> I mean, if Amish people want to have a society where (in most Amish subcultures), women are essentially uneducated broodmares that aren't encouraged to do any

> I mean, if Amish people want to have a society where (in most Amish subcultures), women are essentially uneducated broodmares that aren't encouraged to do anything that conflicts with popping out babies... Is that really that much worse than how our broader culture needs to import truckloads of immigrants to maintain healthy population levels? ..huh? It’s not like the US is importing Amish from other countries, we’re allowing people who want to immigrate to work here (albeit too slowly). I don’t get this argument. > Amish Elder to assign you a nice Amish woman This is so far from my own beliefs in individual liberty I’m not sure how to engage frankly