3 ms·
In my humble opinion some home NAS use cases are beneficially converted to Thunderbolt. It's a lot more practical than the faster varieties of ethernet. If you
by jeffbee 4y ago
In my humble opinion some home NAS use cases are beneficially converted to Thunderbolt. It's a lot more practical than the faster varieties of ethernet. If you have two hosts that need fast access to the NAS you can do it with TB4, and one of those hosts can re-export the stored resources for applications with lesser performance requirements, over SMB or iSCSI or whatever.
- rektide 4y ago40Gbps host-to-host networking in thunderbolt/usb4 is so epic & great to have.
- jjoonathan 4y agoDoes someone make a thunderbolt -> thunderbolt connector that exposes an ethernet PCIe endpoint to each host and forwards packets between them? 10 years ago I joked that someone should do this, but I thought high speed ethernet would trickle down and obviate the need. Evidently not, lol.
- jeffbee 4y agoIP-over-Thunderbolt is a thing. It's the thing we are discussing! All major operating systems can do it.
- jjoonathan 4y agoI didn't know you could just connect two thunderbolt hosts and get a network interface. Amazing! Ok, so now I need to find a small cheap computer with a thunderbolt port or two and lots of NVMe.
- jjoonathan 4y agoYeah, but then the primary host inherits the uptime requirements of a NAS and this gets really awkward when you have workflows in different operating systems that both want to use the fast storage. Both OSes can access thunderbolt, of course, but only one can be a good server. Now that I've experienced the separation of concerns that comes from an independent NAS I do not want to go back.
- jeffbee 4y agoWhich host have you nominated as "primary" in this scenario? I'm only thinking of the TB4 link as a relatively cheap and simple point-to-point networking link. I think it's a lot more practical, and cheaper, that 25gbps ethernet. A dual-port 25gb ethernet NIC costs hundreds of dollars, while you can find all kinds of cheap computers with 2 TB4 ports.
- jjoonathan 4y agoThe host connected to the NVMe storage.