3 ms·
I would be a lot more impressed by people who make arguments that are rationally correct, but that do not favour them. I've been arguing for a long time that u
by cperciva 18y ago
I would be a lot more impressed by people who make arguments that are rationally correct, but that do not favour them.
I've been arguing for a long time that universities should take fewer students and technical training schools should be expanded. Given that I hope to end up with a faculty position at a university, I'd say that this isn't a position which particularly favours me.
It's like people who argue for Eugenics - their version of Eugenics never involves them or their friends/family being cut out from the genetic pool.
I wouldn't argue for cutting myself out of the gene pool, since I think the genes I have which are responsible for my intellect are worth keeping (both of my parents have doctorates, so I think it's safe to say that there's a strong genetic component in my case); but there is strong evidence that I have genes which predispose for autoimmune conditions, and if I'm ever in a position to have children I'd strongly support using genetic testing to eliminate zygotes with those genes.
- markessien 18y agoActually, the first argument favours you because then you would be one of a smaller elite. The second argument also favours you, because you don't want to be responsible for the caretaking of a sick child, and you don't want your offspring to have problems.
- cperciva 18y agoI guess if you look at things closely enough, anything I could ever argue for would favour me somehow. If I want to see more students in university, it favours me because I want to be hired to teach them; if I want fewer students, it favours me because I remain part of a smaller elite. If I think computer scientists should be paid more, it benefits me because I would earn more; if I think computer scientists should be paid less, it benefits me because it means that fewer people would enter the field and I'd have less competition. Somehow I get the feeling that we'd get more done if we stuck to arguing about policies rather than spending time dissecting the possible motives of their proponents.
- ced 18y agoboth of my parents have doctorates, so I think it's safe to say that there's a strong genetic component in my case Both of your parents have doctorates, so I think it's safe to say that there's a strong nurture component in your case.
- nostrademons 18y agoYou can't draw that conclusion unless he has an adopted sibling or a biological sibling that was put up for adoption. Normal unadopted children share both their genes and their environment with their parents. When studies have been done on identical twins raised apart, they've shown that genetics matters far more than parental environment, with genes being responsible for close to 40% of the variance in a wide array of personality traits, parental nurturing responsible for about 10%, and the child's peer group responsible for the remaining 50%.