3 ms·
But certain arguments do favor the proponent, even if they do not appear to. For example, I'm irreligious, so I should be in support of the world becoming reli
by petercooper 18y ago
But certain arguments do favor the proponent, even if they do not appear to.
For example, I'm irreligious, so I should be in support of the world becoming religion free, right? I'm not. I know that I don't need it, but I think people, generally, are not morally enlightened enough to deal with a world without religion.. ergo, I want it to stick around!
I guess this is a bit like a master criminal being in support of more policing because they think they can get away with it while lesser crooks are put off by the extra policing. I believe this sort of reasoning is quite common - but it goes against your pattern, I think.
- markessien 18y agoYes, but in your examples, even though the argument on the surface seems to be against you, in actuality, you are making an argument that benefits you. Just so there is no wandering from my main argument - what I am saying is that everytime we read one of these 'controversial' argument, the opinion of the article writer is almost always an opinion that directly benefits him or some group he identifies with. Rarely do we get a controversial article where the person discovers something that turns out to be totally against what he is or stands for.
- ars 18y agoThat's not actually true. What happens in such a case is an author write about how he discovered something and changed. If you discover something that is against what you stand for, almost everyone will change to match it. So you'll never see someone say: look I found this, but I won't do it. Instead you'll see someone say: look I was a, but I found b, and now I'm b. And you certainly see plenty of that.