4 ms·
Did he rape, kill or physically assault any American citizen? Was he selling drugs to children? No? Well then we had no right to extradite him. Law enforcemen
by ck2 15y ago
Did he rape, kill or physically assault any American citizen? Was he selling drugs to children?
No? Well then we had no right to extradite him.
Law enforcement is created by society to protect PEOPLE not corporations.
- badclient 15y agoLaw enforcement is created by society to protect PEOPLE not corporations. So, are you arguing that corporations should not be protected or that law should protect him or both?
- muyuu 15y agoNot overriding other countries' legal systems.
- mato 15y agoIANAL, but it doesn't work that way. See specifically sections 7 and 11 of the Extradition Act 1999 (http://www.legislation.govt.nz/act/public/1999/0055/latest/whole.html#DLM25689 http://www.legislation.govt.nz/act/public/1999/0055/latest/w...). Further, the Extradition Treaty between NZ and the US ( http://newzealand.usembassy.gov/uploads/images/o16y8MOyHW2l-jJTxaMpeQ/ExtraditionUSNZ.pdf http://newzealand.usembassy.gov/uploads/images/o16y8MOyHW2l-...), Article V, which states: "Neither of the Contracting Parties shall be bound to deliver up its own citizens under this Treaty, but the executive authority of each shall have the power to deliver them up, if, in its discretion, it be deemed proper to do so." So there's a bilateral opt-out for both parties, at least in the case where their own citizens are involved.
- muyuu 15y agoThe problem with that is the asymmetry between the US and New Zealand in terms of power and trade. Having both parts being able to opt-out effectively means that the smaller part will be free to do exactly as they're told, or else. I hope New Zealand deals with this case and does so fairly and ignoring external pressure. Sadly, this looks unlikely.
- adestefan 15y agoNew Zealand has a history of standing up to the US, especially its military. See the fallout from declaring NZ a nuclear free zone which forced the dissolution of the ANZUS military treaty between the US and NZ.
- brown9-2 15y agoHow does an extradition take place if the host country doesn't agree to let it happen? They had to give consent. Their police conducted the raid.
- nodata 15y agoCorporations count as people don't they?
- runn1ng 15y agoHe stole other people's work and made business out of it. You are not magically allowed to steal* from corporations. *I personally don't classify downloading other people's work as stealing, but building a huge business from it is totally different matter. And it's totally not the point of the article, anyway.
- gameshot911 15y ago>I personally don't classify downloading other people's work as stealing, but building a huge business from it is totally different matter. You should though, because the two are just different shades of the same color. Downloading other people's work = benefiting from their work without their permission. Building a huge business = benefiting from their work without their permission on a larger scale.
- InclinedPlane 15y agoIf I hear a song on the radio I'm benefiting from the artists work without paying. If I record a song off the radio then sell copies of it to other people I am doing something entirely different.
- robotresearcher 15y agoYou are paying for the ads that support the radio station when you buy any advertised product or donate to a political campaign that buys ads. The radio station pays to play the song. You are paying artists to listen to their music on the radio.
- InclinedPlane 15y agoAnd if I skip the ads or if the ads never influence me to buy anything, then what?
- runn1ng 15y agoYou can't do it ad absurdum, though, and have to put the line somewhere. That reminds me - in one Czech Onion-like fake news, there was an article about the architect union collecting money from every person who looks at buildings; the more buildings you see, the more you will pay. You just have to draw the line somewhere and I think that pirating for personal use is fine. I think it's reasonable to say that pirating for personal, non-commercial use (even when "non-commercial" is always vaguely defined) is fine.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]