4 ms·
Right. Without a bailout, each customer would have $250K today (if they had that much n deposit) and probably another 10-20% this week, as assets were sold off
by Animats 4y ago
Right.
Without a bailout, each customer would have $250K today (if they had that much n deposit) and probably another 10-20% this week, as assets were sold off. The FDIC could have worked a deal so that depositors were paid off in a few weeks, but in Treasury bonds with 5-10 years to maturity, to match the maturities of SVB assets. Depositors who really had to could sell their bonds immediately at a discount. That would have given time to liquidate SVB's loan portfolio. Depositors probably would have lost 5%-20%.
- Waterluvian 4y ago> Depositors who really had to could sell their bonds immediately at a discount. How does this kind of thing function? I assume the bank pools all the money and buys various investment products. Is there just another wild level of abstraction where"you own X% of this investment product. Feel free to sell your share to someone else" ?
- Animats 4y agoThe normal FDIC procedure would be that depositors get receivership certificates which represent a share of SVB's assets. Those are hard to trade, though. Somebody would offer to buy them, but at a deep discount. A better offer from the FDIC would be to offer Treasury bonds instead to those who want them, at a discount based on the FDIC's valuation of SVB's assets. The FDIC is well placed to sell off illiquid assets slowly. That's what they do after a bank failure. Depositors would have quick liquidity if they wanted, but it would cost them something. Is SVB's balance sheet, from the FDIC, out yet?
- Waterluvian 4y agoAhh okay. So the FDIC is doing that big government thing of acting collectively in everyone's interest, I suppose? Instead of everyone getting their piece of the frozen pie, starving as it thaws (possibly having to sell it at a steep loss of degrees to the radian), the FDIC just says, "I'll hold on to the whole pie and hand out slices from my backup pie stash. Then once it thaws, I'll add it to my backup pie stash."
- nerdponx 4y agoI think they are also rebuilding the backup pie stash by charging everyone a slightly bigger slice of pie than before.
- steve76 4y ago[dead]
- FormerBandmate 4y agoThere would have also been massive bank runs. Check out regional bank stocks, tons of them were down 30% this morning for no reason and a lot are still down. The rich panicked, which destroyed Washington Mutual and Wachovia in 08 and caused both the Great Recession and Great Depression
- david927 4y ago> for no reason For reason. This is far from over.
- epistasis 4y agoThe only thing we have to fear is fear itself! Bank runs are quite often a crisis of unreason, and I think this one is mostly caused by poor communication. The contagion effect is as much a mental virus as it is an assessment of liquidity.
- pas 4y agoIt's kind of obvious from this that either deposits should be guaranteed by law (because in practice FDIC does that now anyway) or the law has to prohibit banks from investing deposits (unless the account holder instructs the banks to do so, of course).
- anon291 4y agoOkay well banks are not owed existence. If the banks went out of business give the deposit holders the choice of holding the underlying assets or the choice of selling them on the market. If you held the same portfolio as the bond, you too would not be able to withdraw at full face value. You are believing a lie if you think a ten million dollar deposit can be immediately withdrawn anywhere in its entirety.
- kevingadd 4y agoStartups were in fact able to withdraw large amounts of money from SVB. That's why it collapsed, they did this to the tune of 42 billion, and lots of the pending transfers completed.