3 ms·
This reads like a Smalltalk hype-man (like the guys hyping a rapper) - I think I've read this guy before on ST topics. The "secret weapon" angle dismisses lang
by coldtea 4y ago
This reads like a Smalltalk hype-man (like the guys hyping a rapper) - I think I've read this guy before on ST topics.
The "secret weapon" angle dismisses languages in wide use for all kinds of superficial reasons that didn't hurt major adoption across startups, unicorns, and huge companies like Google and Amazon.
e.g.:
"Python has many peculiarities in its design, especially with respect to object-oriented programming. Its multithreading capability is crippled by the GIL (global interpreter lock). Its lambdas are oddly restricted to single expressions. Its half-open intervals are unintuitive"
"Java is extremely verbose. It’s more awkward to use than Python. C# is Java on steroids."
etc.
while sidestepping major Smalltalk issues - first and foremost the lack of a wide and mature ecosystem of libs and a non-frequently-breaking-compatibility FOSS Smalltalk, or the lack of programmers to hire.
- DeathArrow 4y agoWell, he probably is an Smalltalk evangelist but I don't see this as something bad. "The secret weapon" I think makes reference to Paul Graham's essay Beating the average: http://www.paulgraham.com/avg.html http://www.paulgraham.com/avg.html and he probably thinks that Smalltalk gives the same kind of "unfair advantage" as Lisp did in Paul Graham's article. According to some studies, Smalltalk seems to be very productive: https://www.cincomsmalltalk.com/main/2022/07/need-productivity-smalltalk-is-the-most-productive-programming-language/ https://www.cincomsmalltalk.com/main/2022/07/need-productivi... http://www.ifpug.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/IYSM.-Thirty-years-of-IFPUG.-Software-Economics-and-Function-Point-Metrics-Capers-Jones.pdf http://www.ifpug.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/IYSM.-Thirty...
- znpy 4y ago> According to some studies, Smalltalk seems to be very productive: https://www.cincomsmalltalk.com/main/2022/07/need-productivi https://www.cincomsmalltalk.com/main/2022/07/need-productivi... In fairness however, Cincom develops and dells a commercial/proprietary Smalltalk implementation... you'll hardly see somebody saying "yeah our software is a pile of garbage" in their product/company website.
- nickd2001 4y agoHaving done some Smalltalk development, I can confirm for certain sorts of problems e:g complex engineering problems where the data model is inherently very complex, Smalltalk can really help to the point of being game-changing and allowing people to even attack certain problems at all in the first place. But Smalltalk's image-based dev, and lack of integration with the rest of the ecosystem, really hinders too! Smalltalk is both a blessing and a curse. I'd say for most companies Smalltalk doesn't give an advantage because most companies aren't actually solving problems that are all that complex. Its specific niche problems Smalltalk is good at. And even then, you'd have to do without things like numpy or scipy, i:e other languages have better more powerful libraries at your disposal. You could kind of cobble things together, get Smalltalk to call out to other languages to use their libraries, but that does start to get messy. One thing I would still use Smalltalk for would be pure computer science research. Its good for modelling things.
- brabel 4y ago> complex engineering problems where the data model is inherently very complex, Smalltalk can really help Interesting, what are the features of smalltalk that make that possible? Wouldn't it be very similar to JS or Lisp for representing data?? Also, given its dynamic nature, doesn't it make very hard to wrap your head around complex code bases after they grow beyond what you can keep in your head at the same time (as any other dynamically typed language)?
- rbanffy 4y agoThe way you model systems in ST, with objects and messages being passed between them, matches some physical models very closely.
- nickd2001 4y agoThis. And also Smalltalk is so succinct and has simple syntax, that one can "see the wood for the trees" when dealing with an inherently complex data model. I am unfraid for example of a long multi-pronged inheritance hierarchy of classes in Smalltalk, as its still reasonably easy to see what's going on, and there isn't a huge amount of code, whereas in other languages that'd be a nightmare. Java is notorious for that but actually that'd be bad in Python too
- coldtea 4y ago>Well, he probably is an Smalltalk evangelist but I don't see this as something bad Surely, not bad. Smalltalk could use far more adoption again! But in his case, he isn't also giving the full unbiased picture, so it's more of a "marketing man/evangelist" than an "objective adopter/evangelist"...
- cutler 4y agoWhat's often overlooked is that Viaweb was developed, as I recall, in the late 90s when the Internet was in its infancy and there were far less libraries than we have today which made hand-rolling everything in Common Lisp more viable.
- wirrbel 4y agoI really like Smalltalk but basically he fails to explain what the added value of Smalltalk would be over Python as a baseline. GIL is inconvenient but the times I was really limited by it are few. Lambdas are not Smalltalk blocks, but you can just define a local function and refer to it by name. This is like a block, the only thing you need to do is to bind the block to a name. Indentation-based syntax is not everyones preference (even not mine), but not using indentation is not a super power. What I would say is a primary selling point of Smalltalk to this day is the seamless development experience with Class Browser/Editor/Playground/TestExecution.