4 ms·
An interesting idea, but to pull yet more parallels from Ender's Game: what about emotional trauma when they see something they invented / inspired used to kill
by Groxx 15y ago
An interesting idea, but to pull yet more parallels from Ender's Game: what about emotional trauma when they see something they invented / inspired used to kill people? Can they sue the government? Will there be any repercussions?
As much as I'd like to believe they won't be working on projects like that, I think it's quite literally impossible to make that claim. A better armor idea may become a more-penetrating bullet idea. Is there such a thing as a purely-defensive technology?
- simonsarris 15y ago> Is there such a thing as a purely-defensive technology? I think that most medical technologies, at the least, can be considered purely defensive. Ie, a mobile defibrillator or penecillin. Then again, inventions like spray-on bandages increase the effectiveness of an army, which would aid in offensives. But I think the inventor of any such spray-on bandage would agree that the benefits to humanity outweigh the fact that armies can march a little longer with the invention. So I think there's probably a large class of inventions that have humanitarian uses that "outweigh" the military ones from a general conscious perspective. Spray-on banadages, canned food (which may have allowed Napolean to conduct more and greater expeditions than he would otherwise), etc. Aside, there have been many purely war-motivated or wartime-motivated inventions that have gone on to aid the public at large. (See for instance the history of the tampon, or the history of canned food).
- Groxx 15y agoSpray-on bandages rely on aerosoling a drying, congealing liquid which hardens quickly. I fail to see how that core tech can't be slightly adapted to do something harmful. Penicillin isn't really an invention, nor is it a technology, but we are capable of biological warfare because we know about cellular structures and resistances. Mobile defibrillators are essentially tasers without a propellant and barbs. --- There are definitely cases where I'd argue something made for war has done more good than harm. Lots of them, even. But I didn't invent those things - how does the inventor feel about it all? If your accounting software turned out to have a unique algorithm that made it easier to keep ammo supplies available on a battlefield, resulting in a few thousand more deaths, how would you feel about it? What if it were tens of thousands? More?
- rdouble 15y agoI'm not sure there would be any emotional trauma. Historically, engineers have tended towards being amoral about building weapons. Even Da Vinci was designing trebuchets and selling himself as a defense technician.
- epochwolf 15y ago> I'm not sure there would be any emotional trauma. I'm pretty sure I will be. I work with a former Boeing employee. Him and a number of coworkers were absolutely devastated that aircraft they sold where used to kill people. Granted, it's a small number of data points but I would be pretty upset knowing something I designed killed people.
- anthonyb 15y agoReally? If you help design a military plane, it's going to be used to kill people at some point, surely? Seems a bit odd that you wouldn't be prepared for that.
- Groxx 15y agoWhat if you designed a cargo plane, or engines for commercial jets, which ended up being / being on bombers? Boeing doesn't just make military planes. Or a simpler case: what about those who made planes that got hijacked, maybe even flown into buildings?
- anthonyb 15y agoSure, but we're talking in the context of engineers and defence technology. Boeing is a large military contractor, so there's not much question that the work that you do for Boeing as an engineer working on planes is going to be used by the military.
- Groxx 15y agoThe one explicit context to this whole thread is this: >... one of the directors of the program, Dale Dougherty, was quick to point out that the students will not be building weapons for the military. The only place I can see actual weapon-engineer context is in rdouble's example - elsewhere there's been plenty of room for non-weapon interpretation. "Military plane" came out of nowhere, except that Boeing makes them, as well as many other non-military planes. It even seems reasonable to me to think that Boeing makes more commercial products (and employs more making them), so an average Boeing engineer may simply never touch or create tech for the military. I have no numbers to that effect though, so I could be off. But why would there be 'not much question' that a 7X7-line engineer would have worked on a military plane?