3 ms·
> Maybe it's time for distributions to slim down considerably to the point where they really only contain everything that's needed for the system to run on its
by JoshTriplett 15y ago
> Maybe it's time for distributions to slim down considerably to the point where they really only contain everything that's needed for the system to run on its own.
> All end-user software (with all their dependencies - disk space is cheap nowadays) would then be installed directly from the vendors - as it's done on every other OS on the planet.
First of all, by "every other OS on the planet", you mean "the other two major desktop/laptop OSes", as opposed to all the major smartphone OSes where you normally install packages provided through a standardized packaging system.
And second of all, no, let's not switch from a system where every package has a nice uniform install process with automatic dependency handling to one where every vendor has their own "unique" way of doing things.
I'd argue that the various magic scripting language packaging systems exist to handle the OSes without sane package management, meaning OS X and Windows. Those languages wouldn't need gem, easy_install, or cpan if they could always count on apt or rpm. But once the scripting languages implement their own packaging system, it becomes painful to integrate with the distribution packaging systems, so they just say "screw it, ignore the distributions and install it yourself".
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- rsynnott 15y ago> I'd argue that the various magic scripting language packaging systems exist to handle the OSes without sane package management, meaning OS X and Windows. And you'd be wrong. For many languages, it is simply not feasible to rely on the OS maintainer to update repositories in a timely fashion. EDIT: Also, in practice, many applications have a dependency on a specific older version of a library.
- JoshTriplett 15y ago> For many languages, it is simply not feasible to rely on the OS maintainer to update repositories in a timely fashion I'd suggest s/languages/distributions/. Nothing stops a distribution from updating packages immediately after updates occur upstream, and many distributions do. If a distribution lets their packages for a language or particular module get out of date, report a bug. If the problem persists, sure, recommend that people install their own copy (or switch distributions), but don't automatically assume that no distribution could possibly keep up with your language. > Also, in practice, many applications have a dependency on a specific older version of a library. Consider improving your language to have a sensible shared-library versioning system, such as the SONAME system used for standard C-like shared libraries. (I hesitate to call SONAMEs entirely sensible, but they certainly solve the problem you mentioned.) In any case, consider fixing your application to work with the latest version, rather than delaying the inevitable.