4 ms·
British industry calls for regulation of autonomous vehicles
- kneebonian 4y agoLike I get where this is coming from, but given the UK's history with technology I feel like this will just end up retarding the growth of Self Driving technology in the UK. Also there's this little gem buried in the bottom of the article > Lisa Johnson, UK director of public affairs for Starship Technologies, said the company would welcome regulation, ...“There needs to be some sort of national regulation that underpins all decisions because we have invested a lot of time and energy in our safety case. If we don't have regulation, what's to stop somebody coming into the market who isn't as safe as us? ... And we don't want a free for all,” she said. And there's the push for this, a corporation already in the UK that wants to ensure that there are regulations to "keep people safe" (a.k.a keep competitors out.) and yes I understand regulation can be good and helpful, but regulatory capture can be an insidious b*h
- dazc 4y agoI would also welcome legislation since their robots operate on public pavements which were originally designed for human beings to safely walk on without having to navigate around motorized vehicles. I would start with banning these things from all public pavements.
- ChatGTP 4y agoHonest question here, who really wants / needs autonomous cars so badly ? I feel like this is a real Silicon Valley mission, I’m not so sure the rest of the world gives much of a toss about it?
- fomine3 4y agoLet's count how many cars run in worldwide
- TheLoafOfBread 4y agoI guess Silicon Valley would be screaming something about disruption if they would have come with something resembling ETCS. But they did not, so they pretend that trains does not exist.
- localplume 4y ago[dead]
- sebzim4500 4y agoOver a million people die annually in car accidents. At minimum, their families probably care a fair bit about it so that's quite a lot of people right there.
- vorpalhex 4y ago1. Senior citizens 2. Truckers 3. People reliant on public transport 4. Everyone else on the road who appreciates being alive 5. People who would like less traffic 6. People who drive long stretches in remote areas
- scratcheee 4y ago7. People wanting to get home from the pub legally and safely at 3am.
- ChatGTP 4y agoYou can't do that now?
- Balero 4y agoMany of these people would be better served by having better funded public transit, especially in densely populated areas. This would 1. help the elderly have more freedom. 3. help people who already use public transport. 4,5. It would make roads safer and allow for less space being used for private vehicles which makes the remaining spaces safer. Improving intercity and freight rail can also help many people in category 6 who can now do something productive or fun on the train rather than risk driving long distance, and can take some long distance freight off of roads. The only people who need to have private vehicles are those would live in rural locations, who would still benefit from traveling to a more distant urban area, and people who's jobs demand it such as tradies (trades people). These would all be served by having less people on the roads when they don't need to be.
- vorpalhex 4y agoPublic transit doesn't run enough. In Japan, which has one of the most functional train systems in existence, staying out late (and not even very late!) means paying for a hotel room or post-drinking room (they serve you snacks and wash your clothes, etc). This is in Tokyo. Public transportation can't replace private vehicles. It can help. It can be useful. It can't replace them. It's like trying to replace traditional powerplants with wind - it doesn't work.
- AlotOfReading 4y agoNot everything has to be a cure for cancer. Things can just be cool tech. But autonomous vehicles do solve some real issues as well. Many of the women in my life have full on PTSD about certain aspects of driving. There are days they struggle to get themselves to work. Autonomous vehicles are a drop-in solution for that, with better safety and privacy than Uber/Lyft. Some people would say that better public transit would also solve this, but those people have never done infrastructure advocacy in the US. A moonshot like autonomous vehicles has a genuinely better likelihood of existing for most people in the US than effective public transit. They're also a potentially safer and more enjoyable solution to the non-joy driving many people do daily. There's no need for those miles to be done by humans who are distracted by other concerns. Companies also really want it to exist. Pretty much everyone with a large delivery program is in talks with one or more AV companies to automate their shipping. It's going to become a significant part of the industry as soon as the costs are competitive.
- TheLoafOfBread 4y ago> with better safety and privacy than Uber/Lyft. LOL if you really believe that. Self driving cars will be connected to cloud with camera pointed on you the whole ride. Reasoning for this will be simple - people are pigs without a bit of a care for property of others when they are not supervised
- AlotOfReading 4y agoVirtually every Uber already has one or more cameras inside to monitor the passenger. It's even a feature of the driver app to do this with the phone on the dashboard. Companies like Google have far better track records with their internal privacy controls than random Uber drivers and I'm at least somewhat hopeful that US lawmakers will get their act together on regulating the use of the data. As for safety, have you ever been in an Uber? Waymo at least is already meeting that bar.
- smcl 4y agoI personally don't care about it too much - I'd much rather see greater investment in public transport. But there's some interest in the UK - there's a driverless service across the Forth that keeps popping into the news (https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-scotland-edinburgh-east-fife-64350096 https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-scotland-edinburgh-east-fife-643...) and I'd be surprised if there wasn't some activity going on in academia around autonomous/driverless
- rtkwe 4y agoPersonally I'd love to be able to just relax on longer road trips rather than driving. Taking the 2 hour trip back to my parent's neck of the woods is much less annoying if I don't have to drive it too.
- LatteLazy 4y agoThe UK cannot regulate an international market. That is down to major players like the US and EU.
- mindracer 4y agoThis is about regulating the UK
- sebzim4500 4y agoThe UK can absolute regulate what cars are allowed to be sold in the UK.
- rtkwe 4y agoTheir point is the UK is too small of a market by itself. I have some doubts about that analysis though given California effectively drives so much of the US car market and it's 30 million people smaller than the UK in terms of raw population, though it's also roughly even in terms of car sales each year.
- dakial1 4y agoPeople commenting that UK can't force big manufacturers to adapt to their regulations seem to forget that they drive in the right side of the car. Pretty big adaptation there no?
- SilverBirch 4y agoI think you're missing the implicit point - car manufacturers operate on massive scale and razor thin margins. So you have 4 real options - 1. Massively deregulate, in which case the UK might be a good place for R&D but still not for manufacturing (disadvantageous tariffs to their largest export markets and a second tier domestic market, cars exported would be designed to meet foreign standards anyway). 2. Regulate about the same as other key markets, this is what you'd normally do by default as a country, you get decent safety standards, but costs will be high, because the automotive manufacturers will design for major markets, not the UK, so they'll see extra costs associated with UK regulatory compliance, but all products sold in the UK will match EU standards anyway. 3. Just adopt EU standards. It makes operating in the UK cheap for automotive companies, you can use it to argue for tariff reductions with the EU, but a small group of psychopaths in the UK parliament will collapse the entire government and economy. 4. Have higher standards than elsewhere, likely locking the larger manufacturers out of the UK market entirely, opening the door for smaller, higher cost niche manufacturers, but significantly slowing adoption. Obviously number 3 is the economically advantageous option, but the politically advantageous option is to loudly claim you're doing option 1, whilst in reality doing option 3.
- glumreaper 4y agoThere has been a UK Code of Practice since 2019, PAS 1881:2020 and PAS 1883:2020. Companies like Oxbotica are already assessed under these standards. See https://www.oxbotica.com/insight/oxbotica-achieves-safety-landmark-with-autonomous-vehicle-assessment/ https://www.oxbotica.com/insight/oxbotica-achieves-safety-la...