5 ms·
The US doesn't have database copyright, but some countries, including the entire European Union, do.[1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Database_right https:
by Animats 4y ago
The US doesn't have database copyright, but some countries, including the entire European Union, do.[1]
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Database_right https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Database_right
- mx20 4y agoInteresting. That could be a huge disadvantage for the EU and it's companies that want to use AI and also often can't give their Data to third parties. But I am not sure a neural net is even considered a DB. Because when this was created they clearly had structured Information accessed by people in mind. There has to be some distinction otherwise I make a db that stores digits of PI in a file and if you publish part of it, that is considered substantial enough, you are infringing on my DB rights.
- hgsgm 4y agoIf I copy your database, that violates copyright. I generate the same data using my own process, it doesn't. That's different from creative works where it's implausible to claim that you created the same work independently of someone else.
- amoss 4y agoThose protections rely on "systematic arrangement", i.e. that some effort has been put into finding, verifying and collection a set of facts / individual pieces of data. It is not obvious that would apply to the set of weights that come out of a training algorithm. (standard I'm not a lawyer, I don't know but I suspect it is unclear enough that it would need to be argued in court).
- sdenton4 4y agoI assure you that if you scramble the weights of a neutral networks, the model will perform poorly... Training something new cost millions of dollars in accelerator and research salary, and evaluation ('verifying') is a big part of the work.
- amoss 4y agoThis is true, but not currently relevant. The cost (difficulty) of training does not indicate how good a fit the model is for copyright protection. I suspect that part of the arguing this out in court will be making those economic arguments as part of an attempt to extend copyright protection to model weights - but that is a separate issue from if they are protected currently. Part of the economic argument for copyright is to encourage the investment of time into producing new works, so it may be a persuasive argument for extending protection. Although (relatively) recent history suggests that persuasive argument is not as powerful as giant wads of cold hard cash in extending copyright coverage.