3 ms·
> I provide event study evidence that within 500 ft, for every 10% increase in the housing stock, rents decrease by 1%; and for every 10% increase in the condo
by crazygringo 4y ago
> I provide event study evidence that within 500 ft, for every 10% increase in the housing stock, rents decrease by 1%; and for every 10% increase in the condo stock, condo sales prices decrease by 0.9%.
This is... a silly thing to examine. 500 ft is nothing. A 10% increase in a 500 ft area is a tiny, tiny, tiny increase in the NYC housing stock overall.
The cause and effect between housing stock and rents operates at a combination of city level and large neighborhood level mainly. When people shop for an apartment they're usually considering lots of neighborhoods, not a tiny 500 ft area.
Anything you observe at the 500 ft level is more likely than not to just be noise.
Also the HN title is wrong, because it sounds like it's a universal law, when the study is meant to be about a certain snapshot of NYC only.
- dylan604 4y agoyeah, but in NYC, isn't 500ft considered a spacious 2-bedroom condo?
- tzs 4y agoTerminology: a "row" is the buildings on one side of 1 block of an ~E/W street in Manhattan. A 500 ft radius circle around an apartment building in the middle of a row in Manhattan includes about 6 full rows and and about half of 2 more rows, so about 7 rows worth of buildings total. That seems like it would include enough buildings to see more than just noise.
- crazygringo 4y agoIt's not about the number of apartments being sampled, it's about the cause and effect happening at a larger scale, not the local scale. In other words, rents changing in a 500 ft area is due to housing stock changing citywide. Not housing stock changing within 500 ft. The noise I referred to isn't the noise of statistical measurement, it's that housing stock within 500 ft is mostly random noise when compared to the change in stock citywide.
- foogazi 4y agoIsn’t real estate local ? How much housing stock increase do you get from a new condo building near the train station or the local elementary? Or multiple ADUs on a desirable neighborhood?
- crazygringo 4y agoIn NYC people will often or usually be considering multiple entire neighborhoods when apartment hunting. They'll be weighing trade offs of the locations with trade offs of the specific apartments available at the moment. Very few people pick a tiny area and then only look for availability within it. That's just not how the city works.