4 ms·
Linux obviously gets a lot more attention but it's also more fast with new features and possible exploits. BSD maintainers are fast fixing known exploits but h
by wkat4242 4y ago
Linux obviously gets a lot more attention but it's also more fast with new features and possible exploits.
BSD maintainers are fast fixing known exploits but has the drawback of older tech like X11. Wayland works on FreeBSD but still doesn't work with KDE on it.
- thewataccount 4y agoTBH Wayland is rocky on linux too from my experience. It's really hit or miss with applications especially electron ones. I think electron natively supports wayland without adding a flag now? The issue is most applications don't use that version yet. Both me and my friend installed wayland on a fresh arch install and we both had issues with random "black boxes" on electron applications. Games are also very hit or miss. IDK it's just felt very half baked. And this was with Gnome which my understanding should have very decent wayland support?
- freedomben 4y agoInteresting, I've been running Wayland (Fedora) for years now and the only issues I've ever had were application compatibility (rather than bugs). Screen sharing is the big one. Which GPU do you have? Wayland on nvidia is definitely more buggy than wayland on AMD and Intel, so if you run nvidia that could definitely be a factor.
- petepete 4y agoEven screen sharing is mostly solved now. I do it daily without issue on Fedora with Wayland. The only thing concession I need to make is running Slack in a browser tab instead of the app, because the app comes with an older version of Electron.
- prmoustache 4y agoYes most electron apps can be replaced by their browser counterparts without loss of any feature and wayland works great on the browsers. I don't even understand why electron exists to be honest, there is no added value.
- NavinF 4y agoThere are a million edge cases that don't work in the browser. System wide hotkeys (Eg push to talk), screen sharing with audio, etc.
- prmoustache 4y agoYou are speaking of millions but I have yet to encounter one. And I would say missing one feature I am unlikely to use is a small price to pay for more control of my privacy, advertising, telemetry, hardware and OS access.
- officeplant 4y agoI've come to enjoy just keeping to apps browser counter parts because they usually work better and can be resized however I want as a window.
- prmoustache 4y agoWhat prevents you to resize your browser window? The fact you make it run within a browser don't mean you can't run it in a separate window. The only good point I can think of is having a separate icon for the app in an alt+tab situation. But in my case I use the activities view on Gnome and usually view and recognize the window content. Also epiphany browser allows me to create "apps" with their own icon. Sadly not all of them work due to user agent nazism.
- officeplant 4y ago>What prevents you to resize your browser window? I'm talking about how electron apps prevent you from a wider range of window resizing
- thewataccount 4y agoIndeed we both have 4090's so that might explain the issue. It sucks that nvidia is more buggy in general on linux because they're currently the only realistic* option for working with a bunch of ML stuff. * Yes ROCM is gaining support, but it's still trailing behind CUDA unfortunately and you can't beat the 4090/3090 for ML in the consumer range right now.
- bee_rider 4y agoSway worked pretty well in general for me, except Zoom didn’t play nice with it at all. Zoom is bad, but then, I wouldn’t be using it if I wasn’t paid to use it.
- JohnFen 4y ago> has the drawback of older tech like X11. Not everyone considers that a drawback.
- wkat4242 4y agoNeither do I for that matter. But we were talking about security and there's no denying that X11's architecture has inherent security risks. You can cover this in other ways but security wise I do consider it a drawback. However in most other ways I do prefer X over Wayland too.
- JohnFen 4y agoYes, the need to take extra steps to lock things down is the biggest downside. I'd love to see a replacement for X that retains X's feature set but that is more secure by default (and more performant would be nice). The thing that keeps me off the Wayland train is that they are not intending to support X's remote features, which I use quite heavily. I'm unaware of any other way to do simultaneous independent remote DE logins.
- wkat4242 4y agoSame here, I totally agree with you there. SSHing into a remote box and having a GUI app popping up on my local screen without any fiddling is just amazing. It's not very performant because it was designed for local networks and relies on too many round-trips. NX fixes that but it's too fiddly. Also you really need to trust your remote box because it'll be able to see and control all your screens. It can do this even without popping up any user visible windows so be careful. For this reason I don't blanket enable it, I just use the -Y parameter only when I need it. But yes I'd love to see something that continues on this path and brings it into the 21st century.