3 ms·
I stand by what I wrote. Science started when the scientific method started. The scientific method is a process for distinguishing facts from bullshit. The exp
by WalterBright 4y ago
I stand by what I wrote.
Science started when the scientific method started. The scientific method is a process for distinguishing facts from bullshit. The explosion in technology and science sprung from that. Endless age-old ideas crumbled away when the scientific method was applied to them.
Collecting and describing and organizing data is not science, although it enables science.
Further observations, of course, can be used to test and thereby support or disprove a hypothesis. The history of astronomy is a delightful exercise in hypotheses followed by more observations that separated truth from bullshit.
- basch 4y agoI can’t agree with this. You may be describing the formalization of science, but science was occurring well beyond the bound of the scientific method. Ancient science generally gets broken down into mathematics, astronomy, medicine, and material. If we skip right to medicine and material, there was a huge amount of recorded “knowledge” of chemicals that either functioned as medicine or manufacturing, dating back 5k years. The people absolutely knew “these combinations worked” but still didn’t completely distinguish chemistry from magic and ritual and God. There’s still science occurring there. Some combination of knowledge being applied and passed down through generations. There is precursor to our scientific method happening in parts, and it was still science.
- WalterBright 4y agoMathematics is not science, it's a tool used by science. Knowing combinations that work is not science, either, when it does not come with an explanation as to why it works that is able to successfully predict other combinations that work. Magic, ritual and God are not science because they have no predictive value. Precursors to science are not science. Just like hydrogen and oxygen are precursors to water, but are not water.
- bakuninsbart 4y agoThe exponential growth in knowledge output and technological advancement started before the formalization of the scientific method though. There's a variety of factors contributing to this, to name some: - Social mobility as a result of the Black Death - Excess agricultural output, leading to population growth and specialization - Wealth extracted from the Americas leading to a new class of Idles - Certain inventions, like the printing press, massively increasing knowledge retention and spread. Even more egregiously, this is a distinctly English view - neither the French nor the Germans have such a narrow view of science and at least until the late 1800s both had a higher scientific output than the English. This narrow view of science is ok if there is a positively-connotated word to describe the process of knowledge advancement, in English I guess that would be academia, although that is too narrow still. Without engineering and mathematics, science would have started to stagnate centuries ago - or never been formalized in the first place.