3 ms·
There's another implication of this. It looks like the next generation of search will require a login.
by Animats 4y ago
There's another implication of this. It looks like the next generation of search will require a login.
- mtlmtlmtlmtl 4y agoFuck that. Not worth it imo. I already know how to search. I find 90% of what I'm looking for via good old google before bing would have even finished generating. The rest is more complicated stuff that involves multiple queries and finding lots of stuff within a more general area, sorting and prioritising, reading it. Basically in depth research. I feel like I actually learn more doing the research the hard way than I would having an AI do it. And I definitely do a better job at it
- jdironman 4y agoAnd that's implying Google won't eventually follow that same model.
- mtlmtlmtlmtl 4y agoIf push comes to shove I'll throw together my own using whatever open source search/scrape stuff is out thereif I have to. Probably be better than anything because I can brutally cut down what I'm scraping to my needs.
- dredmorbius 4y agoI think you're precisely correct, and I can't emphasize this point enough. People talk about their various breaking points with Google, and several threads on the recent Google Reader shutdown 10-year anniversary post discusses these. For me, the turning point was Gmail. BG, Before Gmail, Google Web Search (GWS) was a utility you used without identifying who you were. Yes, there were IP tracking and cookies, but those were reasonably loose fits. AG, After Gmail, GWS for many people was something that was fully personalised. Not only were your searches associated with your email address, but often with a Real Names identity. This seemed a dark turn for me, and I resisted getting a Gmail address for years on account of that. (I've since acquired ... several, though I use them exceedingly infrequently now, and have cleared out most associated information.) But even in the AG era, you could use GWS without authenticating. Or through proxies such as StartPage. Around 2013 I'd switched to DuckDuckGo (DDG), which is (mostly) a Bing proxy, based on its privacy assurances. I'm now wondering what impacts Microsoft's Sydney / GPT-Bing transition will have for DDG moving forward. And what opportunities for anonymous and/or pseudonymous use of GPT / AI chatbot (is there a more graceful term for these yet?) might be. I was an extreme early adopter of Google. I've yet to use ChatGPT or similar tools given that they all appear to require authentication. That's not the future I'd been working for. Yonatan Zunger, an ex-Googler who was chief architect of that company's social and identity platform, Google+, recently landed at Microsoft as "corporate vice president and chief technology officer of identity and network access". <https://www.crn.com/news/cloud/microsoft-recruits-top-twitter-google-engineer-for-security-role https://www.crn.com/news/cloud/microsoft-recruits-top-twitte...> He's made cogent observations on forced disclosure in the past. I'm hoping he'd be highly sensitive to the concerns you and I are raising here. (I've contacted him concerning your comment.)