I'm also a bit skeptical given they plan to commercialize this and refuse to release any real information about their fabrication process. Would not be the firs

I'm also a bit skeptical given they plan to commercialize this and refuse to release any real information about their fabrication process. Would not be the first breakthrough result that can't be replicated, and as the group has already tampered with data before it's not improbable that this is the case again, from a purely Bayesian point of view. If I was to make such a discovery I'd be hell-bent to have other labs reproduce it independently as fast as possible, as that would, with very high likelihood, earn me a Nobel prize. Not releasing any information about my wonder material because I might want to get a patent on it (which they probably already filed before publishing results anyway) seems just weird.