3 ms·
That estimate is misleading as SV failed after people pulled 45 billion out. It wasn’t a 200 billion dollar bank when it failed and people didn’t lose 200 billi
by Retric 4y ago
That estimate is misleading as SV failed after people pulled 45 billion out. It wasn’t a 200 billion dollar bank when it failed and people didn’t lose 200 billion dollars.
We are at ~1.3 bank failures per month in 2023 which is much closer to 2020’s 0.3/month than 2009’s 11.7 banks failing per month. That IMO says more about the rest of the year than the size of the banks that failed.
- epgui 4y agoThe parent comment just made the point that you need to normalize for the size of the bank, not for the number of banks per year. Your comment takes the annual frequency and divides it by 12 to get an average monthly frequency, adding nothing to the argument of the grandparent comment.
- Retric 4y agoThey suggested you should normalize for the size of the bank but didn’t support it. They even used non inflation adjusted numbers. Maximum assets under control don’t correlate with actual losses especially when people pulled money out before the collapse. It’s a completely meaningless number on it’s own.
- phil21 4y agoCertainly very valid criticisms. To be fair, I specifically was trying to ballpark it and this graph does not contain the Signature failure yet so I think it is a fair representation of this particular metric. I also think it's a good point that a dollar is not necessarily equal to another dollar in this context. But the same can be said for individual banks as well.
- Retric 4y agoThat’s fair, I do think it’s reasonable to compare losses or the size of bailouts. But we just don’t have that info yet.