3 ms·
About 1-2% of GDP each year could have cut global warming in half over the last 50 years. That’s a monumental amount of resources but wouldn’t have had a parti
by Retric 4y ago
About 1-2% of GDP each year could have cut global warming in half over the last 50 years.
That’s a monumental amount of resources but wouldn’t have had a particularly noticeable lifestyle impact. We would likely have had more nuclear accidents, but those are really local events.
The path was basically eliminating coal, home heating oil, plus drastically reducing oil use by adding in road electrical power delivery for cars. The specific implementation would have depended on massive R&D plus either carbon taxes/banning coal, or larger nuclear subsidies.
- pif 4y ago> About 1-2% of GDP In economic terms, 1-2% of GDP is the difference between a year worth celebrating and a shitty one. OK, I exaggerated a bit, but it is absolutely not negligible over a couple of years, and a catastrophe over 50 years.
- Retric 4y agoYou lose 1% GDP not 1% GDP growth rate per year. Basically you get one bad year, and every year after that you don’t notice the difference. Much like how our military spending is a lot of money but you only notice when it changes. The economy might even be larger today if we had gone down that path because of increased efficiency and cleaner air.
- TomSwirly 4y agoYour argument is this: "Rather than give up 2% of our income, we should condemn all our descendants for the rest of time to a blighted ecosystem." > a catastrophe over 50 years. It is a palpable obscenity for you to use the word "catastrophe" to refer to a 2% decrease in the GDP but not for the complete devastation of our biosphere. I heard a theory once that only a certain number of human souls were ever created, and after that, a lot of people got born with partial souls or no souls at all. I found it charming but unconvincing, but sometimes I wonder...