compete for developers, and so on).
Let's not forget the "US/Europe needs X millions more developers" reports churned out every few months...
- saiya-jin 4y agoIf US/EU get just a significant fraction of those developers needed, software dev salaries will go to the level of other engineering, say mechanical, construction or material one. Employers would be very happy with that. And lets be honest here, its not that different job despite what some bigger egos think about their work and echo chambers that keep them in that dream. I don't agree those other engineers are treated as cattle, merely as normal employees. IT, mostly in SV and other places cargo-culting ie Google is often really treated like divas. Bear in mind that this was never true in corporations where IT was treated as a cost center, ie banking. But from various HN posts it seems that typical young SV dev has no experience with that and many feel they are changing the world for the better, when reality its at best a zero sum game, and often not even that (ie optimizing ad revenue stream for your corporation is definitely loss for mankind as a whole, or anything that makes societal parasites who breed depression like facebook/insta/tiktok more effective at their goals). But folks for some obscure reason need to feel that their work has a good purpose and high moral ground, hence sometimes quite advanced mental gymnastics seen also here.
- galangalalgol 4y agoAs you hint, incredible demand for full stack developers created high salaries at businesses that viewed that as their core product. Businesses that built things that had software mostly kept paying what they always had. That voracious demand seemed to feed on itself a bit and grow on its own. When times got rough those businesses asked themselves if they were getting the expected roi on all those positions, and if they could be more efficient and do almost as well with fewer heads. They apparently decided they could. I don't find that surprising, software isn't infinitely improvable. Once you have a product done and refined, there simply becomes less to do over time. If the hours spent maintaining a site never decrease from initial development levels, you are doing something wrong.
- cj 4y agoFor any curious re: software vs. mechanical engineer salaries: Software: https://www.bls.gov/oes/current/oes151252.htm https://www.bls.gov/oes/current/oes151252.htm Mechanical: https://www.bls.gov/oes/current/oes172141.htm https://www.bls.gov/oes/current/oes172141.htm The 75th percentile for Software is $151k vs. $120k for Mechanical. Median is $120k vs. $95k. So about 20% higher for Software. I would have expected the difference to be higher based on levels.fyi and anecdotal salaries shared on HN. I guess the average software engineer also isn't working for a top 5 tech company who pay well above average.
- 908B64B197 4y ago> IT, mostly in SV and other places cargo-culting ie Google is often really treated like divas. Bear in mind that this was never true in corporations where IT was treated as a cost center, ie banking. It's interesting to look at fintech, where banks purchase tech focused company with great engineers because their internal IT simply can't compete thanks to a cost-center culture. Any industry that doesn't have a regulatory moat around it has tech circling it, looking for the parts of the business with the biggest margins. Even Amazon and Apple are timidly entering highly regulated markets such as health.
- joenot443 4y agoAs someone who spends every day in a state of the art FAANG office, I don’t think anyone deserves or needs this level of comfort. I think it’s wasteful and unnecessary. I can make my own coffee, I don’t need on-site baristas doing it for me.
- coldtea 4y agoYou don't need fancy baristas and exotic blends, but cafeterias with people making coffee for workers has been a thing in offices and even factories for a century or so, it's not some unique privilege...
- humanrebar 4y agoOK, but the costs aren't coming from fancy coffee. They come from salaries of engineers. So the question is really about how many employees there are and how much those employees are paid. And maybe, secondarily, how many facilities are needed to provide space for a certain employee headcount.
- pydry 4y agoWhen those benefits get stripped, the savings won't be used to feed the hungry or the homeless. It'll get capitalized into equity values or profits raked in by the 0.1%.
- coldtea 4y agoAnd the baristas will be out of a job
- insane_dreamer 4y agoOk but cutting benefits just means that baristas are out of work and more $ goes into the pockets of billionaire shareholders who need it even less than you. The only reason those perks exist is because of the unfathomable amounts of profit those companies make compared to others.
- larksimian 4y ago
- drdrek 4y agoThis is just academic gymnastics. If market conditions dictate that a worker produces 10 dollars in value so you hire people for 9 dollars, and then the value of their production is reduced to 7 dollars you need to fire someone. In the real world there is uncertainty in the projected value their work (if it can even be measured, and not taking into account non economic consideration). So someone can be overpaid for a while until it is discovered, at least in the way most people think about the meaning of overpaid.
- sharemywin 4y agoLet's not forget what makes those amazing profits. 1. very copyright friendly regulations, EULAs 2. poor data privacy, transportability/migration regulations 3. Section 230 4. lack of good antitrust laws - especially in market places and advertising markets. 5. and lets not forget the complete anti-union sentiment and lack of "professionals" to unionize I forgot about the complexity of stock options and transparency around compensation. Imagine if startups had to disclose as much as a franchise or mlms regrading how the compensation works. public funded research that's given away to "tech" companies Tax incentives with no strings attached. universities that provide the labor force for the companies to cherry pick the best from figure out whether someone should swipe left or scroll up. This was almost cathartic.
- RajT88 4y agoMight be covered by your bullet points, but is worth bringing up: - Shady licensing practices - Dark software patterns
- sharemywin 4y agoI think the general idea would be poor customer/user bargaining. we have regulations from lobbyists, industry bureaucrats and corrupt politicians(usually legally). or choose another provider with exactly the same shitty terms. because why invest in a consumer friendly platform except to gain network effects and change the terms of service.
- eastbound 4y ago> 5. and lets not forget the complete anti-union sentiment and lack of "professionals" to unionize I would hate for my bonus to be negotiated by the union. Generally the union gets a new funding and the employee get 14,89€ a year as a “hard environment” bonus. In fact I used to work in a unionized company as a developer, and not only there was groupthink, but the groupthink was bullying the weaker elements. And as developers, we’re all socially inept, so the weaker elements were most people except the union. Worst working conditions ever, it was ATOS in France.